Japan Defence Forum

[Kai Liu]

A lost soul spotted...

Man, I am serious, don't be modest, Let me to explain to you:
You and lots of people like you on this forum are the strongest. You know what? You can bring US, Russia, Japan, UK, Germany, every country you name it, to destroy China, on this forum, with your mouth of course, because you don't belong to any of them... Haha...

 

[HannibalBarca]

By considering Japan as strong, which in our eyes is NOT

Japan is not strong...but not weak either...
But many here...put Japan defense capabilities to Zero in the region... That is something untrue and mostly stupid to think that way.

At least Chinese Gov is competent in that matter and do take Japan as a potential threat that could be difficult to play with when times come...

Man, I am serious, don't be modest, Let me to explain to you:
You and lots of people like you on this forum are the strongest. You know what? You can bring US, Russia, Japan, UK, Germany, every country you name it, to destroy China, on this forum, with your mouth of course, because you don't belong to any of them... Haha...

That is your opinion...not mine neither from others( like you pointed out)
And in anyway does make up for our Reality.

You can think everyone is against you...so be it. Reality is otherwise.

 

[terranMarine]

Japan is not strong...but not weak either...
But many here...put Japan defense capabilities to Zero in the region... That is something untrue and mostly stupid to think that way.

At least Chinese Gov is competent in that matter and do take Japan as a potential threat that could be difficult to play with when times come...

is not strong , is not weak now that's contradicting your own words. No wonder members view you as a complete fool. Make up your own mind, is Japan weak or strong versus China. Is Japan gonna survive a war with China? Is there anything left of Japan if China smashes dozens of MEGATONS on Japanese soil? Are there any Japs left after absorbing dozens of MEGATONS?

 

[Fledgingwings]

Japan cant afford to have a big neighbouring country as a foe.

 

[HannibalBarca]

is not strong , is not weak now that's contradicting your own words. No wonder members view you as a complete fool. Make up your own mind, is Japan weak or strong versus China. Is Japan gonna survive a war with China? Is there anything left of Japan if China smashes dozens of MEGATONS on Japanese soil? Are there any Japs left after absorbing dozens of MEGATONS?

Well...ofc when you see things as black and white...you can't see the inbtw...
But since you want to get an opinion on such matters...that, yourself can't be at peace with...then here it is...

- Japan is neither weak neither strong... since the right answer will be "Japan has weaknesses and strength"
- Will Japan survive a war with China if no nuclear weapons are used? Yes and No... if it happen we will see..;but she has some chances.
-Does Japan survive few nuclear strikes? No.

See... before jumping on your horses ...try to understand the subject... and no jumping on your Binary thinking...

Ps: the scenario is a 1v1... With no foreign help... If allies come... that will be another story for China.

 

[terranMarine]

Well...ofc when you see things as black and white...you can't see the inbtw...
But since you want to get an opinion on such matters...that, yourself can't be at peace with...then here it is...

- Japan is neither weak neither strong... since the right answer will be "Japan has weaknesses and strength"
- Will Japan survive a war with China if no nuclear weapons are used? Yes and No... if it happen we will see..;but she has some chances.
-Does Japan survive few nuclear strikes? No.

See... before jumping on your horses ...try to understand the subject... and no jumping on your Binary thinking...

Ps: the scenario is a 1v1... With no foreign help... If allies come... that will be another story for China.

Does Japan survive few nuclear strikes? No.
DONE, end of story. China has the capabilities to completely wipe out Japan. SAme applies to India, complete destruction. China is left standing.

 

[haidian]

Japan has serisou problems with 3 nuclear neighbors , Russia, China and N.Korea, the last one is trigger happy and eager to try their bombs in Japan. That's what put Japan in a very precarious position.

North Korea threatens Japan with 'nuclear clouds'
'No one knows when the touch-and-go situation will lead to a nuclear war, but if so, the Japanese archipelago will be engulfed in flames in a moment'

• Lucy Pasha-Robinson
• @lucypasha
• Wednesday 4 October 2017 10:54 BST

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...d-threat-kim-jong-un-shinzo-abe-a7982306.html

 

[HannibalBarca]

Does Japan survive few nuclear strikes? No.
DONE, end of story. China has the capabilities to completely wipe out Japan. SAme applies to India, complete destruction. China is left standing.

Yeah...like If China, will in an actual war...use Nuclear strikes when she is the one starting the war...
And no...Against India...both will fail... India has capabilities for deep strikes and vice versa... In a nuclear war btw IN/CN...both get destroying...that's a fact.

Anyway.

 

[vostok]

Japan lives in a world of illusions if she thinks that she owns part of the Russian territory.

 

[terranMarine]

Yeah...like If China, will in an actual war...use Nuclear strikes when she is the one starting the war...
And no...Against India...both will fail... India has capabilities for deep strikes and vice versa... In a nuclear war btw IN/CN...both get destroying...that's a fact.

Anyway.

India , first check the nuclear capabilities of the slumdog before jumping to wrong conclusions

Japan lives in a world of illusions if she thinks that she owns part of the Russian territory.

Japan wants the Kurils from Russia, wants Dokdo from South Korea. Is scared of China because of Diaoyu island.
Now the Communist block with DPRK having nukes, Japan is totally surrounded

 

[haidian]

Japan lives in a world of illusions if she thinks that she owns part of the Russian territory.

Those are Russian lands and Japan can never get even an inch of them.

 

[Martian2]

India , first check the nuclear capabilities of the slumdog before jumping to wrong conclusions



Japan wants the Kurils from Russia, wants Dokdo from South Korea. Is scared of China because of Diaoyu island.
Now the Communist block with DPRK having nukes, Japan is totally surrounded

Indians on PDF are incredibly ignorant.

China's THERMONUCLEAR (fusion) warhead: 5 MEGATONS on DF-5A ICBM
India's ATOMIC (fission) warhead: 0.02 megaton

Nuclear Weapons | Federation of American Scientists
"Based on seismic data, U.S. government sources and independent experts estimated the yield of the so-called [INDIAN] thermonuclear test in the range of 12-25 kilotons, as opposed to the 43-60 kiloton yield claimed by India. This lower yield raised skepticism about India's claims to have detonated a thermonuclear device."

India said it can only build two Agni-V missiles per year. China has plenty of mid-course GBI (ground based interceptors) to shoot down an Indian Agni-V.

China probably has its own version of Nike Hercules thermonuclear-tipped anti-missile missiles as a last line of defense.

The claim that India can hit a major Chinese city is ludicrous.

 

[terranMarine]

Indians on PDF are incredibly ignorant.

China's THERMONUCLEAR (fusion) warhead: 5 MEGATONS on DF-5A ICBM
India's ATOMIC (fission) warhead: 0.02 megaton

Nuclear Weapons | Federation of American Scientists
"Based on seismic data, U.S. government sources and independent experts estimated the yield of the so-called [INDIAN] thermonuclear test in the range of 12-25 kilotons, as opposed to the 43-60 kiloton yield claimed by India. This lower yield raised skepticism about India's claims to have detonated a thermonuclear device."

India said it can only build two Agni-V missiles per year. China has plenty of mid-course GBI (ground based interceptors) to shoot down an Indian Agni-V.

China probably has its own version of Nike Hercules thermonuclear-tipped anti-missile missiles as a last line of defense.

The claim that India can hit a major Chinese city is ludicrous.

Also should it manage to hit Beijing (hypothetically speaking), the PLA is gonna retaliate by completely wiping out India with plenty of DF-5 + DF-41 MEGATONS, just the thought of 50-60 Megatons spreading across all over India, everybody turning into charcoal gives me the chills. And China? It's still there on the map, comes out as the winner in the nuclear exchange. How can a puny nuclear power like India destroy China? When China retaliates, it's gonna be OVERKILL

 

[MultaniGuy]

Have you checked the calendar lately?

WWII was 1945. That's 73 years ago.

Today, China has Five MEGATON thermonuclear warheads on its DF-5A ICBM.

So, what's your point of bringing up WWII?

Will Japan ever have the chance to attack China? Does Japan want to exist anymore?

WWII was WWII. That's ancient history and it will never be repeated.

In today's world, Japan faces extinction if China decides to push the thermonuclear button.

Let me reiterate. Japan is not a major power.

Agreed with you, now the times have changed. It is China which has the upper hand here.

I believe that P*ki was trying to match the IQ of the slumdogs

Ignore the false flagger. All Pakistanis are pro Chinese.

Japan is no match for China militarily.

And China is the world's largest economy now.

 

[terranMarine]

http://www.g2mil.com/sasebo.htm

Naval base sitting duck for China's missiles