Is ‘Hindu’ our National Identity?

[Norwegian]

your grin says it all.

LOL

 

[wolfschanzze]

Why marriage and divorce laws are different when all indian have common identity of Hinduism? Why beef should be forbidden for Muslim when they love to eat it?

Those laws were changed by a politician for vote bank politics and eventually they will be scrapped and replaced by Uniform Civil Code.
Killing cows is prohibited as was written in our Constitution.You cannot change that.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

We will decide as Indians.

I do not think butchering cows should be allowed. It hurts 1 billion of us. Why should we allow it or our own soil?

There is nothing in muslim religious texts which says you have to eat beef. You like to eat is different.

And even if your religion says you have to eat, it goes against our sentiments and sensibilities. So we will outvote you on that. It is a democracy, and the common man counts. If push comes to shove, we will make each common Hindu man and woman count on what we cannot tolerate.

Hope that answers your question.

Personally I cannot tolerate 4 mother in laws as well. Just in case you want to know.

Your religion dictate your thinking and perception and those who dont follow your religion might not agree with your thinking. Uniform civil code is not possible when people dont agree over ceratin issue or personal laws and everyone should be free to live according to his/her beliefs and no one should have this right to impose his/her own like or dislike on others.

 

[doppelganger]

Your religion dictate your thinking and perception and those who dont follow your religion might not agree with your thinking. Uniform civil code is not posdible when people dont agree over ceratin issue or personal laws and everyone should be free to live according to his/her beliefs and no one should have this right to impose his/her own like or dislike on others

Uniform civil code should be the basic that all should be able to follow under their religion.

Islam says you are allowed to marry 4 women. It does not say you HAVE to marry 4 women.

India says you can only marry one at any given time.

How does it trample on your religion?

If you want the full breadth of what your religion allows, move to a country where the same may be exploited. Here you will get only one.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Those laws were changed by a politician for vote bank politics and eventually they will be scrapped and replaced by Uniform Civil Code.
Killing cows is prohibited as was written in our Constitution.You cannot change that.

So you expect from Indian Muslim to not go for nikkah and islmic divorce procedire and they should follow hindu inheritance laws, death rituals and adoption laws even when they are followers of Islam

 

[doppelganger]

So you expect from Indian Muslim to not go for nikkah and islmic divorce procedire and they should follow hindu inheritance laws, death rituals and adoption laws even when they are followers of Islam

You can do whatever procedure you want within Indian law. Only that part of the procedure per Indian Law will be allowed legal status. Rest you can do to feel good, for elders to feel good, etc. That's where it ends for the state.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Uniform civil code should be the basic that all should be able to follow under their religion.

Islam says you are allowed to marry 4 women. It does not say you HAVE to marry 4 women.

India says you can only marry one at any given time.

How does it trample on your religion?

If you want the full breadth of what your religion allows, move to a country where the same may be exploited. Here you will get only one.

You are idiot. Difference between Hindu and Muslim is not just three more wives for Muslims lol

Having four wives is not compulsory thing in islam. I was talking about different personal laws which people derive from their religion

 

[wolfschanzze]

So you expect from Indian Muslim to not go for nikkah and islmic divorce procedire and they should follow hindu inheritance, death rituals and adoption laws even when they are followers of Islam

In matters of Marriage(you can marry as per islamic ritual) and Inheritance(is a Civil court matter,not religious matter) other than that yes everyone will have the same laws.Death rituals are as per their wish.
Adoption laws are the same for everyone in India even now.

 

[doppelganger]

You are idiot.

Don't be a moron. I have answered your question with the biggest social impact point for India. There are others of course. All of which (divorce, woman's rights, etc.) will be per common India law.

We need to protect our muslim women.And hindu ones as well.

 

[wolfschanzze]

Law of India - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

What will be the source of this uniform civil code for inheritance ,adoption, marrige and divorce laws etc? Bhagvad geeta , Quran or Bible? Lol would butchering cow will be allowed under this uniform civil code

Butchering of cows is prohibited as per Constitution.
Just like you dont eat swines and you expect the rest of your nation to respect your sensibilities,the same thing here.

 

[doppelganger]

Butchering of cows is prohibited as per Constitution.
Just like you dont eat swines and you expect the rest of your nation to respect your sensibilities,the same thing here.

I think their Christians (mostly low caste fringe guys) are allowed to eat pigs. Many on outskirts of Islamabad. Come in from the forests and create havoc in the cities.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Butchering of cows is prohibited as per Constitution.
Just like you dont eat swines and you expect the rest of your nation to respect your sensibilities,the same thing here.

Your constitution is secular or based on hinduism?
For your kind information non muslim are allowed to eat pig or drink wine in islamic republic of Pakistan lol

 

[doppelganger]

Your constitution is secular or based on hinduism?

How is not being allowed to butcher cows going against any faith? Can you show me something from your book which says you have to eat beef otherwise you are not a good muslim?

Do you know that when the book was written, where it was written, there were now cows at all? Only camels, desert rats and lizards.

For your kind information non muslim are allowed to eat pig or drink wine in islamic republic of Pakistan lol

Thanks for confirming.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Don't be a moron. I have answered your question with the biggest social impact point for India. There are others of course. All of which (divorce, woman's rights, etc.) will be per common India law.

We need to protect our muslim women.And hindu ones as well.

Again you dont have any brain.. How their will be common Indian laws when source of personal laws is different for Hindus, Muslims and christians in India and their religion play huge role in their lives?

 

[doppelganger]

Again you dont have any brain.. How their will be common Indian laws when source of personal laws is different for Hindus, Muslims and christians in India and their religion play huge role in their lives?

You can do anything from your personal law as long as it does not go against the law of the land. Which comes first. Always.

Anything which does not go against the law of the land, but is also not as per the prescribed boundaries of the law of the land, can be done by any citizen in keeping with his personal faith, but will not have any legal or official state sanction or status.