What's new

Is China copying the old imperial Japan?

Joined
May 21, 2010
Messages
15,305
Reaction score
-21
Country
India
Location
United States
In the 1920s, Japan began to translate its growing economic might -- after a prior 50-year crash course in Western capitalism and industrialization -- into formidable military power.

At first, few of its possible rivals seemed to care. America and condescending European colonials did not quite believe that any Asian power could ever dare to threaten their own Pacific interests.

Japan had been a British ally and a partner of the democracies in World War I. Most of its engineering talent was trained in Britain and France. The West even declared Japan to be one of the "Big Five" world economic powers that shared common interests in peace, prosperity and global security.

Occasional parliamentary reforms had convinced many in the West that Japan's growing standard of living would eventually ensure cultural and political liberality.

That was a comforting dream, given that by the 1930s Americans were disillusioned over the cost of their recent intervention in the Great War in Europe. They were weary of overseas engagement and just wanted a return to normalcy. A terrible decade-long depression at home only added to the popular American desire for isolation from the world's problems.

Americans sympathized with China's security worries -- but not enough to do much other than hector Japanese military governments with haughty sermons about fair play and international law, and threaten to impose crippling embargoes.

Japan ignored such sanctimoniousness. Instead, it harangued its Asian neighbors on the evils of Western colonialism and the need for them to combine under Japan's own tutorship to reassert their Asian influence in world politics.

The League of Nations did nothing when Japan began colonizing Manchuria in 1931. Westerners seemed more impressed by the astonishing rate of Japanese economic progress and growing armed clout than they were determined to stop Japanese aggression.

By 1941, few Americans were even aware that the Imperial Japanese Navy had almost magically grown more powerful than the Pacific fleet of the United States in every category of battleships, carriers, cruisers, destroyers and submarines. The idea that Japan was waiting for an opportune moment to exploit American weakness, at a time when Europe was convulsed in war, would have seemed absurd to most Americans.

The 1940 American relocation of its Pacific Fleet home port from San Diego to an exposed Pearl Harbor was supposed to deter Japan. But the Japanese interpreted such muscle-flexing as empty braggadocio, if not more foolhardily symbolism.

The attack on Pearl Harbor followed.

Substitute communist China for imperial Japan, and the same thing is now occurring in the Pacific. China believes it is finally time to make its military reflect its enormous economic power.

Chinese armed forces are growing while America's are shrinking. China does not like visiting American blowhards -- most recently, Vice President Joe Biden -- lecturing them on human rights, especially when American power, both military and economic, appears to be waning.

If the Japanese of the 1930s once talked of Western decadence and American frivolity, so too the Chinese now sense that American global influence is not being earned by the current generation of Americans that enjoys the high life on $17 trillion in borrowed money, much of it from China.

China likewise senses growing American isolationism, hears parlor talk about the U.S. reducing its nuclear arsenal, and notices America's new habit of distancing itself from allies.

Americans once talked tough about Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria. But China tuned out that empty rhetoric and instead noted that we abandoned Iraq after the successful surge, are exhausted by Afghanistan, were humiliated by Bashar Assad in Syria, and were seemingly paid back with Benghazi after removing Muammar Gadhafi in Libya. China is reassured that what America says and what America does are not quite the same things.

More importantly, the Chinese also appear to hate the Japanese in the same way the latter apparently despised the former in the 1930s. China resents Japan's undeniable lack of contrition over the approximately 15 million Chinese killed by Japanese aggression in World War II. The Chinese also sense that Japan may be a has-been power, with an aging, shrinking population; energy woes; a sluggish, deflationary economy; and increasingly without its once ubiquitous American patron at its side.

China accepts that the U.N., like the old League of Nations, is useless in solving global tensions, and prefers that it is so.

Add everything up and China seems about as confident of the future as Japan once was in the 1930s. It is as eager to teach Japan a lesson, as Japan once did China.

America once again appears confused by these radical changes in the Pacific. That is, until someone in the region tries something stupid -- once again.

Is China copying the old imperial Japan? - chicagotribune.com
 
.
Nope, it is Japan who wants to go back to the Imperial Japan of the old days.

Just look how the anti-Abe movement in Japan thinks about.

680-1c6T7m.St.138.jpeg

abechaplin.jpg

japan_secrecy_law_shinzo_abe_hitler.jpg
 
. .
The author is stupid. I can't believe he is a historian at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University. That article is full of his own opinions. The dude had the nerve to put his mug before the article haha.
 
.
Nope, it is Japan who wants to go back to the Imperial Japan of the old days.

Just look how the anti-Abe movement in Japan thinks about.

680-1c6T7m.St.138.jpeg

abechaplin.jpg

japan_secrecy_law_shinzo_abe_hitler.jpg


Why are they using Nazi pictures? Japan was in that war, they could have just used Hirohito, Tojo or any of the other imperial japan uniforms.


As to copying Japan, the author does know the year 1900 means at least 1900 years have past since that time. China has been an unstoppable juggernaut for more than 2000 years and he's saying we are copying Japan? We have our own history much grander than anything Japan can ever do.

In fact first mention of Japan was in the late book of Han of CHINA, by that time 800 years of Zhou, 400 years of Han has already past, and China was well established as the dominate power in east Asia, matched only by India and Rome, and then unmatched again as Rome and India broke apart.

The first mention was the Wa people a barbaric people with 100 tribes ruled by a woman. That was Japan, by the time of Three kingdoms, China was scientifically advanced, and militarily unstoppable, all surrounding kingdoms not only paid tribute but has has a Han commander at the helm of their government to make decisions.

While Japan had no words until they learned Chinese.
 
.
Why are they using Nazi pictures? Japan was in that war, they could have just used Hirohito, Tojo or any of the other imperial japan uniforms.


As to copying Japan, the author does know the year 1900 means at least 1900 years have past since that time. China has been an unstoppable juggernaut for more than 2000 years and he's saying we are copying Japan? We have our own history much grander than anything Japan can ever do.

In fact first mention of Japan was in the late book of Han of CHINA, by that time 800 years of Zhou, 400 years of Han has already past, and China was well established as the dominate power in east Asia, matched only by India and Rome, and then unmatched again as Rome and India broke apart.

The first mention was the Wa people a barbaric people with 100 tribes ruled by a woman. That was Japan, by the time of Three kingdoms, China was scientifically advanced, and militarily unstoppable, all surrounding kingdoms not only paid tribute but has has a Han commander at the helm of their government to make decisions.

While Japan had no words until they learned Chinese.

Because Nazi is more famous in the western world, thus it will give a stronger impression to the westerners.

Those Japanese citizens want to tell the world that their country has elected a fascist PM.
 
.
If today China was planning to invade and occupy the Korean Peninsula and Japan,If China was planning to invade and occupy the whole of ASEAN(perhaps save Thailand),If China was planning to butcher and make slaves of tens,even hundreds of millions of people in those regions,and if China was planning to invade parts of India、Outer Mongolia、Russia and the US,yes,then China might be copying the old imperial Japan。
 
.
I guess China always want to revenge the Japanese ...

Nope, it is Japan who wants to go back to the Imperial Japan of the old days.

Just look how the anti-Abe movement in Japan thinks about.

680-1c6T7m.St.138.jpeg

He looks great, the artist done a good job !!!
 
Last edited:
. .
Because Nazi is more famous in the western world, thus it will give a stronger impression to the westerners.

Those Japanese citizens want to tell the world that their country has elected a fascist PM.

You forget that Japanese PM resigns very often ... so only picture modifications tell nothing.
At least, Japanese people could vote to another party with different opinion ...

China and Vietnam still have to give all the trust to the Communism Party ...
 
. .
You forget that Japanese PM resigns very often ... so only picture modifications tell nothing.
At least, Japanese people could vote to another party with different opinion ...

China and Vietnam still have to give all the trust to the Communism Party ...

Because we can only trust the Communist Party, we had the pro-West government in the past, but they fcked everything and made our life a hellhole.
 
.
to be frank, I see the author has some researches not only be First in First out like many guys here !!!
 
. .
Because we can only trust the Communist Party, we had the pro-West government in the past, but they fcked everything and made our life a hellhole.

If there's 1 option, you never know the term "vote" or "choice".
Same to us ... ( Vietnam )

Btw how many Communism party members in China, pal ?
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom