Is China copying the old imperial Japan?

[ChineseTiger1986]

If there's 1 option, you never know the term "vote" or "choice".
Same to us ... ( Vietnam )

Btw how many Communism party members in China, pal ?

About 80 million membership.

The Communist Party is not perfect, but they are still the best choice for China.

Same for you Vietnam, if you have the western "democracy", then you will end up like Thailand right now.

 

[BoQ77]

We have nothing to do with Nazism ...

The National Socialist German Workers' Party (German: Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (help·info), abbreviated NSDAP), commonly known in English as the Nazi Party, was a political party in Germany active between 1920 and 1945. Its predecessor, the German Workers' Party (DAP), existed from 1919 to 1920. The term Nazi is German and stems from Nationalsozialist,[5] due to the pronunciation of Latin -tion- as -tsion- in German (rather than -shon- as it is in English), with German Z being pronounced as 'ts'.

Actually, I see the similar character between Nazi and China, and Emperial Japan ... and also North of Korea ...
You are extremely nationalism, ...
Nazi shared the Socialism and Nationalism ... with China ...

And Japan, Nazi, China ... ever occupy and threaten others

About 80 million membership.

The Communist Party is not perfect, but they are still the best choice for China.

Same for you Vietnam, if you have the western "democracy", then you will end up like Thailand right now.

I've been to Thailand several times ... I wish we could be like Thailand.
Can dream only, it takes at least 20 years for Vietnam to be at the same level

Communism memberships in Vietnam is about 3.6 million ... about 4% of population

 

[Genesis]

You forget that Japanese PM resigns very often ... so only picture modifications tell nothing.
At least, Japanese people could vote to another party with different opinion ...

China and Vietnam still have to give all the trust to the Communism Party ...

I thought you being Vietnamese would give you some insight into one party system, are you really Vietnamese?

American democracy doesn't mean 2 different systems, if Romney was elected instead, the direction America will go will not differ very much, there will be some but not too much.

One party system can have way larger changes look at China, great leap forward, to cultural revolution, opening up China to today another leap towards free market with a trial at Shanghai.


Communist party is open to ALL VIETNAMESE AND CHINESE, Communist party has no permanent leaders, communist party has internal blocs.

For example, Li keqiang has been dubbed the farmer bloc with emphasis on the rural community while Xi is of the business bloc that focuses on business development that drives Chinese growth.

How is this not different party, elections happen same as America, the two blocs fight it out for control of party, in US it's republicans and democrats, in China it is these two and possibly more.

True American public get the final say, but believe me, that choice is not as important as you might think, it basically leaves somethings in the air, if a weak but popular president get elected, like Obama, he will be limited at every turn because he is democratic president, all the major organs of the country don't have to listen to him, he is the mouth, the face, not the brain or the heart.


I won't get anymore detailed due to the size of this topic, but please think with your own head, bring your own life experience into it, think what single party means, think what democracy means. Don't take my word or anyone's word, think for yourself.


I like to use a Japanese general's words, he is the father of modern Japanese cavalry that defeated the Russian elites in Russo Japanese war.

He said to his brother, don't read a newspaper, until you formed your own opinion.

 

[BoQ77]

I thought you being Vietnamese would give you some insight into one party system, are you really Vietnamese?
....
I won't get anymore detailed due to the size of this topic, but please think with your own head, bring your own life experience into it, think what single party means, think what democracy means. Don't take my word or anyone's word, think for yourself.

I like to use a Japanese general's words, he is the father of modern Japanese cavalry that defeated the Russian elites in Russo Japanese war.

He said to his brother, don't read a newspaper, until you formed your own opinion.

A really Vietnamese living in Hanoi like me, know thoroughly about our system.

Nazi - the socialism with extreme nationalism flavor made out a dictator ... Hitler ...
Any extreme nationalism country could turn to be an aggressive invader to neighbors of her.

one main party or sole party could collect the power into 1 party and with extremely nationalism they tend to make war to others.

How about Culture Revolution in China, all outsiders consider it as a step back , do you agree ?
a Democracy country has no such a product.

Who support the dictator Pol Pot the bloody-killers of Kampuchea ?
Is it not Deng Xiaoping - China ?

 

[Genesis]

A really Vietnamese living in Hanoi like me, know thoroughly about our system.

Vietnam, China, old imperial countries, our system today reflect not of communism, but of our updated monarchy system.

A government is ever changing, the capitalist USA has socialist elements in its government, like health care and other programs. Worker programs is started by the very anti communist, socialist German empire Otto von Bismark.

Nazi - the socialism with extreme nationalism flavor made out a dictator ... Hitler ...
Any extreme nationalism country could turn to be an aggressive invader to neighbors of her.

Nazi became what it is not because of its ideology, but because of a strong government and good policies by Hitler. People forget, world leaders loved Hitler, in fact Chamberlain once said he consider Hitler to be the best of man kind and good friend.

one main party or sole party could collect the power into 1 party and with extremely nationalism they tend to make war to others.

As to collection of power into one party, don't look at party, look at it as government, China's government, Vietnam's government, US' government, all control the same thing. Don't be too hang up on the face of things, look deeper. KFC is still KFC regardless of who's the manager. Vietnam and China is the constant, people change, America government is the constant same people in the same positions change. The difference is not as big as you think it is.

Again, just think I don't want to go too much into detail, because it is a loaded question, and I don't have too much time.

As to your making war comment, you do know what America has been doing since ever right, Vietnam was involved in one.

How about Culture Revolution in China, all outsiders consider it as a step back , do you agree ?
a Democracy country has no such a product.

Cultural revolution is wrong, it is not the party's power collection it is the man, Mao, no Chinese or Vietnamese will ever hold that kind of power again. So another revolution is impossible. Look at the these. These all happened under democratic governments.


Reconstruction Era - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Joseph McCarthy - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Movements for civil rights - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Chinese Exclusion Act - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
American Indian Wars - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Guantanamo Bay detention camp - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Who support the dictator Pol Pot the bloody-killers of Kampuchea ?
Is it not Deng Xiaoping - China ?

Do you really want me to list the number of dictators that America has supported?

 

[BoQ77]

Any dictator ordered to kill over 1 million ?

of his own population

 

[Kyle Sun]

.
Can dream only, it takes at least 20 years for Vietnam to be at the same level

20 years ! The same level with Thailand ?

 

[BoQ77]

I say the Truth ...

 

[cnleio]

Copy Vietnam is S@CK ~!
Copy Japan is Evil ~!! (Nuke end)
Copy Soviet is Disappoint ~!!!
Copy U.S is Exciting ~!!!!

 

[KAL-EL]

@cnleio Your avatar reminds me of an 80's movie called "Short Circuit" about a robot that becomes alive.

 

[shuntmaster]

Is China copying the old imperial Japan? - chicagotribune.com

Some compare rise of aggressive China with the rise of Nazi Germany

 

[cnleio]

@cnleio Your avatar reminds me of an 80's movie called "Short Circuit" about a robot that becomes alive.

It's Wall-E.

In China 90s, Official CCTV ever imported a American film,Chinese named 《霹雳5号/ ThunderBolt N.o5》, It's just ur mention 《Short Circuit》. I believe most of Chinese age 30-20 have impressions on that film, coz early 1990s CCTV broadcast it many times on the TV screen. Another famous robot film is 《RoboCop》.

Ths U.S, during 1990s the American robot films and Hasbro‘s transformer r Chinese boys' favorite.

 

[cnleio]

Sometimes just need to ignore the bad guy ...

 

[Nike]

@BoQ77
Any dictator ordered to kill over 1 million ?

of his own population

Hitler and his Nazi party for a while before all of the mess in Poland happened, US gov. and companies was one of their biggest supporter. Don't forget US for so long has backing Soeharto before they abandoned him in 1998 crisis. US gov. is one of the biggest supporter for Chiang Kai Sek, and i think he was quite bloody too if i recall

 

[Water Car Engineer]

Sometimes just need to ignore the bad guy ...

You have a video of this?