aryobarzan
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2019
- Messages
- 4,586
- Reaction score
- 1
- Country
- Location
Snowy winter days in Iran
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I was watching a documentary on the biography of Hazrat Khalid bin Waleed.Snowy winter days in Iran
در دوماه اخیر اخیر ایران در زمینه تولید فولاد از آلمان، برزیل و ترکیه پیشی گرفته و به هفتمین تولیدکننده بزرگ فولاد دنیا تبدیل شده است.@IR_Breakingnews
not that drastic in last 1400 year more like , 75-80 % rural population of Iran , turned into 25-30% rural population even less, in last century.I was watching a documentary on the biography of Hazrat Khalid bin Waleed.
From there i got the image that Iran of that time was highly fertile and rich land.
But nowadays
I see you guys can't produce enough food for even your relatively small population.
It changed so much in only 1400 years?
There must be some drastic changes due to which Iranian lands lost fertility.
fix the dollar / rial rate and that 50% change
Right now there is no way of measuring Iranian GDP using dollar..all three exchange rates in Iran are artificial numbers not representative of economic activity in Iran..for example if you use the open market rate of 40000 as used by the world bank Iranian GDP will be around 230 billion..considering that Iran has $120 billion dollars in actual export this year (no exchange rate used..actual value received by Iran in foreign currancies)..that world bank figure is ridiculously low..IMF uses a rate that makes Iranian GDP at 2 trillion dollars which is too high..my own guess is that GDP must be around 1 trillion dollars but I am no economist.
Actually, those numbers are more accurate than the, say, IMF estimates which use the bogus official exchange rate. If I have X amount of IRR and want to know how much this amount is worth in USD, should I rather look at actual market rates or the fictional official rate?Right now there is no way of measuring Iranian GDP using dollar..all three exchange rates in Iran are artificial numbers not representative of economic activity in Iran..for example if you use the open market rate of 40000 as used by the world bank Iranian GDP will be around 230 billion..considering that Iran has $120 billion dollars in actual export this year (no exchange rate used..actual value received by Iran in foreign currancies)..that world bank figure is ridiculously low..IMF uses a rate that makes Iranian GDP at 2 trillion dollars which is too high..my own guess is that GDP must be around 1 trillion dollars but I am no economist.
Iran’s economy runs on IRR, not USD. So if you want to convert Iranian GDP (IRR) numbers into a USD equivalent, you need an exchange rate.I really like some economist to look into this and calculate the GDP in dollars without using exchange rate..if that is possible at all!!
fix the dollar / rial rate and that 50% change
$50-55 billion official and $20 billions unofficial imports.Right now there is no way of measuring Iranian GDP using dollar..all three exchange rates in Iran are artificial numbers not representative of economic activity in Iran..for example if you use the open market rate of 40000 as used by the world bank Iranian GDP will be around 230 billion..considering that Iran has $120 billion dollars in actual export this year (no exchange rate used..actual value received by Iran in foreign currancies)..that world bank figure is ridiculously low..IMF uses a rate that makes Iranian GDP at 2 trillion dollars which is too high..my own guess is that GDP must be around 1 trillion dollars but I am no economist.
I really like some economist to look into this and calculate the GDP in dollars without using exchange rate..if that is possible at all!!
Iran's so-called market rate of 40000 is invalid to calculate GDP and here is why.Actually, those numbers are more accurate than the, say, IMF estimates which use the bogus official exchange rate. If I have X amount of IRR and want to know how much this amount is worth in USD, should I rather look at actual market rates or the fictional official rate?
Iran’s economy runs on IRR, not USD. So if you want to convert Iranian GDP (IRR) numbers into a USD equivalent, you need an exchange rate.
Snowy winter days in Iran