Iran kills 1 Pakistani soldier, 3 injured.

[SOHEIL]

From what I hear, you could get hanged for saying vulgar and haram things like that in the Democratic Republic of Mullahstan.

You funny ...

 

[jaunty]

The timing suggest another path to be investigated, and that is if India (and/or others) was proven to assist some Pakistani insurgents, than it might just be steering trouble for Pakistan on a third fronts., Not only the Iranians whom have been back-stabbed many times in the UN by their supposedly friend India, but by Pakistan too, and has to act prudently.. This is the well known law of the third party A third party is always involved in any conflict between two parties).

I was waiting to see when someone brings India into this. Congratulations you win.

 

[Farah Sohail]

Exercising tactical restraint. This incident is going to spark a total rethinking of Iranian image in Pakistani power circles. We have all options on the table including responding with proxy warfare. Iran will certainly have fun dealing with insurgencies from every single border for a sustained period of time. Arab states will outgrow Iran economically and militarily in a decade - then Iran can sit and bite peanuts.

Havent we exercised such restraint with many countries already? And to what again? raymond Davis killed Pakistanis, then Abbottabad, drones,and last but not the least, Salala attack... Such incidents didnt spark rethinking with respect to US in our power circles......Ofcourse we cant take on US militarily ...no country can...tht would be insane...but we have always heard we will hurt US where it hurts them the most....and at a place and time of our choosing... But no such thing happened..ever... Infact on the opposite side... What we see..is tht.. We are again cooperating with US on drones.. Is this what we wanted withrespect to US? So actually we did nothing... And we will do nothing again....with Iran also...although no comparison between these two countries but just saying abt our response every time and our excuses then....

 

[TheMatador]

where did tehran come from

If Iran turns unfriendly toward Pakistan, Pakistan is strong enough to do a regime change in Tehran. Then Pakistan would have more strategic depth especially important against India.

 

[Fracker]

New great game begans, the day NS joined the government. His offering security to KSA and Afghanistan with backing of china, has pumped Iran into lap of USA. That is the reason, iran is clearly voilating rules by crossing boarders. This is still question, why iran went towards USA, when he could have secured deal with china in the region.. But one thing is for sure, Iran is no more a friend. May be Afghanistan or even india be better then them who can change side anytime. Atleast India and Pakistan both have understanding that they are eachother's enemy, but still have to live together...

 

[waz]

I understand the whole issue to do with terrorists and controlling borders. There is a point here. However, in this case we have had Iranian military personal firing and then killing one of our uniformed men.

Ok, let's say a mistake was made, but firing for 6 hours afterwards.

 

[ozzy22]

RIP to the dead.

The reaction from the Pakistani members is mind blowing!!! from the calls of killing Iranian soldiers to the nuking of Tehran!!!!

As it appears there is a great deal of anti Iranian sentiment and hatred amongst the Pakistani members, I always taught that the majority of Pakistanis held positive view of Iran.

If the roles were reversed and the Pakistani army killed two Iranian border guards. I doubt the reaction from a nationalistic Iranian forum would be different.

 

[Kompromat]

Havent we exercised such restraint with many countries already? And to what again? raymond Davis killed Pakistanis, then Abbottabad, drones,and last but not the least, Salala attack... Ofcourse we cant take on US militarily ...no country can...tht would be insane...but we havealways heard we will hurt US where it hurts them the most....and at a place and time of our choosing... But no such thing happened..ever... Infact on the opposite side... What we see..is tht.. We are again cooperating with US on drones.. Is this what we wanted withrespect to US? So actually we did nothing... And we will do nothing again....with Iran also...although no comparison between these two countries but just saying abt our response every time and our excuses then....

One needs to fight with a cooler skull when fighting on multiple fronts. For Pakistan there is NO FRIEND. We are ON OUR OWN, so lets fight on our own terms!

Yes, what you stated looks like a bleak statement on its surface but you also must remember that attacking Salala costed the US about $7 Billion dollars and the loss of an entire fighting season which has had a great impact on the battlefield outcome.

 

[jaunty]

then Abbottabad, drones

Bibi, I believe the govt of Pakistan and PA support those covertly regardless of what they say publicly.

 

[Shariqattari]

Shariqattari said: ↑
Exactly.......
Now understand why your men are quite ....its because UN has already snubbed you and you've a reputation to maintain.In short Pakistan would not risk escalating this situation and its not because Iran and Pak 're brothers as you concluded.It was an ignoratio elenchi!!
Your soldiers understand it better that 3 neighboring countries are coordinating. And ergo this silence.
Kapish???

Iran has been testing our nerves for a long time (even firing rockets, unprovoked firing etc i have already shared links in previous posts) & our military & political parties have ignored it always. By this particular incident has sparked & came into spotlight as it is done at the time of tensions at border with INDIA.... Samjhus ya nahiiin....

 

[Levina]

The 'thaw' is not going to work as the current Iranian political system was a product of American and British meddling into Iran's internal affairs. The west wants Iran's nuke program gone before they lift the crippling sanctions, something Iran won't agree to.

Hmmmm I am not sure...When U.S. president uses diplomacy and nonviolence to coerce Iran then it confuses the Iranian hardliners. The regime understands how to deal with threats but it doesn’t understand how to deal with a friendlier United States.
And Rouhani is ready to flex his political pecs...so Iran might actually surprise the world this time.

 

[Jaanbaz]

We should drop the Islamic and call ourselves Banana Republic of Pakistan.

 

[F117]

If Iran turns unfriendly toward Pakistan, Pakistan is strong enough to do a regime change in Tehran. Then Pakistan would have more strategic depth especially important against India.

Who are you kidding, change your flag. By the way, Pakistan can barely do regime change in its own tribal areas.

 

[Icewolf]

Iran needs to pay for these actions

 

[Levina]

Iran has been testing our nerves for a long time (even firing rockets, unprovoked firing etc i have already shared links in previous posts) & our military & political parties have ignored it always. By this particular incident has sparked & came into spotlight as it is done at the time of tensions at border with INDIA.... Samjhus ya nahiiin....

????

Samjhus ya nahiiin???