Indian doctors indirectly murders 40 indian patients

[tamygu]

Doctors in india are doing noble job by going on strikes...
1. they relive patients of their miseries and miserable indian lives so easily-----one can call it assisted natural euthanasia by doctors.
2,.by strikes doctors are helping indian govt in population control which is making live of billions indians miserable.for this noble cause to them doctors and terrorists must be awarded bharat ratna.

 

[jbond197]

Dont get over emotional , 1st listen the demands if they are not genuine then reject their demands but if you will not listen and say these things then condition will become more critical .

There is no stopping anybody putting demands or even striking but there is something called conscience. You can not just leave people dying what ever your reason may be? It's not just about their duty/salary it is also about the human being whose life is at risk and demands immediate attention.. Their strike can wait his life can't..

What kind of man can let anybody die in front of him when he is the one who has the cure? Tell me, Mr Doctor..

 

[harpoon]

I am not defending the the harsh act by doctors but i am saying that at least Govt should listen them and try to negotiate with the . In all this fights only common poor man is suffering

I think the Govt is taking a stand against the blackmailing(atleast for now), but its sad that poor people has to suffer due to this.

 

[Doctor09]

There is no stopping anybody putting demands or even striking but there is something called conscience. You can not just leave people die what ever your reason may be? It's not just about their duty/salary it is also about the human being whose life is at risk and demands immediate attention.. Their strike can wait his life won't..

What kind of man can let anybody die in front of him when he is the one who has the cure? Tell me, Mr Doctor..

i think you did not read my all posts . I mentioned that usually when such strikes happens doctors lefts only OPDs not emergency departments and not all doctors withdraw their services

---------- Post added at 02:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:44 AM ----------

I think the Govt is taking a stand against the blackmailing(atleast for now), but its sad that poor people has to suffer due to this.

You and me both know that Govt does not care about common man . if they do care they have to do something practical. at least starts negotiation on the basis that doctors come back and then we will find some way .

 

[harpoon]

Just like in Army & Police, strike by doctors should also be made illegal under law. Those who are unhappy should simply leave rather than playing with the lives of common man.

 

[Doctor09]

I am not promoting any quacks(if you can dare call nurses as quacks). A nurse's education in India is of 4 years and all I am saying is that with a little bit more training she/he can become a doctor. I want govt to seriously to look into this matter.

If nursing training is sufficient then there is no need to spend million of million rupees on doctors . I think you will never mind if you have to be operated by a nurse for neurosurgery,
By your logic a driver can fly Su 30 with little extra training , a motor mechanic can build an aircraft with little extra training

 

[harpoon]

You and me both know that Govt does not care about common man . if they do care they have to do something practical. at least starts negotiation on the basis that doctors come back and then we will find some way .

Negotiation should be on a basis on give and take..but doctors only take take take..

 

[Doctor09]

Negotiation should be on a basis on give and take..but doctors only take take take..

when you are even not ready for negotiation then how can you say that they take take and take .
you are applying your personal feelings here not facts

 

[harpoon]

If nursing training is sufficient then there is no need to spend million of million rupees on doctors . I think you will never mind if you have to be operated by a nurse for neurosurgery,

I can sense your arrogance creeping in which is very typical of professionals. Its like 'How dare you compare me the doctor to a 'lowly' nurse."..but you forgot the word "more training".

By your logic a driver can fly Su 30 with little extra training , a motor mechanic can build an aircraft with little extra training

Pls don't forget that the fist aircraft was built by 2 low educated cycle repairmen and a driver surely can fly a Su 30 if he has the aptitude to do so.

 

[Doctor09]

and if their demands are not genuine then action should be taken against them but for that you have to listen to them before making any conclusion . But here people even dont want to listen their demands and blaming them for everything. its not justice . and if their demands are genuine then you have to stand by the side of doctors ( but it does not happen)

 

[harpoon]

when you are even not ready for negotiation then how can you say that they take take and take .
you are applying your personal feelings here not facts

I remark was based on the strikes by Kerala doctors not so long ago. All they want is more and more pay eventhough they are paid quite well by Indian standards.

 

[Doctor09]

I can sense your arrogance creeping in which is very typical of professionals. Its like 'How dare you compare me the doctor to a 'lowly' nurse."..but you forgot the word "more training".



Pls don't forget that the fist aircraft was built by 2 low educated cycle repairmen and a driver surely can fly a Su 30 if he has the aptitude to do so.

i think you should educate yourself about medical profession . if you mean more training by 20yrs then may be some nurse can perform neurosurgery but the success rate of that surgery will be less than 10 %
About 2nd part . you are telling me about an exceptional case . But if you think so then of apply your super logic in India , i doubt how many Indians will be ready to be a test subject for nursing staff . BTW who will train those nurses ? dont tell me that you want a doctor to train them

Even a neurosurgeon cant perform a job of ENT specialist or urologist or dermatologist and you want nurses to do doctor's job .

 

[harpoon]

i think you should educate yourself about medical profession . if you mean more training by 20yrs then may be some nurse can perform neurosurgery but the success rate of that surgery will be less than 10 %
About 2nd part . you are telling me about an exceptional case . But if you think so then of apply your super logic in India , i doubt how many Indians will be ready to be a test subject for nursing staff . BTW who will train those nurses ? dont tell me that you want a doctor to train them

Even a neurosurgeon cant perform a job of ENT specialist or urologist or dermatologist and you want nurses to do doctor's job .

Why it takes 20 years when you can become a doctor from start to finish in 5 years.

Yes, I don't know much about medical profession, but my question is if we can have specific doctors for dentistry (BDS) why can't we have the same in general medicine, who can then be posted in rural areas. This could help in reducing the rush in district hospitals/Medical colleges as minor ailments can be treated by the above said doctor in the local dispensary itself, referring only the serious cases to the big hospitals. Only he can ensure the well being of the local population.