What's new

India is heading the same road as US, UK, Japan, Eurozone and... Zimbabwe

Status
Not open for further replies.

BigDaddyWatch

FULL MEMBER
Joined
May 31, 2012
Messages
727
Reaction score
1
India's central bank the RBI from 23 august onward is going to start purchasing long term government bonds in order to suppress interest rate on government borrowing. This is the same policy as in the US, UK, Japan, Eurozone and Zimbabwe. This will further weaken the rupee and raise in flation in India. Asset purchase by central banks is a roach motel policy where you check in but you don't check out. It will be impossible for the central bank to sell their assets, no one is going to buy them because once the central banks announce that they would sell the assets on their balance sheet traders and other market participants are going to "front run" these sells. ie shorting them to make money so the value of those assets on the central banks and others balance sheet will collapse. And in the process bankrupting everyone that owns Indian government bonds. This is also a indication that the Indian government has no intentions to rein in excessive spending. The printing of money also known as quantitative easing is a slippery slope once you are on it is hard to get off. You either have to continue to print ever larger amounts in order to keep the system going and allow the value of the currency to be destroyed or you stop printing and let the economy to "correct" itself ie crash.

India Eases Cash-Supply Curbs as Surging Yields Imperil Growth

India’s central bank announced plans to buy long-dated government bonds after a surge in yields imperiled economic growth, in a move that eases cash-supply curbs aimed at stemming a plunge in the rupee.

The Reserve Bank of India will conduct open-market debt purchases of 80 billion rupees ($1.3 billion) on Aug. 23 and “thereafter calibrate them both in terms of quantum and frequency” based on market conditions, it said in a statement yesterday. The earlier liquidity-tightening steps must not “harden longer term yields sharply” and hurt lending, it said.


India’s 10-year bond yield touched 9.48 percent yesterday, the highest since 2001, as the nation struggles to curb capital outflows spurred by risks such as a record current-account deficit and speculation the U.S. Federal Reserve could taper stimulus. The RBI since mid-July raised two interest rates and capped cash injections into the banking system to aid the rupee, steps that risk hurting expansion in Asia’s No 3 economy.

“The long-end yields reacted too much and that was, probably, not the objective,” said Prasanna Ananthasubramanian, an economist at ICICI Securities Primary Dealership Ltd. in Mumbai. “There are other objectives that the RBI has to worry about, like government borrowing costs and the impact on the economy.”

Government bonds eventually snapped a five-day drop at the close in Mumbai yesterday. The yield on the notes due May 2023 slid 32 basis points, or 0.32 percentage point, to 8.92 percent. The rupee weakened 0.2 percent to 63.23 per dollar and has tumbled about 14 percent in the past six months. The S&P BSE Sensex index slid for the third straight session.

Steps Reviewed

The central bank said a review of the measures since mid-July suggests the “immediate objective of raising the short-term interest rates has substantially been achieved.”

The issue of cash management bills will be calibrated going forward, “including scaling it down as may be necessary,” the RBI said.

The central bank last month increased both the marginal standing facility rate and the bank rate by 200 basis points to 10.25 percent. It has also tightened daily reserve requirements.

The interbank overnight lending rate has surged more than 300 basis points, or 3 percentage points, to 10.3 percent since the end of June.

The yield on the 10-year notes has jumped 1.46 percentage points in the same period, while that on the two-year securities rose 1.85 percentage points, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

Trade Imbalance

The current-account gap widened to 4.8 percent of gross domestic product in the 12 months ended March. The Reserve Bank of India estimates the sustainable level is 2.5 percent of GDP.

The plunge in the rupee threatens to stoke the cost of imports such as oil, adding to price pressures.

Consumer prices rose 9.64 percent in July from a year earlier. Another gauge based on wholesale prices advanced 5.79 percent, a five-month high that exceeded the central bank’s comfort zone of about 5 percent.

India’s economy may expand 5.5 percent in the year through March 2014, compared with 5 percent in the previous 12-month period, the central bank estimates. That lags behind the 10-year average of about 8 percent.

The nation is suffering as Asia’s role as the world’s growth engine wanes and investors pull out billions of dollars.

Raghuram Rajan, the top adviser in the Finance Ministry since 2012 and a former International Monetary Fund chief economist, becomes the Reserve Bank governor in September. He succeeds Duvvuri Subbarao. The next scheduled monetary-policy review is on Sept. 18.

India Eases Cash-Supply Curbs as Surging Yields Imperil Growth - Bloomberg
 
. .
This is utter bullshit and everyone knows it.We may not grow at 9 % or for the matter even 5% for sometime but zimbabwe!!What are u smoking man?
 
. . .
What i meant to say was that its the same policy as in the US, UK, Japan, Eurozone and Zimbabwe. And the result will be the same high inflation, plunging currency and bulging debt. If this policy is implemented this will be India's downfall. Rather or not India will become as bad as Zimbabwe still remains to be seen. But its obvious that the Indian government and the RBI do not know what they are doing and is making one mistake after another. First they curb cash flows trying to stem the losses of the INR as a result interest rate on government borrowing has increased and now they are directly buying bonds to suppress the interest rate for government borrowing. If this policy is implemented then you could well see a accelerated drop of the INR.
 
.
What i meant to say was that its the same policy as in the US, UK, Japan, Eurozone and Zimbabwe. And the result will be the same high inflation, plunging currency and bulging debt. If this policy is implemented this will be India's downfall. Rather or not India will become as bad as Zimbabwe still remains to be seen. But its obvious that the Indian government and the RBI do not know what they are doing and is making one mistake after another. First they curb cash flows trying to stem the losses of the INR as a result interest rate on government borrowing has increased and now they are directly buying bonds to suppress the interest rate for government borrowing. If this policy is implemented then you could well see a accelerated drop of the INR.

Tightening short term rate, but easing long term rate by buying long tenure govt bond is not the same as quantitative easing (QE), like what Fed and BOJ did. It's realigning the "yield curve"
To shore up the rupee, RBI has stopped reducing India short term interest rate, but it still stood at well over 7%. In the law of economics, the longer tenure rate would have to be correspondingly higher than 7%. In fact, it almost hit 10%--too high a rate will hurt growth in the long term, this is why they are buying long tenure bond to bring the yield. Flattening the yield curve if you like.

QE is reducing both short and long term interest rate.
 
. .
What i meant to say was that its the same policy as in the US, UK, Japan, Eurozone and Zimbabwe. And the result will be the same high inflation, plunging currency and bulging debt. If this policy is implemented this will be India's downfall. Rather or not India will become as bad as Zimbabwe still remains to be seen. But its obvious that the Indian government and the RBI do not know what they are doing and is making one mistake after another. First they curb cash flows trying to stem the losses of the INR as a result interest rate on government borrowing has increased and now they are directly buying bonds to suppress the interest rate for government borrowing. If this policy is implemented then you could well see a accelerated drop of the INR.

Dollar is strengthening not plunging.
Current US inflation is around 2% (high inflation?)

even then - economics is a complex game. A few factors over a few years period does not indicate the health of the economy. Its really like being rich. Money never stays at one place for too long - it changes hands - and more often than not, it circles back.
 
. . .
Tightening short term rate, but easing long term rate by buying long tenure govt bond is not the same as quantitative easing (QE), like what Fed and BOJ did. It's realigning the "yield curve"
To shore up the rupee, RBI has stopped reducing India short term interest rate, but it still stood at well over 7%. In the law of economics, the longer tenure rate would have to be correspondingly higher than 7%. In fact, it almost hit 10%--too high a rate will hurt growth in the long term, this is why they are buying long tenure bond to bring the yield. Flattening the yield curve if you like.

QE is reducing both short and long term interest rate.

What you say is technically true however in order for India to flatten the yield curve the central bank has to print money to buy government bonds and that will further depreciate the value of the Rupee. And its also means that the Indian government is taking more resources away from the rest of the economy and shows to the rest of the world that they have no intension for fiscal discipline all of which will further hurt the rupee.
 
.
Dollar is strengthening not plunging.
Current US inflation is around 2% (high inflation?)

even then - economics is a complex game. A few factors over a few years period does not indicate the health of the economy. Its really like being rich. Money never stays at one place for too long - it changes hands - and more often than not, it circles back.

First of all do you really believe that inflation is only at 2% ? If you look at your grocery bills and compare them from last years is the rise in prices only 2% ? Or even when you fill up your car. But the biggest inflation are in the asset prices like houses, bonds and stocks ie its all one giant bubble.

Its true that money doesn't stay in one place but its a supply and demand issue as you create more dollars and there are more dollars in existence thats going to depreciate the value of the dollar. The reason why the USD is still rising is for several reasons.

One is that the dollar is benefitting from the problems in the Eurozone, Japan and the UK.

Two is that those countries are printing as well.

And three is that the USD as the world's reserve currency has a special status that enables it dodge some of the normal workings of the currency markets.
 
.
What you say is technically true however in order for India to flatten the yield curve the central bank has to print money to buy government bonds and that will further depreciate the value of the Rupee. And its also means that the Indian government is taking more resources away from the rest of the economy and shows to the rest of the world that they have no intension for fiscal discipline all of which will further hurt the rupee.

No, becoz short term repo rate is at 7%. They are not reducing anymore. What they are buying is long term bond, 10yr or more to push down the yield, interest, this have no immediate impact on short term repo rate, hence, the rupee.

Buying bond to influence the yield is a common monetary policy. It does not necessarily mean printing money. That's QE.

Unless short term cut is from 7% to 1 or 0%, what you said makes no sense.
 
.
The entire global fiscal policy is begging for a revolution. Since 1998 the markets have sent a clear message that the outdated banking and international fiscal calculators need to be rehauled. India like most other nations is a victim of this outdated fiscal policies. We have moved from financially independent nations into one large global financial village in the 21st century and yet the world uses barometers which were created in the early 1900's when it comes to fiscal evaluation.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom