What's new

India denies Pakistan access to Mumbai gunman

Major Sam

STAFF
Joined
May 8, 2011
Messages
2,750
Reaction score
-3
Country
Pakistan
Location
Malaysia
A Pakistani commission investigating the 2008 terror attack in Mumbai will visit in early February.


But the commission will not be allowed to interrogate the lone surviving gunman, Indian officials said Monday.

The visit is the result of intricate negotiations between the nuclear-armed neighbors, but is unlikely to resolve tensions.

Disagreements over access to gunman Ajmal Kasab, who has been sentenced to death in India for his role in the rampage that killed 166, have spilled into public view.

Pakistan s interior minister, Rehman Malik, told India s NDTV last week that Pakistani officials would like to speak with Kasab directly to verify his confession.

"It can be verified either by bringing Ajmal Kasab to Pakistan or the judicial commission goes and personally interviews the witnesses, including Ajmal Kasab," he said. "That s what we have requested."

Ira Joshi, a spokeswoman for India s Ministry of Home Affairs, said Monday that such access was not part of the memorandum of understanding governing the visit.

In his confession before the court which he later retracted Kasab described in detail a network of training camps and safe houses across Pakistan, revealing the names of four men he said were his handlers.

Pakistan bristles at that criticism, noting that seven suspects in the Mumbai attack have been put on trial.

The Pakistani delegation will visit Mumbai in the first week of February and speak to doctors who did the post-mortems on the nine gunmen killed during the attack, as well as to the magistrate who recorded Kasab s confession and the chief investigating officer of the attacks, an official at Mumbai s high court said on condition of anonymity because of the confidential nature of the visit. --AP

Dunya News: Pakistan:-India denies Pakistan access to Mumbai gunman...
 
. .
That's because the Indians are liars. We tried to conduct joint-investigations, but to no avail.

Clearly if there is a need to find out exactly what happened - logically a joint investigation would have been paramount. Why are the Indian authorities ducking this issue?
 
.
That's because the Indians are liars. We tried to conduct joint-investigations, but to no avail.

Anyone in their right minds know real well that Pakistani investigation will lead no where, that they are not interested in carrying out a honest and diligent investigation because they indirectly support terrorism. You can keep denying but the world has enough evidence and is apparently not dumb enough to not understand whats going on.

To be honest with you, Indians dont give a sh** about whom you investigate and whom you punish. All we want is peace and safety of our civilians, but that's too much to ask. If Pakistan was even half serious about this they would not need to make conspiracy theories.
 
.
Anyone in their right minds know real well that Pakistani investigation will lead no where, that they are not interested in carrying out a honest and diligent investigation because they indirectly support terrorism. You can keep denying but the world has enough evidence and is apparently not dumb enough to not understand whats going on.

To be honest with you, Indians dont give a sh** about whom you investigate and whom you punish. All we want is peace and safety of our civilians, but that's too much to ask. If Pakistan was even half serious about this they would not need to make conspiracy theories.

Steaming pile of bs. You Indians created propaganda against Pakistan, otherwise you would have nothing to fear.
 
.
Steaming pile of bs. You Indians created propaganda against Pakistan, otherwise you would have nothing to fear.

come on yaar . if joint investigation was the need for the day why have it 4 yrs after the event and why after he has been found guilty and sentenced to death?
the guys we have named are roaming freely in Pakistan . you put him under house arrest then let him go .
while we would like to see the guys brought to book in Pakistan . we are under no illusions that there will ever be tried ,much less convicted.
 
.
Steaming pile of bs. You Indians created propaganda against Pakistan, otherwise you would have nothing to fear.

You Pakistanis are the busiest bunch unleashing propaganda and continuously enlightening us about things we should worry about. Do not misjudge our caution and term it fear. Our strongest feeling for Pakistan is pity. Our leaders do not continuously preach us about what our biggest threat needs to be.
 
.
come on yaar . if joint investigation was the need for the day why have it 4 yrs after the event and why after he has been found guilty and sentenced to death?
the guys we have named are roaming freely in Pakistan . you put him under house arrest then let him go .
while we would like to see the guys brought to book in Pakistan . we are under no illusions that there will ever be tried ,much less convicted.

Pakistan offered joint investigations right after the incident.

You Pakistanis are the busiest bunch unleashing propaganda and continuously enlightening us about things we should worry about. Do not misjudge our caution and term it fear. Our strongest feeling for Pakistan is pity. Our leaders do not continuously preach us about what our biggest threat needs to be.

Irrelevant to my point and topic.
 
.
Pakistan offered joint investigations right after the incident.



Irrelevant to my point and topic.

tell me in 4 yrs you have been able to unearth nothing my friend? yaar let us agree to disagree on this point that your government was not serious about the investigation.
 
.
tell me in 4 yrs you have been able to unearth nothing my friend? yaar let us agree to disagree on this point that your government was not serious about the investigation.

I will disagree, because your government did not allow us to participate.
 
.
That's because the Indians are liars. We tried to conduct joint-investigations, but to no avail.

The people who committed the crime dont need to participate in the investigation, they will pay for their crimes in the long run anyways, infact they are paying now too.
 
.
The people who committed the crime dont need to participate in the investigation, they will pay for their crimes in the long run anyways, infact they are paying now too.

So you think these terrorists had no logistics? You have to cut off the head. We were willing to work with GOI, but you guys just painted the entire nation with the terrorism brush. Immature really, since there is no guarantee these groups will not strike in India again.
 
.
That's because the Indians are liars. We tried to conduct joint-investigations, but to no avail.

So Pakistan refused joint investigation of the recent border attack by US forces on Pakistani checkpost that killed 28 PA soldiers.. Does that prove Pakistanis are liars?? I am simply extrapolating your comment above. Just like Pakistan had reasons to not do a joint investigation of the NATO attack on PA soldiers, we had our reasons to prevent Pakistani participation in 26/11 investigations..
 
.
I will disagree, because your government did not allow us to participate.

boss....u know it very well....pak civilian govmt hardly does anything when it comes to carrying out attacks of this magnitude against civiliants in countries like India...it is only ISI and Army who but when we asked ISI Chief to be a part of the investigation, you disagreed!..now tell me, what to do with Zardari and Gilani??? for you guys are also they are redundant..isnt it?
So, what did you offer and how it could have helped the investigation agencies without active participation of ISI and Pak Army?
 
.
Clearly if there is a need to find out exactly what happened - logically a joint investigation would have been paramount. Why are the Indian authorities ducking this issue?

Same reason Pakistan ducked joint investigation with NATO. Most Indians establishments believe that Pakistan was complicit in 26/11 attack, just like Pakistan believes the border attack by NATO was intentional. And hence for India to do a joint investigation, would be like teaming up with a suspect to investigate the crime
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom