India and China are good friends – PM

[Shardul.....the lion]

We have been peaceful with each other throughout history before british drew that infamous McMahon line.

Saying China has ambition against India and wanting to take indian's territory is just absurd.

During Qing dynasty, when Kangxi Emperor controlled Tibet, defeated russia in the north, killed those mongol separatists in the northwest, has he ordered his troops in Tibet invading india?

I supposed then it should be much easier since india has never been a united country but hundreds of small kingdoms.

So you see China historically was never interested in conquering india or take lands from india.

However, after british drew that McMahon line with the sole intention to take land from China (then Qing Dynasty) and inciting tibet local government to sign accord which China central government had never recognized, india should have been wiser not to use its colonial master's devious line/tactics to grab land from China by recognizing that line.

However, your premier nehru became so arrogant with everything he inherited from british was legal attitude since he thought his india got independence earlier, was stronger and China was poorer, weaker.

India should be the No. 1 in asia and there should be no problem taking land from China. He thought india should brought tibet under india's umbrella since his colonial master u.k. just showed him how things got done.

However, even though China was not interested taking yours, China would not be the sitting duck when india took China's.

We all know the 1962's result and it led to the downfall and demise of nehru.

If india did not change its attitude inheriting from its colonial master, the relationship between China and india will not really be back to normal.

I want to say one thing about Macmohan line. I know it was drawn by british imperialist.
But in south asia, almost all borders were drawn by British.
So if say Mcmohan line is illegal, then india-pakistan border, pakistan-afghanistan border, india-nepal border, india-bangladesh border, india-myanmar border all become illegal.
So, whats your take on that?
Are all these borders to illegal, and should all countries fight for border according to ancient cultural history, where kings, and sultans constantly fought with each other.

 

[Kesang]

You back stabbed us by hosting our largest separatist group in 1959. And as if that was not enough, you then carried out the "Forward Policy" against us in 1962.

Both of which happened BEFORE the Sino-Indian war, so don't pretend that you were innocent.

USA helping ROC and Tibet separatist, why not you attacked them? and many xinxiang separatist training camp in pakistan and you didn't attack them and There are many Indian sepratist and moist sheltered by China, Did we attack?

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

USA helping ROC and Tibet separatist, why not you attacked them? and many xinxiang separatist training camp in pakistan and you didn't attack them and There are many Indian sepratist and moist sheltered by China, Did we attack?

The USA supported the RoC against us in the Chinese Civil War, which is one of the reasons we went to war with the USA in 1950.

In the 1950 Korean war, we fought the USA + 16 of her allies combined... And we ended up pushing them completely out of North Korea.

India though... India still has the distinction of being the only country to be hosting our separatist groups.

 

[Kesang]

The USA supported the RoC against us in the Chinese Civil War, which is one of the reasons we went to war with the USA in 1950.

In the 1950 Korean war, we fought the USA + 16 of her allies combined... And we ended up pushing them completely out of North Korea.

India though... India still has the distinction of being the only country to be hosting our separatist groups.

You didn't answered about separstist in Pakistan and our'ss in china.

Do you know that PLA when Invade tibet? What if we Indvade pakistan, Bangladesh, sri lanka, bhutan or nepal ? Will you accept our occupation and those land is our despite BD and pakistan was our part? Same thing goes for tibet.

 

[FairAndUnbiased]

You didn't answered about separstist in Pakistan and our'ss in china.

Do you know that PLA when Invade tibet? What if we Indvade pakistan, Bangladesh, sri lanka, bhutan or nepal ? Will you accept our occupation and those land is our despite BD and pakistan was our part? Same thing goes for tibet.

PLA did not invade Tibet. I suggest you look at a map of Taiwan (the Republic of China).

 

[Kesang]

PLA did not invade Tibet. I suggest you look at a map of Taiwan (the Republic of China).

???? PLA didn't invade Tibet?? Tibet is free ?? I checked and I found that ROC is a small Island near eastern china an Tibet is our neighbour and it is in southern part of china and far from ROC

 

[bobthebuilder]

Tibet was never part of china. It shares cultural heritage with India. How come china alone claim tibet . They should be better be buffer state between India and china

 

[LetsGetRowdy]

Tibet was never part of china. It shares cultural heritage with. How come china alone claim tibet . They should be better be buffer state between India and china

and india was never a country. of course you would like to see tibet as a buffer. china would also like to see india split into 30 princely states. which one do you think has a higher chance of materializing?

 

[bobthebuilder]

Those qing dynasty need to cross Himalayas .how can they attack India with that day technology.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Tibet was never part of china. It shares cultural heritage with India. How come china alone claim tibet . They should be better be buffer state between India and china

It was this mentality that lead to the 1962 war and turned us into your enemies.

Why blame Nehru?

 

[Tractor]

Indian thought China should not bigger in size than India.Tibet just a barran land uninhabitable,forget about it.

 

[bobthebuilder]

It was this mentality that lead to the 1962 war and turned us into your enemies.

Why blame Nehru?

what is wrong in that. Why hide from true history

---------- Post added at 02:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:00 PM ----------

and india was never a country. of course you would like to see tibet as a buffer. china would also like to see india split into 30 princely states. which one do you think has a higher chance of materializing?

India was united during many kingdoms like mauryas,mughals,marathas,cholas.
If we go by china's logic many south asian country should come under our neck.

 

[LetsGetRowdy]

what is wrong in that. Why hide from true history

---------- Post added at 02:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:00 PM ----------



India was united during many kingdoms like mauryas,mughals,marathas,cholas.
If we go by china's logic many south asian country should come under our neck.

you were united by middle eastern islamics, then by east asian mongol decedents, and finally by the western british. india does not belong to indians, just like the indian ocean does not belong to india. splitting india up into a dozen different states may become reality in the future.

 

[Lyrical Mockery]

arm chair generals day dreaming.

Sorry guys, the world doesn't work the way you people think and want it to.

 

[navtrek]

No wonder the Indians here hate Manmohan Singh so much.

No we don't hate our Prime minister Dr Manmohan Singh. We only hate the policies of the government he heads.