What's new

In a rare meeting, Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi apprises FIIs about party's stand on stuck G

fsayed

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Feb 21, 2013
Messages
2,606
Reaction score
-2
Country
India
Location
India
NEW DELHI: Businesses lobbying ministers for favourable policies is common practice, but doing that with Opposition leaders is extremely rare. But a bunch of top foreign institutional investors has done just that.

Some 20 or so top foreign fund representatives met Congress Vice-President Rahul Gandhi in Delhi on Thursday to discuss the fate of key economic legislations, notably the long-pending Goods and Services Tax (GST) Bill, the unusual meeting underscoring the nervousness in markets whether economic reforms will once again become hostage to politics in the upcoming winter session of Parliament.

The meeting, at Gandhi's Tughlak Lane residence and arranged at the behest of the investors, was labelled by one of the attendees as an attempt to get a 'first-hand view' of the Congress party's stance in the upcoming Parliament session. Put bluntly, they wanted to know whether or not Congress would support the GST Bill's passage in the winter session that starts on November 26. Representatives of firms such as Capital International, HSBC, T.

Rowe Price, Dutch Pension Fund and Jupiter Capital are among those said to have attended the hour-long meeting with Gandhi, who was accompanied by United Progressive Alliance-era minister and close adviser Jairam Ramesh and other party functionaries.

While representatives of the firms were not available for comment, one of the Congress functionaries present at the meeting said Gandhi assured the investors that his party was not against economic reforms and put the onus for the Bill's passage on the government.

"It was the Congress party which ushered in liberalisation and first brought the GST Bill. But the party is equally committed to protecting the marginalised, the poor and make sure the security support systems are in place," said this person.

"He (Rahul Gandhi) didn't say that we will stall Parliament. 'The GST Bill is our Bill, we introduced it three years ago...We are not against growth but the present government has to engage with Opposition. They can't take a stand just because they have the numbers'," the person quoted Gandhi as saying.

Rahul Gandhi too acknowledged the meeting on his twitter handle @officeofRG. "Had a fruitful discussion with top foreign institutional investors yesterday on state of the economy & its priorities."

Market watchers warn further delay in passage of key reforms, including GST, could lead to some foreign investors paring a portion of their Indian holdings. "Investor patience is running thin and the government needs to push through at least one big-banner reform in the winter session of Parliament to regain confidence," said Taimur Baig and Kaushik Das, economists at Deutsche Bank.

The hour-long meeting largely focussed on the GST Bill, but the bankruptcy law was also discussed.

In a recent interview with Reuters, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley said the government is ready to discuss all issues with the Opposition on GST, but would not compromise on the basic architecture of the tax reform.

Congress leader and former finance minister P Chidambaram has put three conditions for supporting the Bill. These include a constitutional cap of 18% on GST, a dispute resolution authority, and dropping of the 1% tax proposed on interstate movement of goods. ' The government could not get the GST Bill passed in the monsoon session because it refused to accept these conditions.
In a rare meeting, Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi apprises FIIs about party's stand on stuck GST Bill - The Economic Times
 
. . .
The onus of passing bills belongs to the govt , not the oppositions. This govt has not come out of its campaigning mode after elections of 2014. they have to build consensus and work with other parties. which they have not.
They needed someone like Pranab or Rajiv shukla to do backroom deals and to reach out to the OPP . Running parliament is not about rhetoric , it may sound good for the voters but nothing gets achieved.
 
.
The onus of passing bills belongs to the govt , not the oppositions. This govt has not come out of its campaigning mode after elections of 2014. they have to build consensus and work with other parties. which they have not.
They needed someone like Pranab or Rajiv shukla to do backroom deals and to reach out to the OPP . Running parliament is not about rhetoric , it may sound good for the voters but nothing gets achieved.
That does not mean that the opposition has no duty to the country. The party in opposition int the Lok Sabha is the majority in the Rajya Sabha. Don't they have ANY duty to behave responsibly to the nation? If they don't we need to scrap the present parliamentary system and throw out the Rajya Sabha. They should not use their majority in an unelected portion of parliament to dictate their partisan terms.

In which other democratic country does an opposition MP and member of the previous cabinet no less go to professed enemy country in a Cold War situation and ask for the current democratically elected government to be removed!

The Congress is behaving disgracefully, having said that , we have to work with what we got and the government has to find a way to bribe and/or pressure these principle-less opposition. public opinion should also force them into working with the government - if these jokers figured out that the public see what they are doing it would make a difference.
 
.
That does not mean that the opposition has no duty to the country. The party in opposition int the Lok Sabha is the majority in the Rajya Sabha. Don't they have ANY duty to behave responsibly to the nation? If they don't we need to scrap the present parliamentary system and throw out the Rajya Sabha. They should not use their majority in an unelected portion of parliament to dictate their partisan terms.

In which other democratic country does an opposition MP and member of the previous cabinet no less go to professed enemy country in a Cold War situation and ask for the current democratically elected government to be removed!

The Congress is behaving disgracefully, having said that , we have to work with what we got and the government has to find a way to bribe and/or pressure these principle-less opposition. public opinion should also force them into working with the government - if these jokers figured out that the public see what they are doing it would make a difference.
Factories running 30% below capacity: Rajan | Page 3
Post 36 .
 
.
raul ghandy should be lynched

we need to purge this family from Indian politics
 
.
The onus of passing bills belongs to the govt , not the oppositions. This govt has not come out of its campaigning mode after elections of 2014. they have to build consensus and work with other parties. which they have not.
They needed someone like Pranab or Rajiv shukla to do backroom deals and to reach out to the OPP . Running parliament is not about rhetoric , it may sound good for the voters but nothing gets achieved.

Secularism and tolerance are the most important wealth of this nation and the opposition must stay united and not let any backroom deals happen- This fascist Govt- must go- Parliament must not function till then- I am feeling suffocated in this environment- can't eat my beef-
 
.

The government needs to reach out more effectively but The opposition has DUTIES too. They cannot behave like total d!cks. Again in no democratic country in the world is an opposition so partisan as to go to an enemy country and ask for help in removing the constitutionally elected PM. Sonia has not yet apologized and most likely will never have to. The opposition does not care about the country. This is only possible in India.
 
.
That does not mean that the opposition has no duty to the country. The party in opposition int the Lok Sabha is the majority in the Rajya Sabha. Don't they have ANY duty to behave responsibly to the nation? If they don't we need to scrap the present parliamentary system and throw out the Rajya Sabha. They should not use their majority in an unelected portion of parliament to dictate their partisan terms.

The Congress is behaving disgracefully, having said that , we have to work with what we got and the government has to find a way to bribe and/or pressure these principle-less opposition. public opinion should also force them into working with the government - if these jokers figured out that the public see what they are doing it would make a difference.

Actually GST was passed by Congress some years back and BJP simply refused to support it. As a senior member said @jbgt90 said the onus is on the govt to find middle ground or deals with the opposition. That's how bills have been passed in the last 15-20 years or so. Same can be said about the Nuclear deal. The major thing is once the bills are passed, small amendments can be brought into it, without passing it in the Parliament. Its a known fact and opposition will be silent during that time
 
.
The government needs to reach out more effectively but The opposition has DUTIES too. They cannot behave like total d!cks. Again in no democratic country in the world is an opposition so partisan as to go to an enemy country and ask for help in removing the constitutionally elected PM. Sonia has not yet apologized and most likely will never have to. The opposition does not care about the country. This is only possible in India.
The same could be said about the bjp when they were in opposition.

Actually GST was passed by Congress some years back and BJP simply refused to support it. As a senior member said @jbgt90 said the onus is on the govt to find middle ground or deals with the opposition. That's how bills have been passed in the last 15-20 years or so. Same can be said about the Nuclear deal. The major thing is once the bills are passed, small amendments can be brought into it, without passing it in the Parliament. Its a known fact and opposition will be silent during that time
Another example of taking the opp aboard is when the opp disagrees with a bill , they govt agrees to some amendments in some other bill and the opp stages a walkout , thereby letting the bill pass in the lower house. When it comes to the upper house they get the amendments they wanted.
 
.
The same could be said about the bjp when they were in opposition.


Another example of taking the opp aboard is when the opp disagrees with a bill , they govt agrees to some amendments in some other bill and the opp stages a walkout , thereby letting the bill pass in the lower house. When it comes to the upper house they get the amendments they wanted.

Exactly. The walkouts are nothing, but a diversionary tactics to pass the bill. We can see that a lot in State Assemblies. And Parliament is no different.
The only face BJP has in its ranks to broke peace with the opposition right now is Sushma Swaraj. Other than Congress nobody even gave a statement against her. She must be employed to full effect. Or else Modi govt must find a new deal breaker.
Congress had Ghulam Nabi Azad, who used to break deals with opposition. Its time this govt start using its "Rajthandiram"
 
.
Exactly. The walkouts are nothing, but a diversionary tactics to pass the bill. We can see that a lot in State Assemblies. And Parliament is no different.
The only face BJP has in its ranks to broke peace with the opposition right now is Sushma Swaraj. Other than Congress nobody even gave a statement against her. She must be employed to full effect. Or else Modi govt must find a new deal breaker.
Congress had Ghulam Nabi Azad, who used to break deals with opposition. Its time this govt start using its "Rajthandiram"
Actually sushma is a friend of sonia, that she was attacked was just politics. she is respected in the congress, and she would be a great asset if the bjp could effectively use her.
But will she even be used?
 
.
Actually sushma is a friend of sonia, that she was attacked was just politics. she is respected in the congress, and she would be a great asset if the bjp could effectively use her.
But will she even be used?

Given the way Modi tries to run the foreign policies, Sushma must be given the most important job of effecting deals.
A political dawn is needed on this govt to realise the importance of Sushma ji
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom