Ignorant Muslim Bangladeshi celibrating Benglai new year: Nauzubillah Minzalik

[Al-zakir]

Why is the term devangiri not accepted in islam?!!! and how is urdu more "islamic" than other language? Where in the Quran and Hadith it says that? urdu was not even invented then! Urdu has more Khariboli<sanksrit verbs than any other languge! It's grammer is almost purely khariboli hindi! There are persian and arabic nouns and adjective with minor verbs in all the indo-aryan languages of south asia, whether it is urdu or bengali. How can we term a mere language hindu or muslim?!:S that means if a hindu has a cow it is a hindu cow and if a muslim has it then its muslim??? How are you our friend when you imposed a totally unfamiliar language on us!?

He isn't imposing on us. All he is saying is that Urdu was and is favorable language to religious scholars in subcontinent because of its Arabic script. Urdu compliment Arabic little different than bangla. That all.

 

[Communist]

India is our only neighbour and they know us more than anybody else, how dangerous the Bengalis could turn out to be.. and they will dare to attack us...

Akhanda Bharater galpota jaina nile bhalo hoy... dakhol korte gele shobshomoy lorai korte lagena... magoj dholai koira dile, juddher ki dorkar? Bojhaite parlam ki?

 

[TopCat]

Name of your country is Bangladesh not bengal so therefor if anything than you should be Bangladeshi Muslim though I prefer Muslim form Bangladesh.

This Bengali identity will not permit you to enter heaven. At the end of the day "La ilah illa Allah; Muhammad Rasul Allah" count which is Arabic not bangla.

So my point is why are you so proud of your ancient bengali Hindu culture when you are momin and your allegiance should be to absolute power of Allah and his Rasul. What is more important than teaching of our Pyari Nabi.

Please tell me because I am not understating you at all and your unusal attraction toward un-Islamic culture is worry some.

Well, I dont know whether you watch "Jibon Jiggasa" a NTV program where the person (which is most respected islamic scholar in Bangaldesh, and the persident of Imam Samity organization of all Imams) was asked whether is it permittable in Islam to listen to Rabindra Sangit. His answer was, some of Rabindra's songs are so spiritual that even a Muslim can become more close to Allah by listening to them and there is no problem in listening to Rabindhra Sangit.

I hope you understand now...

 

[gromell]

He isn't imposing on us. All he is saying is that Urdu was and is favorable language to religious scholars in subcontinent because of its Arabic script. Urdu compliment Arabic little different than bangla. That all.

we had more than long discussion on this so i am not going to start again but i'd prefer arabic if i have to use arabic script. cause learning arabic for me is no way harder than learning urdu. I like islamic nasheed in Bangla than urdu. It reaches deeper in my heart

 

[Al-zakir]

we had more than long discussion on this so i am not going to start again but i'd prefer arabic if i have to use arabic script. cause learning arabic for me is no way harder than learning urdu. I like islamic nasheed in Bangla than urdu. It reaches deeper in my heart

Very cool brother. I can understand that...........No problem form my side.

 

[TopCat]

He isn't imposing on us. All he is saying is that Urdu was and is favorable language to religious scholars in subcontinent because of its Arabic script. Urdu compliment Arabic little different than bangla. That all.

50% of Muslim and Islamic scholars lived in Bengal. So before he took this decission, did he consult with Bengali religious scholar??? Where are those scholars now??? I even asked some of Pakistani scholars whether it is Islamic to have Urdu instead of Bengali. They just bashed that idea out...
Dont denigrate my beloved Islam, only by quoting some very unislamic ideas.... which has nothing to do with Islam. Go and talk to some scholars first before you yourself become a scholar...

 

[Communist]

In case of language Muslims from Bangladesh should gradually try to get rid of the sanskrit devanagri obsession for their own good.

 

[Al-zakir]

Well, I dont know whether you watch "Jibon Jiggasa" a NTV program where the person (which is most respected islamic scholar in Bangaldesh, and the persident of Imam Samity organization of all Imams) was asked whether is it permittable in Islam to listen to Rabindra Sangit. His answer was, some of Rabindra's songs are so spiritual that even a Muslim can become more close to Allah by listening to them and there is no problem in listening to Rabindhra Sangit.

I hope you understand now...

Do you mean "apnar giggasa" and are you talking about Allama Abul kalam Azad.

Is it possible to get "you tube" links where he said that. I would like to hear that form his mouth and in what way he answer the question.

 

[TopCat]

Do you mean "apnar giggasa" and are you talking about Allama Abul kalam Azad.

Is it possible to get "you tube" links where he said that. I would like to hear that form his mouth and in what way he answer the question.

Sorry i saw it in TV. You can just send him an email and he will answer again.

PS: Ask him a direct question. Dont ask him whether you could do a Puja to Rabindhra. He will get pissed...

 

[Communist]

50&#37; of Muslim and Islamic scholars lived in Bengal. So before he took this decission, did he consult with Bengali religious scholar??? Where are those scholars now??? I even asked some of Pakistani scholars whether it is Islamic to have Urdu instead of Bengali. They just bashed that idea out...
Dont denigrate my beloved Islam, only by quoting some very unislamic ideas.... which has nothing to do with Islam. Go and talk to some scholars first before you yourself become a scholar...

Now you are talking about scholars. Yes there are many hired scholars who are used as tools by the enemies to spread ideological corruption in Islam.

Taslima Nasreen, a **** story writer, herself once claimed to be such scholar. We know that very well.

 

[Al-zakir]

Dont denigrate my beloved Islam, only by quoting some very unislamic ideas.... which has nothing to do with Islam. Go and talk to some scholars first before you yourself become a scholar...

Your beloved Islam yeh. How about changing this vulgar avatar of yours for the sake of Islam and prove yourself worthy of a Muslim first before preaching me anything about Islam. I am not diluted when comes to my Islamic root. You are a joke man.

 

[TopCat]

In case of language Muslims from Bangladesh should gradually try to get rid of the sanskrit devanagri obsession for their own good.

Sanskrit is a oral language and it does not have a script. Dont you know that???

 

[Al-zakir]

Sorry i saw it in TV. You can just send him an email and he will answer again.

PS: Ask him a direct question. Dont ask him whether you could do a Puja to Rabindhra. He will get pissed...

Well I don't need ask him because I don't like his music and never listen to it in my life.

As Allama Delwar Hussain saydee said " He may be a good poet but he is Musrik so therefor Muslim should not follow him and his work with blind eye because there is a chance of that Muslim to be Hindu mentality Muslim"

unfortunately he is right and that why some of our Muslim don't see anything wrong with celebration of bangla new year with animal all around which is un-Islamic.

 

[Sambha]

Sanskrit is a oral language and it does not have a script. Dont you know that???

Thank you.

Where is the subscribe button.

 

[Communist]

Sanskrit is a oral language and it does not have a script. Dont you know that???

Who told you that? Are you talking about Vedas? I did not get your point...