What's new

If missing jet made it to Andaman Sea, did Indian radars fail to detect it?

Mate, once assume that the plane indeed pass through Andamans..........

You mean to say that the navy intercepted it but deliberately chose not to disclose as there radar capabilities will be out in open??

We can't just assume since then we can also assume that it crashed in Malaysian waters. The point here is that the radar system of three countries didn't notice a giant aircraft.

One imp question is -

What would be the IAF response if such aircraft enters Indian airspace with all communication system turned off?

Simply give them a warning and ask them to turn around, or they will have escort it and force it to land, since that is the international law.
 
what is the range of India Radars in A&N ??

what kind of Radars are installed in A&N?

That's the point mate nobody outside of the military knows since these are defense points that have to be kept under guard. If they simply give out sensitive details then what's the point of installing them when the enemy can simply bypass them and get around our defenses.
 
I have heard there are 5 indian citizens on board.I can understand the tough their families in india are facing right now((
 
The possibility that the missing Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 could have made it to the Andaman Sea, off the coast of the Andaman & Nicobar Islands, could raise questions about the effectiveness of India's air defence systems.


If the flight did enter the Andaman Sea, on way to the Bay of Bengal, Indian air defence radars should have ideally detected it.

The possibility of the aircraft heading into this area came up on Saturday when Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak mentioned it as one of the two possible routes the missing plane took.

According to him, the joint investigation by Malaysian and global agencies indicated a distinct possibility that flight MH370 was near the Andaman Islands.

According to senior Indian Air Force (IAF) officials, India does maintain a radar north of Port Blair in the Andaman Islands. This radar is primarily directed at the Myanmar's Coco Islands, which is believed to serve as a base for Chinese military activity.

However, with a range of about 200 nautical miles, it can detect air movement in the area.

"We use primary radars that can detect any movement in the air. The radar coverage in the Andamans is limited, but capable," a senior air force official told HT on the condition of anonymity since he is not authorised to speak to the media.

Civilian radars used by Air Traffic Controllers across the globe use secondary radars that use data streaming in from transponders fitted on board the aircraft. These radars are programmed to avoid detecting other flying objects but can be picked up by the primary radars that the military uses.

"The radars that we have in the Andaman Islands have a range of about 200 NM, but our shore-based radars usually have limited coverage," former naval chief Admiral Sureesh Mehta told HT.

Mehta, who is also a navy combat pilot, is familiar with the tri-service command capabilities that are present on the Andaman Islands.

"While the Andamans are designated as a Flight Information Region (global earmarked spaces to track aircraft), it is not on the air corridor taken by civilian aircrafts," he said.

"But if anything were to happen in this FIR, it will be our responsibility."

The Boeing 777 is capable of flying non-stop between long distances such as New Delhi and New York and therefore Andamans and the east coast of India has emerged as one of the two possible routes that the aircraft took after leaving Kuala Lumpur.

Incidentally, the Malaysian PM Razak confirmed that the transponder and the communications on board the missing flight had been "deliberately" switched off. This raises concerns about a possible hijacking of MH 370.

If missing jet made it to Andaman Sea, did Indian radars fail to detect it? - Hindustan Times

If true, than this is the serious loophole in Indian defense set-up.

Too may ifs and buts ....
 
A quote from Prasun K. Sengupta -

He isn’t entirely right & let me explain why. When one talks about military radars, there are two types of them: one is for military ATC & the other one is for airspace surveillance. While the former is reqd to be operational 24/7, the same cannot be said for the latter since the latter has a service life of only 29,000 hours & is therefore used sparingly during peacetime only during exercises. What this Caucasian has been referring to are Malaysia’s S-743 Martello & RAT-31DL airspace surveillance radars located at Kuantan facing the South China Sea & at Penang facing the Andaman Sea. It is extremely likely that both these radars were not operational on March 8. Instead, what was operational & fully functional was the RMAF’s network of ATC radars (each with a primary surveillance antenna & a secondary surveillance antenna, plus a built-in IFF interrogator). What is, however, most surprising is that despite picking up an unidentified track (reportedly MH-370), the RMAF did not mobilise any of its combat aircraft from either Kuantan or Gong Kedak or Penang in order to investigate this unidentified flying object on the night of March 8. As for overhead recce satellites, they can detect objects only when such objects are floating on the surface. The mere fact that no part of the debris has so far been located by the satellites only means that MH-370 crashed in deeper waters (which excludes the Gulf of Thailand) somewhere in either the Andaman Sea or the eastern fringes of the Bay of Bengal. If that’s the case, then the debris will began to surface about five days after the crash.
 
Come on people.... How come a giant plane not be detected in the radars of Indonesia, Malaysia, and Indian's....... There's nothing weird plane fell into the sea... maybe there's no wreckage..... My opinion it's in the bottom of the Ocean.
 
There have been reports that A&N can be the new Kargil, we have to seriously think about the security of A&N if the plane flown right over it undetected.
This is nonsensical- think about it. How can a heavily militarised set of islands belonging to India many 1000s of KMs away from Pakistan, sat in the middle of the ocean become the next Kargil? If any Kargil-like occupation was to occur, those fools would be annihilated within days- quite easily.


@Topic, news emerging now points away from the A&N islands to central Asia and the like so non-news, just Indian media speculation....
 
Actually, if the reports are true, it's raises serious questions about Indonesia's air defence network, since the plane would have flown directly over their airspace.

It's too early to raise alarm bells over India's preparedness in the region. Especially since we don't know yet if the plane made another turn subsequent in it's flight.
If this news is true then Chinese Navy and airforce will have a gala time in our oceans.

I hope MH-370 has landed safely somewhere.ahem ahem....this is going to rub many here in the wrong way :D
Read this Indee.
Malaysian Missing plane could have been hijacked to Pakistan: US media
 
If this news is true then Chinese Navy and airforce will have a gala time in our oceans.

I hope MH-370 has landed safely somewhere.ahem ahem....this is going to rub many here in the wrong way :D
Read this Indee.
Malaysian Missing plane could have been hijacked to Pakistan: US media

I read that. Hilarious stuff.:lol: Now that would raise serious questions over our Maritime safety infrastructure.

The Andaman and Nicobar Islands are being adequately upgraded these days. We might soon deploy a Green Pine or Sword Fish radar there as well(if they aren't already) in addition to a few Su 30s. But no country can harm the islands in any manner and get away with it. A non-state terror attack might be possible though. :whistle:
 
It shouldnt, it means that Pakistan has developed technology that can beat the world's most advanced radar and satellite monitoring systems and mask as large an object as an airliner.
images
 
maybe the plane is fitted with explosives and it would move towards its target anytime soon?
 
I read that. Hilarious stuff.:lol: Now that would raise serious questions over our Maritime safety infrastructure.

The Andaman and Nicobar Islands are being adequately upgraded these days. We might soon deploy a Green Pine or Sword Fish radar there as well(if they aren't already) in addition to a few Su 30s. But no country can harm the islands in any manner and get away with it. A non-state terror attack might be possible though. :whistle:
Andamans are too far.And worst is that thise islands are closer to mainland China. :tsk:
And there are just too many islands.:(

It shouldnt, it means that Pakistan has developed technology that can beat the world's most advanced radar and satellite monitoring systems and mask as large an object as an airliner.
images

Best of luck then your best friend will soon turn into your worst enemy :D
Remember this is one mission which united all the countries in south asia....hehehehe.
Too big a risk isnt it??? :lol:
 
Back
Top Bottom