ICJ hearing on Kulbhushan Jadhav case : News, Updates & Discussions

[KingChris]

hey wait judges denied the video to not play it in court it will be in favour of pak because how can judges deny the confessional video it is against law.

Simply because video evidence have no credibility when it comes to court. Evidence should be concrete, there is a lot of edits in that video. Why?
If the judge did not want to play the video, it only means they are not giving it face value.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Simply because video evidence have no credibility when it comes to court. Evidence should be concrete, there is a lot of edits in that video. Why?
If the judge did not want to play the video, it only means they are not giving it face value.

Any evidence related to establishing Yadav's 'guilt' (with respect to the allegations made against him by Pakistan) would be outside the scope of the current ICJ hearing. The ICJ is not conducting a trial to establish Yadav's guilt.

 

[kabooter_maila]

India does not have to provide any evidence, its Pakistan who has to provide evidence. They have shown nothing but a doctored tape of confession.

Why then you went to the ICJ? You will need to prove what is the urgency? How the case is in the jurisdiction of the ICJ? And what the heck that terrorist monkey was doing in Pakistan when he was busted? Pakistan simply needs to show the statements of murderer Modi and other filthy sadhus threatening Pakistan to break Balochsitan from the rest of the country? Indians have no legal basis for this case. You will have to prove whatever non-sense you have claimed if the court, by any chance, decides to continue proceedings.

 

[Lord Of Gondor]

Ouch
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...-to-pak-harish-salve/articleshow/58686896.cms

 

[Spring Onion]

indians here claimed that yadav was already dead

indians are under curry hangover so don't mind. they will continue to emmit BS

 

[NakedLunch]

We all know that ICJ has no jurisdiction in the matter of National Security. My worries are towards the ICJ, the way they immediately started the hearing with in few days and only gave Pakistan couple of days for hearing is clearing showing something fishy behind this. I think Pakistan should have asked for some times to prepare the case more solidly. I still believe that Jadhev's sentense will be turned into Life prisionment and will be used as bargaining chip.

Maybe. But what the ICJ can not do is force Pakistan to acquit him. That is not within their remit. India wants his return. That cant happen. Nawaz Shareef will not want to be seen as the PM who released such a high value asset from India. India wants him back and we cant and must not let him return. This is probably a good time to call in a favour from China. If anyone can influence an International Tribunal it is China. All these courts are subject to political influence, make no mistake about that. This man is responsible for the deaths of scores of Pakistanis and destabilising the Pakistani State. Nawaz Shareef is already being described as a threat to National Security. If he lets this guy walk, that will only add credence to that charge.

 

[Emmie]

Let the court decide that in a fair & just trial. Every human has his inviolable rights and they cannot be violated for whims & fancies of few. If we start taking lives left & right ,center then then there will be no difference between animals & humans.

Sorry but the court isn't going to decide fairness or unfairness of the trial, all it's going to decide is consular access. Couldn't agree more with rest of your post! But we shouldn't overlook the fact that Yadav is a con, he is handed death sentence for espionage and killing innocent Pakistanis. We all know the fate of terrorists, don't we?

 

[war&peace]

Well ICJ has no jurisdiction over Pakistan's national security. Pakistan should hang him and not accept any dictation over this issue.

Any evidence related to establishing Yadav's 'guilt' (with respect to the allegations made against him by Pakistan) would be outside the scope of the current ICJ hearing. The ICJ is not conducting a trial to establish Yadav's guilt.

Then what is it doing?

Pakistan has fought her case very well but the way ICJ has responded the Indian request overnight and asked for hearing is bit of worry sign for Pakistan as it is clearing showing that ICJ has some tilt toward Indian side.

Just hang him and show a middle finger to ICJ.

 

[kabooter_maila]

.... I still believe that Jadhev's sentense will be turned into Life prisionment and will be used as bargaining chip.

We don't chase shadows. What will happen to the terrorist monkey in future, just leave that to the national leadership. They have the mandate and responsibility. I mean both the political and military leadership.

 

[Spring Onion]

Pakistan me bhi saalan banta hai bahi..

welcome doc. banta hay banta hay bas zarra humain hangover kam hee hota hay. hum curry chakhtay hain sala ap log to lagta ha ashnan kartay ho curry ka. wesay phaisla anay tak kia harz hay joke marnay main thread to already bhartion k gems say bhar gaya hay

Sorry but the court isn't going to decide fairness or unfairness of the trial, all it's going to decide is consular access. Couldn't agree more with rest of your post! But we shouldn't overlook the fact that Yadav is a con, he is handed death sentence for espionage and killing innocent Pakistanis. We all know the fate of terrorists, don't we?

when Pakistan arrested kalbhushan and told India about his links official links with indian government they did not accept him for over one week.
then finally India owned him as former naval officer. during ICJ hearing indian lawyer claimed that Pakistan condionalized counsular acess to kalbhushan. now if we take his argument for pondering then a question arises that as per indian claim if Pakistan had asked you to be part of investigations and get access to him then why india refused joint investigation in this case?? is it that india did not have any evidence to prove Pakistani claim wrong?

 

[hussain0216]

Let the court decide that in a fair & just trial. Every human has his inviolable rights and they cannot be violated for whims & fancies of few. If we start taking lives left & right ,center then then there will be no difference between animals & humans.

Are you learning this now after years of fake encounters?

 

[war&peace]

National security is ensured by the nation. BTW is there any political leadership...that's not leadership but political criminalship or mafia and our military leadership has not shown any spine so far and thus people get pretty vocal from now on about all the issues of national security to keep pressure on them.

 

[cerberus]

ow if we take his argument for pondering then a question arises that as per indian claim if Pakistan had asked you to be part of investigations and get access to him then why india refused joint investigation in this case??

Why should India Follow Pakistan condition When We have every right consular access under international LAW

when Pakistan arrested kalbhushan and told India about his links official links with indian government they did not accept him for over one week.

Again Wrong India Accepted And demand For consular access since day after Indian high commissioner Made to know his arrest.Our consular harish salve put this fact on ICJ with Written submission

 

[Green Arrow]

Maybe. But what the ICJ can not do is force Pakistan to acquit him. That is not within their remit. India wants his return. That cant happen. Nawaz Shareef will not want to be seen as the PM who released such a high value asset from India. India wants him back and we cant and must not let him return. This is probably a good time to call in a favour from China. If anyone can influence an International Tribunal it is China. All these courts are subject to political influence, make no mistake about that. This man is responsible for the deaths of scores of Pakistanis and destabilising the Pakistani State. Nawaz Shareef is already being described as a threat to National Security. If he lets this guy walk, that will only add credence to that charge.

Pakistan should not have said this that We are not going to hang him immediately and he still has 6 month. I think this might gives the impression that the death penalty is not the final verdict and it can be overturned but then I think that Europe is quite against the death penalty and it might be some kind of trick to reduce the ICJ's fear.

 

[Spring Onion]

Why should India Follow Pakistan condition When We have every right consular access under international LAW

Again Wrong India Accepted And demand For consular access since day after Indian high commissioner Made to know his arrest.Our consular harish salve put this fact on ICJ with Written submission

Pakistan denied putting any condition. and no you cannot have acess to him.
thirdly ypu were supposed to take part in investigations for sake of your own citizen not on demand of Pakistan. Pakistan offered you the fairest thing and that is joint investigation into his case so You should be satisfied but seems you guys are even afraid of your own shadows.
even getting counsular access would change anything . indian modi government is doing emotional politics over life of Kalbhushan to save own image that is all.