How did Jammu and Kashmir become a part of India? 9 facts on Accession Day

[MultaniGuy]

To be fair we can match them there with slums of Karachi with exactly same [ethnic] people only with a Muslim twist. We need to look at towns that are typical of each country.

We do not share any ethnic groups with India. Punjabis only make 3% of Indian population.

Muhajirs who make up Karachi may be Gujarati and people from Maharashtra.

Otherwise than that, I do not see any ethnic commonality with Indians.

To be fair we can match them there with slums of Karachi with exactly same [ethnic] people only with a Muslim twist. We need to look at towns that are typical of each country.

The slums of Karachi is not as bad as the slums of Mumbai.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Muhajirs who make up Karachi may be Gujarati and people from Maharashtra.

Yes your right but Karach is a exception. More then half of Karachi shares the same ethnic roots in India. Thus Karachi is just less exciting version of Mumbai but transplanted in the desert coast of Sindh. Even has similar problems like huge slums.

The slums of Karachi is not as bad as the slums of Mumbai.

True but Mumbai at least offers Bollywood and dazzle. Karachi is just a monochrome version of Mumbai.

 

[MultaniGuy]

Yes your right but Karach is a exception. More then half of Karachi shares the same ethnic roots in India. Thus Karachi is just less exciting version of Mumbai but transplanted in the desert coast of Sindh. Even has similar problems like huge slums.

True but Mumbai at least offers Bollywood and dazzle. Karachi is just a monochrome version of Mumbai.

Well at least we have Lollywood.

 

[padamchen]

Perhaps offer them Marathi India as another....?

The Hindus screwed that up on their own. As they have throughout their history.

You guys (subcontinental Muslims) got 200 years of breathing space as a result.

And a nation to arm behind.

I understand why @Indus Pakistan loves the Brits.

I've never understood why the rest of you don't eugolise them.

You dodged an existential bullet thanks to them.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Roybot]

To be fair we can match them there with slums of Karachi with exactly same [ethnic] people only with a Muslim twist. We need to look at towns that are typical of each country.

No one calls Pakistan a failed state because of what it's cities and towns look like, its for other reasons. You should refer to the failed state index and the methodology they use for that.

P.S: This is also Kolkata. So stop cherry picking.

 

[MultaniGuy]

No one calls Pakistan a failed state because of what it's cities and towns look like, its for other reasons. You should refer to the failed state index and the methodology they use for that.

P.S: This is also Kolkata. So stop cherry picking.

You are also cherry picking. You are just showing one good district of Kolkata.

We all know most of Kolkata doesn't look like that.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

No one calls Pakistan a failed state because of what it's cities and towns look like, its for other reasons. You should refer to the failed state index and the methodology they use for that.

P.S: This is also Kolkata. So stop cherry picking.

The same people who call Pakistan a failed state are the same people who claimed Iraq has WMD that can destroy Europe in 30 mins..................Go figure.........

 

[padamchen]

You are also cherry picking. You are just showing one good district of Kolkata.

We all know most of Kolkata doesn't look like that.

Calcutta is a lovely city.

You can breathe the era of the Raj there.

It's the city I love the most since boyhood.

Pure character ....

Cheers, Doc

 

[SabzShaheen]

What is your grievance? Ethnic Kashmiris did not become part of Pak or they are not independent?

Replace 'independent' with 'free' and you have your answer. There are many successful Pakistani Kashmiris in and out of Pakistan. Unfortunately, part of their homeland is occupied.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Meanwhile India is setting up military bases in the same regions you would like to block our way to.

You cannot contain India.

You can only join back. At least try.

Or you will eventually descend further into mediocrity bordering a failed state.

Cheers, Doc

..........there is more chance of Pakistan becoming a part of Brazil and Germany than joining up with india...........

 

[Indus Pakistan]

You should refer to the failed state index and the methodology they use for that.

I can as easily set up a Index and churn out the results to my liking. The one you are refering to is some western source with a axe to grind. It carries no objectivity. And the video you posted is cherrypicked. That way I can cherypick as well. The videos I posted were typical from the streets.

Lahore

Peshawar

 

[padamchen]

..........there is more chance of Pakistan becoming a part of Brazil and Germany than joining up with india...........

Not really.

I was speaking to a German a couple of days back.

About reunification. And Germany 30 years later.

I can tell you bro that even with reunification you guys have a big struggle and a tough road back.

Without it, I'm afraid you guys will continue jumping from one sponsor state to another, till they want to play you. And you have a purpose that furthers their own agenda.

Americans. Chinese. Turks. Saudis. Russians.

You will go through them all.Till there is no one left to go to.

And then you will realise the time you wasted. And the hard won opportunity.

That you are and always will be Hindustani Musalmans. Nothing else.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Roybot]

You are also cherry picking. You are just showing one good district of Kolkata.

We all know most of Kolkata doesn't look like that.

I said, this is also Kolkata, how is that cherry picking!!!!

I can as easily set up a Index and churn out the results to my liking. The one you are refering to is some western source with a axe to grind. It carries no objectivity.

Well then stop having a sulk about it

 

[MultaniGuy]

Not really.

I was speaking to a German a couple of days back.

About reunification. And Germany 30 years later.

I can tell you bro that even with reunification you guys have a big struggle and a tough road back.

Without it, I'm afraid you guys will continue jumping from one sponsor state to another, till they want to play you. And you have a purpose that furthers their own agenda.

Americans. Chinese. Turks. Saudis. Russians.

You will go through them all.Till there is no one left to go to.

And then you will realise the time you wasted. And the hard won opportunity.

That you are and always will be Hindustani Musalmans. Nothing else.

Cheers, Doc

Sorry buddy, we have nothing in common with Indians.
Maybe only the Gujarati, Maharashtra, and Uttar Pradesh Muhajirs do.

Punjabis only make 3% of Indian population.

O

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Well then stop having a sulk about it

I was not sulking. You need to find out what that word means before using it. I was merely showing the slumdog face of India.

Sorry buddy, we have nothing in common with Indians.
Maybe only the Gujarati, Maharashtra, and Uttar Pradesh Muhajirs do.

Punjabis only make 3% of Indian population.

The problem is everybody uses Karachi as a exposition of what Pakistan is. The fact that it is only 5% of Pakistan cuts no ice when they go running to some slum in Karachi called "Bihar nagar or Delhi basti or Lucknow goth" where it's obvious the residents are from and then croak "hey we be the same". That is like Sikh from Jallandhar landing in Southall, UK and exclaiming "hey we be same".