It's still a generalizing & stereotyping. It's like saying "All Sindhis are not corrupt people but all corrupt people are Sindhis." I would like to think of myself as an educated person belonging to an educated family. Or at least I was educated enough to serve with a prestigious military organization in a civilian capacity for some years. Most educated Sindhis are hard working and quite successful people, & they have achieved their position on merit. In Karachi, you'll find more Sindhi doctors than ever. Every next bank teller is a Sindhi. Factories increasing prefer Sindhi employees. Most security guards outside banks and homes are Sindhis. The knowledge and intelligence of the younger generation of Sindhis from cities like Hyderabad, Sukhar, etc, will give you run for your money. Sindh writers produce & publish literature on a daily basis (you read that right). I have an urban upbringing with strong rural roots. Even with my strong distaste for rural life, I have discovered that most uneducated or less literate people (including many waderas) of Sindh are of a higher character & more generous in their behavior. Flip the coin & see that what you perceive to be a 'khota sika' is not only NOT KHOTA but increasingly becoming value maximizing. In short, look at the other side of the picture.
Sindhis by and large do not like PPP, whether educated or illiterate, urban or rural. The urban Sindhis, especially ones living in Karachi, do not even vote them. Their vote went to PTI in the last two elections. But overall vote goes to PPP, not because Sindhis like them but because we lack strong alternative that could represent us on the federal level. Since the creation of Pakistan, even the most rural constituencies have rejected ethno-nationalists (some who held separatist ideologies) in favor of those who can represent the province & its people (no matter who they are) on the national level. No other province has completely or comprehensively rejected such ethno-nationalists. No wonder Quaid and Muhtarma Fatimah Jinnah found more support in Sindh province than anywhere else. In 2018 Elections one major reason the anti-PPP opposition could not gain seats was that they brought in goons, including nationalists. Let's not go into the debate on who created this goon-alliance. PTI had a chance to prove itself to Sindhis (& Urdu speaking people) with their 2018 electoral win. But now with the gas crisis, Sindhis are being pushed back to PPP. I'll also not be surprised to see the resurgence of MQM if things keep going the way they are.
I suppose the original poster - to whom I took offense - is not going to humble himself. But let us be humble & respectful to each other. Our words & ignorance hurt our Bengali brothers & look at what happened in the end. Now that I have vented myself here, let's just end this discussion here & talk of our future submarines, who perhaps will not be called Sindhi Class, or Balochi Class, or Pakistani Class, but they'll be our pride, prestige & main naval punch.
