What's new

Govt will have to raise power tariff by 30pc to revive IMF programme

maithil

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 21, 2010
Messages
4,017
Reaction score
-80
Country
India
Location
India
: In a bid to revive the stalled $6 billion IMF programme, the government will have to hike electricity tariff by around 30 percent and put in place a viable plan to erase the monster of circular debt.

Background discussions with top government functionaries as well donors’ representatives in Islamabad told this correspondent on Thursday that without undertaking comprehensive structural reforms, the power sector woes could not be minimised. “The patchwork cannot deliver anymore, so serious reforms are required to erase the monster of circular debt in gradual but sustained manner,” they said.

The circular debt already peaked to Rs2.2 trillion and it increased at supersonic speed in the aftermath of outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic. Now the government will have to take corrective measures to stop its accumulation because if it was not curtailed then there would be addition of Rs500 billion in the current fiscal year.

The status quo approach will provide no solution so it is hoped that the government will come up with viable plan to minimise both stocks and flows of this problem,” said the official sources.

The Ministry of Finance alarmed Prime Minister Imran Khan after which the Subsidies Cell was established under supervision of former secretary finance Dr Waqar Masood. The Ministry of Finance through a circular issued on July 23, 2020 stated that the prime minister is pleased to appoint Dr Waqar Masood as head of newly established Subsidies Cell.

With change of guard at the Power Division with appointment of Omar Rasul, there is hope that the ministry would come up with comprehensive plan and to implement it in order to come out from the increasing mess on cash bleeding power sector.

On power tariff hike, there will be three heads coming under consideration including fuel price adjustments (FPA), quarterly adjustments and placing new tariff so the rough estimates suggested that the government would have to increase electricity tariff by around 30 percent. There is no alternate but to hike the tariff immediately because delays would escalate the requirement for increasing more prices of electricity, said the official.

The government has not yet passed on tariff for K-Electric consumers despite getting approval from the ECC. It was shocking for Adviser to PM on Finance Dr Abdul Hafeez Shaikh and his economic team that the ministers sitting in the ECC favoured the decision to pass on raise in power tariff to consumers but in the federal cabinet they opposed it on political grounds.


A top official commented that the government would have to make up its mind that whether the decision making would be made on economic grounds or political consideration would be given top priority because uncertainty would lead us nowhere so it would cause loss on both political and economic grounds.

When contacted, Dr Khaqan Najeeb, who had earlier served as Adviser to Ministry of Finance, told this correspondent on Thursday that power sector sustainability is a lifeline for the economy. Key issues need to be resolved.

He said reducing line losses and increasing recoveries are a must which if left unhandled can add Rs200 billion in FY-2021 to circular debt.

In addition, key issues of AJK and tribal districts power payments remain unsettled. Tax issues of uncollected GST and late payment surcharge payable on the whopping payables of around Rs1,200 billion will further aggravate circular debt levels.

Passing quarterly and yearly tariff in a staggered manner may be difficult but necessary, he added. Dr Khaqan emphasised on a medium-term horizon commercial orientation of Discos (power distribution companies), generation mix management and increased supply are likely to help. Rs509 billion is owed by private sector to government in power payments and large numbers are running defaulters. A change in law to declare non-payment as an offence as in the case of bounced bank cheques is the solution, he concluded.

https://www.thenews.com.pk/amp/6946...evive-imf-programme?__twitter_impression=true
 
.
Don't catch electricity thieves, don't control power theft, don't upgrade transmission network. But yeah easy way add everything in electricity bill because our per capita has already surpassed USA. So now its time to charge 20-30 cent per KWh.

Freaking incompetent people leading us.

Aasman se gira gira khajoor me atka.
 
. .
they should divert this tax to some other source as expensive electricity damage economy much more
 
.
Don't catch electricity thieves, don't control power theft, don't upgrade transmission network. But yeah easy way add everything in electricity bill because our per capita has already surpassed USA. So now its time to charge 20-30 cent per KWh.

Freaking incompetent people leading us.

Aasman se gira gira khajoor me atka.

Spot on bro.
 
.
Immediate:
- Privatize DISCOs - private companies will deal with the theft which has been lingering on and on.

- Close old inefficient GENCOs

Medium Term:

- Move to Hydel and Thar coal to reduce price and eliminate imported fuel
 
.
Don't catch electricity thieves, don't control power theft, don't upgrade transmission network. But yeah easy way add everything in electricity bill because our per capita has already surpassed USA. So now its time to charge 20-30 cent per KWh.

Freaking incompetent people leading us.

Aasman se gira gira khajoor me atka.
Alot of this rise will be due to rupee devaluation
At average of 18rs its barely at 10-11 cents
Even without line loses we are in trouble because we are locked in expensive coal(9cents) and furnace oil deals (12+ cents)

Only solution is increase the cost for high users end subsidy for agriculture (ask them to switch to solar on govt grantee loan if u have to) and switch all GENCO to coal /gas. Close the inefficient GENCOs.
Renegotate some IPPs contracts if u can.
Imvest heavily in transmission
Wait for relief given by trio completion of cheap hydro from dasu munda bhasha
Other hydros need to be renegotaited on 40-50 years BOT contract to decrease cost
 
.
Immediate:
- Privatize DISCOs - private companies will deal with the theft which has been lingering on and on.

- Close old inefficient GENCOs

Medium Term:

- Move to Hydel and Thar coal to reduce price and eliminate imported fuel

can’t privatize loss making assets, isko kaise privatise karaingay.
 
.
Alot of this rise will be due to rupee devaluation
At average of 18rs its barely at 10-11 cents
Even without line loses we are in trouble because we are locked in expensive coal(9cents) and furnace oil deals (12+ cents)

Only solution is increase the cost for high users end subsidy for agriculture (ask them to switch to solar on govt grantee loan if u have to) and switch all GENCO to coal /gas. Close the inefficient GENCOs.
Renegotate some IPPs contracts if u can.
Imvest heavily in transmission
Wait for relief given by trio completion of cheap hydro from dasu munda bhasha
Other hydros need to be renegotaited on 40-50 years BOT contract to decrease cost

For your info we are getting 40% from hydel at an average cost of 2-3 cents max. Crude amd furnace oil usage has decreased to even less than 10% if i am not mistaken. Then we have nuclear which is cheaper too. Coal agreement was at 10-12pkr per unit. Around 6-8 cents. So Inshort most of electricity on average production is 6-10 cents.
But major problem for circular debt are three
1- Electricity Theft
2- Old Infrastructure and Line Losses
3- IPPs favoured contracts in many of which govt. Has to pay them in dollar for fix amount of power generation, even if govt. Utilise it or not its its upto them and one more thing its been reported that some of them generating less than agreed upon but charging for full generation.

Now if you look at Electricity bill 25-30% is tax. Even if govt. Just charges electricity price many will not have any issue. But no one is there to ask them where the fck these taxes go. Then they have issues of early and late reading for increasing slab units.

If you look into whole fck is to loot common man while elite classes has legal ways to use all the laws in their favour.

The question need to b asked even with cheapest labour why we are paying for most expensive electricity in the world, while govt. Mantra is to increase exports. I don't know from where they have these advisors.

What i believe even a little sincere effort from govt. can decrease per unit cost by 30-40%. But ofcourse it need hardwork and daring. Which our incompetent lott can't do.
 
.
can’t privatize loss making assets, isko kaise privatise karaingay.
Says who? KESC, all the banks that were privatized were in deep loss. Now they are all making profits and contributing tax revenue instead of sucking in resources like they used to.
 
.
For your info we are getting 40% from hydel at an average cost of 2-3 cents max. Crude amd furnace oil usage has decreased to even less than 10% if i am not mistaken. Then we have nuclear which is cheaper too. Coal agreement was at 10-12pkr per unit. Around 6-8 cents. So Inshort most of electricity on average production is 6-10 cents.
But major problem for circular debt are three
1- Electricity Theft
2- Old Infrastructure and Line Losses
3- IPPs favoured contracts in many of which govt. Has to pay them in dollar for fix amount of power generation, even if govt. Utilise it or not its its upto them and one more thing its been reported that some of them generating less than agreed upon but charging for full generation.

Now if you look at Electricity bill 25-30% is tax. Even if govt. Just charges electricity price many will not have any issue. But no one is there to ask them where the fck these taxes go. Then they have issues of early and late reading for increasing slab units.

If you look into whole fck is to loot common man while elite classes has legal ways to use all the laws in their favour.

The question need to b asked even with cheapest labour why we are paying for most expensive electricity in the world, while govt. Mantra is to increase exports. I don't know from where they have these advisors.

What i believe even a little sincere effort from govt. can decrease per unit cost by 30-40%. But ofcourse it need hardwork and daring. Which our incompetent lott can't do.
Hydro cost is around 5 rs and has around 20% share in production

Rest of electricity(including IPP Hydro) comes at cost of 8-16 cents which in rupees will be 14-26 rupees (~165rs)
 
.
Hydro cost is around 5 rs and has around 20% share in production

Rest of electricity(including IPP Hydro) comes at cost of 8-16 cents which in rupees will be 14-26 rupees (~165rs)
Let me know which major IPP hydro is costing us 16 cents, even in last reports furnace oil wss costing us 21-24 pkr. No major hydro ever costed us 25PKR.

Kindly do share your source for 20% hydel power from govt. Ones.
If you add tarbela, mangla alone will b like 15-20% of total power generation.

Well here is the source regarding furnace oil and hydel power. Furnace oil is just 3%.

The fiscal year 2020 was marked by a move towards hydropower and coal based power generation, over gas and furnace oil. Hydel power made up 32% of total power in fiscal year 2020, compared to 26% in 2019, while coal’s share went up from 13% in 2019 to 21% in 2020. Gas generated power’s share however, fell from 18% in fiscal year 2019 to 12% in fiscal year 2020, while furnace oil’s share fell from 7% last year to 3% this year. RLNG, or regasified liquefied natural gas, contributed 20% to the overall power mix, nuclear generation took up 8%, wind-based power took up 2%, while ‘other’ (solar, bagasse) took up 2%.
https://profit.pakistantoday.com.pk...tion-in-pakistan-rising-despite-the-pandemic/
 
.
We are producing more than 60% from hydel, coal and nuclear with avg cost of 2-8 cents max except rare power plant.

It means there is something wrong somewhere. Or its easiest way for the govt. To earn money.
 
.
So now end consumers will have to pay for the circular debt that accumulated because of govt inefficiency and corruption? Way to go IK.
 
.
For your info we are getting 40% from hydel at an average cost of 2-3 cents max. Crude amd furnace oil usage has decreased to even less than 10% if i am not mistaken. Then we have nuclear which is cheaper too. Coal agreement was at 10-12pkr per unit. Around 6-8 cents. So Inshort most of electricity on average production is 6-10 cents.
But major problem for circular debt are three
1- Electricity Theft
2- Old Infrastructure and Line Losses
3- IPPs favoured contracts in many of which govt. Has to pay them in dollar for fix amount of power generation, even if govt. Utilise it or not its its upto them and one more thing its been reported that some of them generating less than agreed upon but charging for full generation.

Now if you look at Electricity bill 25-30% is tax. Even if govt. Just charges electricity price many will not have any issue. But no one is there to ask them where the fck these taxes go. Then they have issues of early and late reading for increasing slab units.

If you look into whole fck is to loot common man while elite classes has legal ways to use all the laws in their favour.

The question need to b asked even with cheapest labour why we are paying for most expensive electricity in the world, while govt. Mantra is to increase exports. I don't know from where they have these advisors.

What i believe even a little sincere effort from govt. can decrease per unit cost by 30-40%. But ofcourse it need hardwork and daring. Which our incompetent lott can't do.


It is time to negotiate the contracts with IPP.

This is why when Asad Umar was tweeting about Power generation, I was raising question about circular debt. No one cares about power generation if we can't pay for it.

These constant tweets about power generation is making me lose my trust on PTI. They are acting similarly to PMLN and are misguiding their voters.


BTW 1st principal of a 80 B PKR finance facility to Power holding became due recently. They have not and are in no mood to pay 1st principal installment (only paid markup/interest). They will revolve it surely as they did for previous similar syndicate financing deals some months ago.
 
.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom