What's new

For UNSC seat, India woos Africa

bhagat

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
772
Reaction score
0
NEW DELHI: India will give $250,000 to help build a monument against slavery and remember victims of the slave trade.

Jamaica's envoy to the UN, Raymond Wolfe, said here this week that this one gesture by India would touch hearts in many countries in Africa and the Caribbean, whose ancestors were victims of this scourge. For India, seeking to change the rules of the global high table, UN Security Council (UNSC), a gift like this helps bring many countries around to supporting India's bid for a permanent seat.

As India returns to the UNSC after 20 years, it is determined to push through its bid for a permanent seat. Indian envoy Hardeep Puri observed, "Once we get on, we're not going to get off."

Last week, India brought the UN envoys from cricket-crazy Carribean nations for a long trip -- hobnobbing with the powerful in Delhi and Mumbai, getting a taste of the India growth story as well as Indian hospitality. In April, India has set a bigger task for itself when it hosts a large group of foreign ministers and UN envoys from the least developed countries, a powerful voting bloc in the UN. Among other things, the LDCs may end up issuing a joint document to support India's candidature.

Small island states like Fiji, Papua New Guinea etc were feted in India at the end of 2010. They are a significant voting bloc in the UN. India's high voltage diplomacy will culminate with the India-Africa summit in summer. India is one of the biggest investors in Africa, occupying almost as important a space as China. This self-canvassing is new to India, but foreign office mandarins say they feel quite at home. "This is what we want to do," said one excited official.

They expect that by the end of summer, the UN reform momentum will gather speed. But numbers is not the only game in the UN general assembly.

The Indian campaign for the permanent seat now has five discernible strands. First, canvassing for itself by entertaining waves of diplomats from around the world.

Second, ensure that India adds value to the UN Security Council. This week, Hardeep Puri told the UN to concentrate on humanitarian relief in Haiti rather than interfere in local politics. On Wednesday, India put out a five-point plan to tackle piracy off the Somalian coast. On Africa, on the Middle East, India is raising its voice, where earlier its diplomacy was best practiced by ducking under the radar.

Push the G4. All other members, Japan, Germany and Brazil have also embarked on a similar exercise. But if Germany faces problems with some countries for having yet another European country in the UNSC, Russia is dead opposed to Japan (as is China). In the absence of a peace treaty between Russia and Japan, they're technically still at war. Brazil's opponents lie in the Spanish-speaking world.

Next week, the UNGA will start work on a new report that will give a shape to the reform. This will start the world on a new set of talks on the future shape of the UN.

Last, but in many ways the most difficult is Africa. According to the G4 plan, Africa gets two permanent seats, but none of the African countries have decided which two that may be. This may drag the effort, because it's pointless to push the African Union to take a decision.


For UNSC seat, India woos Africa - The Times of India
 
a 250K monument which actually does not benefit the life of an average poor class hard working peasant will woo Africa for its permanent UNSC seat. What utter nonsense..some people are on seriously cheap afghan opium...
 
a 250K monument which actually does not benefit the life of an average poor class hard working peasant will woo Africa for its permanent UNSC seat. What utter nonsense..some people are on seriously cheap afghan opium...

hahaha. It's not like they are OFFICIALLY SELLING the seat? It just a nice gesture from India, so when the vote or poll or anything else is taken Africa would remember that India helped it [the amount of money doesn't matter but this will create a goodwill for India among African nations] and if India ever gets a UNSC seat it would be friendly towards africa and not hostile. So, they would most likely vote in favour of India rather than oppose it? And btw at least we can 'BUY' the seat. :)
 
$250,000 to buy a UNSC seat? too cheap
 
And the Govt criticizes Mayavati for this,hypocrisy at its best.


_46109678_mayawati_766.jpg
 
hahaha. It's not like they are OFFICIALLY SELLING the seat? It just a nice gesture from India, so when the vote or poll or anything else is taken Africa would remember that India helped it [the amount of money doesn't matter but this will create a goodwill for India among African nations] and if India ever gets a UNSC seat it would be friendly towards africa and not hostile. So, they would most likely vote in favour of India rather than oppose it? And btw at least we can 'BUY' the seat. :)

Yes when millions of Afghans were starving India was offering donations to save the bhuddas of Bamiyan...repeat of stupidity due to lack of protiens!
 
Yes when millions of Afghans were starving India was offering donations to save the bhuddas of Bamiyan...repeat of stupidity due to lack of protiens!

SO? What's your point? We've got more than 90% people living under poverty line [according to your fellow pakistani only] and america still spends $700BILLION dollars on its' defence alone. Does world care about it?! HELL NO!
 
I have some questions:

If India get UNSC seat, What are the benefits of the five UNSC?

If the UNSC is the right to vote, the five UNSC need access to ally to expand its influence.
But the UNSC is veto power.

One vote can Veto, and Two votes are veto. What is the difference?

Why take risks to allowed India get UNSC seat?
Which country can guarantee India will never be against their own? Russia?
Russia also worried about Maoist takeover....
Before 1971,The KMT China supports the USA, and what about the CCP China after 1971?
--------------------------------------------------
If India get UNSC seat, What are the benefits of other countries?
All along, Submitted the motion in these countries, It requires approval of "the five".
Who wants to make "the five" into "the six"?
 
I have some questions:

If India get UNSC seat, What are the benefits of the five UNSC?

If the UNSC is the right to vote, the five UNSC need access to ally to expand its influence.
But the UNSC is veto power.

One vote can Veto, and Two votes are veto. What is the difference?

Why take risks to allowed India get UNSC seat?
Which country can guarantee India will never be against their own? Russia?
Russia also worried about Maoist takeover....
Before 1971,The KMT China supports the USA, and what about the CCP China after 1971?
--------------------------------------------------
If India get UNSC seat, What are the benefits of other countries?
All along, Submitted the motion in these countries, It requires approval of "the five".
Who wants to make "the five" into "the six"?

Well reform is motivated by a sense of fairness and need to be more representative. Not really hard and fast objectives. So it will be interesting to see how it plays out.

Also the seat will not be a seat with veto.
 
Also the seat will not be a seat with veto.

That is right.

As far as I know, not a single P5 member has supported India to get UNSC veto power.

Having a permanent seat without veto power, is not worth very much.
 
Well reform is motivated by a sense of fairness and need to be more representative. Not really hard and fast objectives. So it will be interesting to see how it plays out.

Also the seat will not be a seat with veto.

The UN in its current form is a sham. It does not reflect the current world power balance, rather, it reflects the situation of 1945.

And the veto gives unmitigated power to the permanent members. Urgent reforms which are required IMO are:

1. Abolishing the veto.
2. NO country to be a permanent member, or atleast 10 permanent members from all continents representing both developed and developing countries
 
Back
Top Bottom