What's new

Dr. Zakir Naik says Partition was wrong

South Asian Muslims are f-ed
end of story

As the English say- empire is no more

Mughals are no more, there's no emperor in Delhi or lucknow to save your a**
There's no Abdali, there's no Delhi sultanate
Closest thing to that legacy we have is probably our nuclear warheads and that's about it
Sure if things get better politically you never know
But South Asian Muslim= Pakistan cause Indian Muslims are too oppressed too count, while Bangladesh it too small a country and is not the inheritor of that Muslim culture of South Asia

(FYI - F Naik guy, Pakistan is the best thing to have happened for Muslims, so I mean I am not supporting him in anyway shape or form, just general trajectory of where we're going in a regional sense)
Bangladesh is not irrelevant at all.

Has a huge population, has a thriving economy, and is majority Muslim.

If anything happens in the subcontinent regarding Muslims, undoubtedly Bangladesh will be involved somehow.
 
.
Deep down, Indian muslims saying there shouldn’t have been partition is a cry for help.

It’s pretty clear Pakistan was a right choice for muslims to have an alternative option. Jinnah knew Pakistan won’t be able to accommodate all muslims to Pakistan.
 
.
Deep down, Indian muslims saying there shouldn’t have been partition is a cry for help.

It’s pretty clear Pakistan was a right choice for muslims to have an alternative option. Jinnah knew Pakistan won’t be able to accommodate all muslims to Pakistan.
The original map of Pakistan was almost 1.5 times of current size. We lost a lot. And no, Jinnah never said that Muslims of India should not come to Pakistan.
 
.
Bangladesh is not irrelevant at all.

Has a huge population, has a thriving economy, and is majority Muslim.

If anything happens in the subcontinent regarding Muslims, undoubtedly Bangladesh will be involved somehow.
The biggest challenges in the foreseeable future are the viability of Afghanistan and Pakistan as functioning economies. And Bangladesh's response will be to remain uninvolved. They have shown the wisdom of trying to improve themselves without distractions.
 
.
Partition of what?

Twitter post on no India before 1947.jpg
 
.
The biggest challenges in the foreseeable future are the viability of Afghanistan and Pakistan as functioning economies. And Bangladesh's response will be to remain uninvolved. They have shown the wisdom of trying to improve themselves without distractions.

It looks in near future there will be confrontation between Pak and Afghanistan , Afghanistan has issued a new map of Asia in which they have included half of Pakistan in Aghanistan . Yesterday TTP attacked pak army in waziristan , it looks Afganistan is not taking action against ttp.
 
.
The Maurya Empire of Pataliputra (Patna), Bihar, under the rule of Ashoka The Great, governed a territory much larger than that of the British Raj.
1692769421447.jpeg

All empires in the Indian subcontinent originated from the province of Bihar in India; there is no history of empires originating from the present-day region of Pakistan.
Pakistanis were unable to fend off the Islamic invasion, and as a result, the entire country was subjugated, humiliated, and compelled to accept Islam. India's non-Muslim majority is due to the Indian people's resistance to the Islamic invasion. The majority of Pakistan's army, the Punjab Regiment, cooperated with the British government even during the British era by cowardly refusing to take part in the mutiny of 1857.
 
Last edited:
.
It looks in near future there will be confrontation between Pak and Afghanistan , Afghanistan has issued a new map of Asia in which they have included half of Pakistan in Aghanistan . Yesterday TTP attacked pak army in waziristan , it looks Afganistan is not taking action against ttp.
There won't be any confrontation, barring some non-State actors going their merry way. Afghanistan's problem for a while will remain preventing starvation and disease of its people.
 
.
Partition is a good think for both Pakistani and Bangladeshi, as well as for Muslim world as a whole.

It is a buffer as welll to protect Afghanistan from India.
 
.
And Bangladesh's response will be to remain uninvolved. They have shown the wisdom of trying to improve themselves without distractions.

Man, you Bangladeshis and your wishful thinking. Keep up with the patriotism :yay:
 
.
Partition is a good think for both Pakistani and Bangladeshi, as well as for Muslim world as a whole.

It is a buffer as welll to protect Afghanistan from India.
In my opinion, Pakistan functions as a buffer, serving to shield India from the influx of Afghan refugees. Without this buffer, India would face significant challenges in managing such a large number of refugees. It's worth noting that India already accommodates around 40 million undocumented Bangladeshi Muslim refugees, in addition to millions of Rohingya Muslim refugees from Myanmar.
 
.
In my opinion, Pakistan functions as a buffer, serving to shield India from the influx of Afghan refugees. Without this buffer, India would face significant challenges in managing such a large number of refugees. It's worth noting that India already accommodates around 40 million undocumented Bangladeshi Muslim refugees, in addition to millions of Rohingya Muslim refugees from Myanmar.

Pakistan and Afganistan have been stabilized politically, these nations economy will be growing inshaAllah.
 
.
Deep down, Indian muslims saying there shouldn’t have been partition is a cry for help.

It’s pretty clear Pakistan was a right choice for muslims to have an alternative option. Jinnah knew Pakistan won’t be able to accommodate all muslims to Pakistan.

Later in 1971 it was established muslims can not accommodate muslims , even today muslims are getting asylum in non Muslim countries .
 
.
Pakistan and Afganistan have been stabilized politically, these nations economy will be growing inshaAllah.
I believe that Afghanistan has the potential to stabilize and flourish, transitioning into a more liberal, democratic, and secular entity similar to Turkey during Mustafa Kemal Pasha's era. It's important to recall that Afghanistan was not originally founded on Islamic principles, which leaves room for its potential secular development. However, considering Pakistan's foundation rooted in Islam, it appears highly unlikely for Pakistan to move towards secularism. Instead, there is a greater chance for Pakistan to undergo further Islamization, paralleling Afghanistan's state in the 1990s.
 
.
Pakistan and Afganistan have been stabilized politically, these nations economy will be growing inshaAllah.

Whatever happens , Pakistan is in great trouble because of Afghanistan, sooner or later pashutn nationalism will confront pak with active help from taliban , they do not honor durand line .
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom