then where do we disagree? ISI may have a hand in it, but it's an assumption that she was held by ISI, tortured at bagram, or handed over to the Americans, at the moment. Just stick to facts, which are, she's been found, the FBI or Ridley are lying, she has a bullet wound and a lot of trauma, she is a potential suspect who will have hopefully a fair case in a civilian court (unlike many currently held in Guantanomo).
Some facts for you RR....
Aafia Siddiqui, whom the US accuses of al-Qaeda links, vanished in Karachi with her three children on
30 March 2003.
The next day it was reported in local newspapers that a woman had been taken into custody on terrorism charges.
Initially, confirmation came from a Pakistan interior ministry spokesman.
But a couple of days later, both the Pakistan government and the FBI publicly denied having anything to do with her disappearance.
Two days after Aafia Siddiqui went missing, "a man wearing a motor-bike helmet" arrived at the Siddiqui home in Karachi, her mother told the BBC.
"He did not take off the helmet, but told me that if I ever wanted to see my daughter and grandchildren again, I should keep quiet," Ms Siddiqui's mother told me over the phone in 2003.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first of these was on 23 June 2003 - three months after her disappearance - in Newsweek.
1.An investigative report, calling her a micro-biologist, said she and her husband were part of an al-Qaeda sleeper cell.
2.In Baltimore, she is alleged to have opened a mailbox for a suspected al-Qaeda operative now in Guantanamo Bay.
3.Majid Khan has been accused of planning to blow up petrol stations across the US.
4.She was later named as part of an alleged al-Qaeda diamond smuggling operation in Liberia.
5.Publications such as Newsweek quoted the FBI as saying this was to finance al-Qaeda's biological and chemical weapons programme.
The charges against her get more and more ridiclious.....dont forget she also shot 2 US army
BBC NEWS | World | South Asia | Mystery of Siddiqui disappearance