does israel have the right to exist?

[BDforever]

For anybody to have an ideology, religion is inconsequential. Even atheists have their own.
Hence your debate is flawed.

then you should not bring religion in first place which hence your debate is flawed

 

[Ahmad1996]

Jews got the RIGHT to exist, but their presence on the occupied land is not acceptable...

Yaar kab sa yahe keh rahe hain leikin log sunte nahin.

 

[ashok321]

Jihad in Islam mean to struggle in the way of Allah not go and kill people. This idea has been misused by people and then idiots like CIA trained them and then branded them terrorists. You can see who's the real culprit here.

Struggle in the way of Allah?
By doing what?

 

[hussain0216]

well keep fooling yourself world dosent thinks so on the contrarry just look at saudi/arab states and egyptian response or do you ... khair jane do ?

That's why we keep pushing


the muslim population is on the verge of overtaking the jewish population across Gaza/israel/WB

and because of higher birth rates, early marriage, having children soon after marriage in short bursts we will outnumber the jews in the land that they covet


the jew nation dosent get peace we will harass it continuously until Palestine is free

the jews can destroy their souls and morals thinking of a solution but we will keep growing




We are not hindus that we will just accept and bow down to occupation

 

[ashok321]

then you should not bring religion in first place which hence your debate is flawed

I have not, its you...More, its you who cherry picked my reply to someone else..
Ami tumake khub jani e dige...beshi bolsho na e vaipare..

 

[unbiasedopinion]

israel was founded in 1948 on the pretense as the homeland for jews and since then jews from all over the world have migrated to this country because it has been made as homeland for the jews.
-who are the jews?? and where do they come from?
jews are people who are born into jewish families or practice the jewish faith.
they come from all over the world like any major religious group.
-did the jews originate from israel??
we know that the religion was founded in modern day israel, but the modern jews at least the vast majority of them have no connection to the land of israel besides the fact that their religion was founded their.
jews are not an ethnicity as many would like us to think nor do they all originate from the tribe or judah or any of the other tribes.

I am not sure whether I am allowed to have analogy but try to re-frame the question by replacing Israel with Pakistan and Jews with Indian Subcontinent Muslims.

Islam was not originated in current Pakistan
Most of the pakistanis currently living in pakistan were not ancestry living there. They came from various other regions, Afghas, Bihar, UP, Bengal, Hyderabad etc etc
Islam has different version across the world and have different sect too.
Most importantly Pakistan was created on the pretense that muslims of Indian subcontinent need separate homeland.

BTW, i have given my answer as Yes. So I am not against creation.

 

[karan.1970]

What a stupid thread. As if a poll on a Pakistani forum about existence of Israel is going to make any difference to Israel or its existence

 

[Devil Soul]

Yaar kab sa yahe keh rahe hain leikin log sunte nahin.

Boltay Rahoo... Kabi Na Kabi tu suna paray ga

 

[BDforever]

I have not, its you...More, its you who cherry picked my reply to someone else..
Ami tumake khub jani e dige...beshi bolsho na e vaipare..

why ? did it hurt you ? lol
anyway rip bangla

What a stupid thread. As if a poll on a Pakistani forum about existence of Israel is going to make any difference to Israel or its existence

yet you bothered to check

 

[karan.1970]

are you saying that these jews in israel originate from israel?
any proofs? to back this up?

Do all Muslims in Pakistan originate from Pakistan ?

 

[Ahmad1996]

Struggle in the way of Allah?
By doing what?

Like study, give charity etc You are not going to understand it, just get this jihad doesn't gives you the permission to kill innocents.

Do all Muslims in Pakistan originate from Pakistan ?

Where else do you think they came from?

 

[ashok321]

If Israel does not have any right to exist, so does Pakistan - Which was nowhere six plus decades ago. There were no Pakistanis, but Jews were everywhere on this globe..

 

[GURU DUTT]

That's why we keep pushing


the muslim population is on the verge of overtaking the jewish population across Gaza/israel/WB

and because of higher birth rates, early marriage, having children soon after marriage in short bursts we will outnumber the jews in the land that they covet


the jew nation dosent get peace we will harass it continuously until Palestine is free

the jews can destroy their souls and morals thinking of a solution but we will keep growing




We are not hindus that we will just accept and bow down to occupation

good luck with it then and keep this attitude but remmeber no one will have any pity / sympathy or remose when a person / quam keeps on repaeting the same mistakes over and over again when the other side will retaliate cause opporteunity dosent comes twice ... good luck

 

[Ahmad1996]

If Israel does not have any right to exist, so does Pakistan - Which was nowhere six plus decades ago. There were no Pakistanis, but Jews were everywhere on this globe..

Okay let's forget about Pakis, what about Arabs then?

 

[karan.1970]

Where else do you think they came from?

You tell me.. Does the word Muhajir ring a bell?