Does India need ACC Killer Version of Shaurya/ Agni 1?

[Chanakyaa]

Ladies n Gentlemen...Mr. Professor AKA Peaceful AKA "Not Chinese" Trying To Prove.. Once AGain That He has Improved His level of Stupidity and Improved Troll Skills ..

indians let's have some meaningful debate if you are capable of doing so:

my argument here is simple - it is never about whether you need it or not, india clearly needs this type of weapon. it is all about whether india/indians will be smart enough to design/master it. to have such weapons,

1. you need a White Cloud class NOSS system. To support the Chinese DF-21D anti ACC system, we launched at least 2 White Cloud class satellite clusters, known as YG-16. the last launch was on 25th Nov 2012. you don't have such satellites, and you don't the required rocket that can launch such satellite.

Heard of INS ( Inertial Navigation System ) , GLONASS ?
India has Military Access to GLONASS.
Didnt You Realize Agni 5 Ahs 6000 KM Range... How Does it Reach the Target ??
Give a Thought...

2. you need super accurate ballistic missile systems. To support that, basically you need a lot of launch tests to collect stats and gain experience. you need a flexible satellite navigation system that is under your full control. you don't have the navigation satellite network, you don't have the required rocket that can launch such satellite to form the network, you don't have a strong enough economy to back the R&D of such network. please note, we are talking about building & putting 30-50 satellites each at 5-8ton to operate such network.

Sats and Ballistic Missiles lol.. Ha ha.. Grow up Kid. R7 Semyorka could launch a Thermonuclear War Head Much Much B4 an Actual Satellite ( Sputnik ) was placed in Orbit.

3. you need super reliable ballistic missile technology. PSLV's success rate is 90%, GSLV is 20%. it would be a wet day dream to build weapon class missiles based on such reliability stats.

First Learn the Difference Between Missile and a Space Rocket.
Agni 5 ICBM Has 6 K Range and CEP of a Few Kms and Its 100% Success.
If a Long March Fails that Doesn't mean DF series ICBMs cant launch a Payload.. Got It ?

in short, to build and operate this weapon, you need to a pretty big reform to get ride of your highly ineffective government first.

In Short You Proved Your Moronic Attitude Again.
And That u And Troll n Troll Alone.

 

[skysthelimit]

Operating from shallow waters and small islands which are prevalent in the IOR.. they could.
even then.. with a H-6 variant providing vectors .. they could launch Missiles much further out.

A few cases when what you are saying might be true -

1. FACs carry intermediate range missiles - impossible without SiFi-level propulsion breakthrough.
2. Myanmar allows China to operate FOB in Bay of Bengal - unlikely again.
3. China gains foothold deep into IOR - then IN is screwed with or without FAC.

So, not really a cause for worry.

Ladies n Gentlemen...Mr. Professor AKA Peaceful AKA "Not Chinese" Trying To Prove.. Once AGain That He has Improved His level of Stupidity and Improved Troll Skills ..

Guys - first rule of internet posting - "Don't feed the Trolls".

Please stop replying to Peaceful and his moronic posts.

 

[IND151]

So I ask question again

Does India need ACC Killer Version of Shaurya/ Agni 1?

 

[IndoUS]

So I ask question again

Does India need ACC Killer Version of Shaurya/ Agni 1?

Simple answer would be no, any missile like Agni1 would not work against a moving Target and it would be waste considering we can do the same damage with the Brahmos or any cruise missile in that matter.