Deep sea port project in Matarbari gains pace, Sonadia dropped

[The Ronin]

'Our neighbouring country Sri Lanka is facing trouble after building a deep sea port with Chinese loans'

The government has decided to drop the plan of building a deep sea port in Sonadia, Cox’s Bazar and fast track the proposed deep sea port in Matarbari.

Official sources confirmed to Dhaka Tribune on Wednesday that the move came after giving consideration to the vulnerability of the ecosystem of Sonadia island, which was declared an Ecologically Critical Area (ECA) back in 1999. But sources also hinted that some geopolitical considerations also came into play.

At the 5th meeting of the Fast Track Project Monitoring Committee, held at the Prime Minister’s Office on January 19, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina said that there would be no deep sea port in Sonadia as such construction would damage the ecological balance of the area, a meeting source told this correspondent.

It was expected that China would provide funds to build Sonadia deep sea port and a feasibility study was carried out to this end back in 2009. But eventually no Sino-Bangla deal was struck all these years. The US, China and India, all global and regional big economies, have their diverse perspectives centring on the Bay of Bengal zone.

Seeking anonymity, a government policymaker told Dhaka Tribune: “We do not want to get involved in regional politics, which may affect our country’s development. Besides, Bangladesh is surrounded by some big foreign deep sea ports, so we do not need to build a shipping terminal here. At the same time, Japan is developing the Matarbari area for an LNG terminal. We can easily develop Matarbari as a deep sea port. That’s why the government changed the decision of constructing a deep sea port in Sonadia.”

“Our neighbouring country Sri Lanka is facing trouble after building a deep sea port with Chinese loans. Now China (China Merchants Ports Holding Company having 70 percent leasing stake) has a large stake at this port. So we were cautious about taking Chinese credit for Sonadia,” explained the policymaker.

On January 18, China and Myanmar signed 33 memoranda of understanding (MoUs), agreements, protocols and exchange letters, including concession agreements and shareholders’ agreement, regarding the Kyaukphyu Special Economic Zone Deep Sea Port Project in Myanmar.

During a two-day visit, Chinese President Xi Jinping sealed the deep sea port deal in Kyaukpyu area, which is located in western Myanmar’s Rakhine State that borders Bangladesh to the north and the Bay of Bengal to the west.

Experts note that Bangladesh’s dropping of the Sonadia port project encouraged Beijing to look to building an alternative deep-sea port in Myanmar for this region, while India is constructing a road network through its seven-sister region to access the deep-sea port in Myanmar.

Dr Amena Mohsin, who teaches international relations at the University of Dhaka, told Dhaka Tribune: “I think Bangladesh is now doing global economic diplomacy. Recent trends show that the country wishes to move forward from its old diplomatic tactics. Previously, Bangladesh used to practice the same pattern of pro-India or pro-China diplomacy but now its strategies are changing.”

“China didn’t stand beside Bangladesh in resolving the Rohingya crisis. Rather, China always lent support to Myanmar on the issue. I think this Chinese strategy also forced Bangladesh to think otherwise,” elaborated Dr Amena Mohsin.

Matarbari port project gaining pace

Two days after the decision to drop the Sonadia deep sea port project, the Chief Representative of the Bangladesh Office of Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), Hitoshi Hitara, met State Minister for Shipping Khalid Mahmud Chowdhury at the latter’s secretariat office on January 21.

A press release issued by the shipping ministry states, “Matarbari port is a highest priority project of the government. We are going to place this project before the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council (Ecnec) meeting soon, Khalid Mahmud Chowdhury told Hitoshi Hirata.”

Talking to Dhaka Tribune, Khalid Mahymud Chowdhury said, “Usually if a sea port is of over14-meter depth, it is considered a deep sea port. The Matarbari port is going to be 19 meters deep. In a sense we can use it as a deep sea port.”

Officials of the shipping ministry said the primary cost of Matarbari port development is estimated to be Tk.17,777.16 crore. JICA and Chittagong Port Authority (CPA) will construct it jointly.

Of the amount, JICA will provide Tk 12,892.76 crore, the Bangladesh government Tk 2,671.15 crore and the CPA Tk 2,213.94 crore.

The timeframe of this project is from 2020 to 2024.

According to the plan, two jetties having a capacity of handling 8,000 TUEs (twenty-foot equivalent units) would be readied at Matarbari. The jetties will make possible the handling of more than three times the 2,500 TUEs daily now being handled at Chittagong Port.

How the business hub will look

The JICA team also shared a drawing, ‘Future image of Moheshkhali-Matarbari area,’ at Tuesday’s meeting at the shipping ministry. Dhaka Tribune has collected a copy of that image.

A graphic presentation of the proposed project gives a beautiful look of the project site and its adjoining areas, having a 28km four-lane road with 17 bridges. The total length of the bridges is estimated to be nearly 7km.

Additionally, a number of high-rises will be constructed there, to facilitate all kinds of works and accommodation. Once completed, the project is expected to draw a number of tourists to the once remote island.

Member (Administration and Planning) of Chittagong Port Authority, Md Zadar Alam, told this correspondent that the port would be connected to the national highway from Chokoria to Cox’s Bazar.

“There will be two jetties: one is a 300-meter multipurpose jetty and the other is a 460-meter container jetty,” he added.

https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangla...2GiAwDFOO0dQ-LpEJG8aIlCTTQkSp9WsLnyQJjpq_utnw

 

[mmr]

'Our neighbouring country Sri Lanka is facing trouble after building a deep sea port with Chinese loans'

The government has decided to drop the plan of building a deep sea port in Sonadia, Cox’s Bazar and fast track the proposed deep sea port in Matarbari.

Official sources confirmed to Dhaka Tribune on Wednesday that the move came after giving consideration to the vulnerability of the ecosystem of Sonadia island, which was declared an Ecologically Critical Area (ECA) back in 1999. But sources also hinted that some geopolitical considerations also came into play.

At the 5th meeting of the Fast Track Project Monitoring Committee, held at the Prime Minister’s Office on January 19, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina said that there would be no deep sea port in Sonadia as such construction would damage the ecological balance of the area, a meeting source told this correspondent.

It was expected that China would provide funds to build Sonadia deep sea port and a feasibility study was carried out to this end back in 2009. But eventually no Sino-Bangla deal was struck all these years. The US, China and India, all global and regional big economies, have their diverse perspectives centring on the Bay of Bengal zone.

Seeking anonymity, a government policymaker told Dhaka Tribune: “We do not want to get involved in regional politics, which may affect our country’s development. Besides, Bangladesh is surrounded by some big foreign deep sea ports, so we do not need to build a shipping terminal here. At the same time, Japan is developing the Matarbari area for an LNG terminal. We can easily develop Matarbari as a deep sea port. That’s why the government changed the decision of constructing a deep sea port in Sonadia.”

“Our neighbouring country Sri Lanka is facing trouble after building a deep sea port with Chinese loans. Now China (China Merchants Ports Holding Company having 70 percent leasing stake) has a large stake at this port. So we were cautious about taking Chinese credit for Sonadia,” explained the policymaker.

On January 18, China and Myanmar signed 33 memoranda of understanding (MoUs), agreements, protocols and exchange letters, including concession agreements and shareholders’ agreement, regarding the Kyaukphyu Special Economic Zone Deep Sea Port Project in Myanmar.

During a two-day visit, Chinese President Xi Jinping sealed the deep sea port deal in Kyaukpyu area, which is located in western Myanmar’s Rakhine State that borders Bangladesh to the north and the Bay of Bengal to the west.

Experts note that Bangladesh’s dropping of the Sonadia port project encouraged Beijing to look to building an alternative deep-sea port in Myanmar for this region, while India is constructing a road network through its seven-sister region to access the deep-sea port in Myanmar.

Dr Amena Mohsin, who teaches international relations at the University of Dhaka, told Dhaka Tribune: “I think Bangladesh is now doing global economic diplomacy. Recent trends show that the country wishes to move forward from its old diplomatic tactics. Previously, Bangladesh used to practice the same pattern of pro-India or pro-China diplomacy but now its strategies are changing.”

“China didn’t stand beside Bangladesh in resolving the Rohingya crisis. Rather, China always lent support to Myanmar on the issue. I think this Chinese strategy also forced Bangladesh to think otherwise,” elaborated Dr Amena Mohsin.

Matarbari port project gaining pace

Two days after the decision to drop the Sonadia deep sea port project, the Chief Representative of the Bangladesh Office of Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), Hitoshi Hitara, met State Minister for Shipping Khalid Mahmud Chowdhury at the latter’s secretariat office on January 21.

A press release issued by the shipping ministry states, “Matarbari port is a highest priority project of the government. We are going to place this project before the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council (Ecnec) meeting soon, Khalid Mahmud Chowdhury told Hitoshi Hirata.”

Talking to Dhaka Tribune, Khalid Mahymud Chowdhury said, “Usually if a sea port is of over14-meter depth, it is considered a deep sea port. The Matarbari port is going to be 19 meters deep. In a sense we can use it as a deep sea port.”

Officials of the shipping ministry said the primary cost of Matarbari port development is estimated to be Tk.17,777.16 crore. JICA and Chittagong Port Authority (CPA) will construct it jointly.

Of the amount, JICA will provide Tk 12,892.76 crore, the Bangladesh government Tk 2,671.15 crore and the CPA Tk 2,213.94 crore.

The timeframe of this project is from 2020 to 2024.

According to the plan, two jetties having a capacity of handling 8,000 TUEs (twenty-foot equivalent units) would be readied at Matarbari. The jetties will make possible the handling of more than three times the 2,500 TUEs daily now being handled at Chittagong Port.

How the business hub will look

The JICA team also shared a drawing, ‘Future image of Moheshkhali-Matarbari area,’ at Tuesday’s meeting at the shipping ministry. Dhaka Tribune has collected a copy of that image.

A graphic presentation of the proposed project gives a beautiful look of the project site and its adjoining areas, having a 28km four-lane road with 17 bridges. The total length of the bridges is estimated to be nearly 7km.

Additionally, a number of high-rises will be constructed there, to facilitate all kinds of works and accommodation. Once completed, the project is expected to draw a number of tourists to the once remote island.

Member (Administration and Planning) of Chittagong Port Authority, Md Zadar Alam, told this correspondent that the port would be connected to the national highway from Chokoria to Cox’s Bazar.

“There will be two jetties: one is a 300-meter multipurpose jetty and the other is a 460-meter container jetty,” he added.

https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangla...2GiAwDFOO0dQ-LpEJG8aIlCTTQkSp9WsLnyQJjpq_utnw

Bd could have built the port and then get into agreement with india Bhutan and nepal to use it.

 

[Tom-tom]

Matarbari, will effectively a low profile deep sea port.

 

[bluesky]

Matarbari, will effectively a low profile deep sea port.

It is a deep sea port only because the water is deep in Matarbari. However, it does not mean that the Ocean-going large ships will come and anchor here. These will anchor at Singapore and our feeder small ships will be re-loaded with goods destined for us. Exports will just do the opposite thing. Coming to Matarbari port is not cost-effective for big shipping companies because of low volumes of cargo to and from BD, this can be managed by feeder ships.

 

[mb444]

It is a deep sea port only because the water is deep in Matarbari. However, it does not mean that the Ocean-going large ships will come and anchor here. These will anchor at Singapore and our feeder small ships will be re-loaded with goods destined for us. Exports will just do the opposite thing. Coming to Matarbari port is not cost-effective for big shipping companies because of low volumes of cargo to and from BD, this can be managed by feeder ships.

How then is it a good deal... we will continue to waste money with feeder ship.... opportunity wasted if what you say is true...

 

[TopCat]

It is a deep sea port only because the water is deep in Matarbari. However, it does not mean that the Ocean-going large ships will come and anchor here. These will anchor at Singapore and our feeder small ships will be re-loaded with goods destined for us. Exports will just do the opposite thing. Coming to Matarbari port is not cost-effective for big shipping companies because of low volumes of cargo to and from BD, this can be managed by feeder ships.

You are only talking about container ship but the dirty cargoes like coal, grains, stones, iron ore etc have to come directly to matharbari and can not be transshipped via singapore.

 

[Tom-tom]

Does that mean Bangladesh won't be a priority for Chinas belt Road initiative and string of peals in sea routes?

 

[bluesky]

How then is it a good deal... we will continue to waste money with feeder ship.... opportunity wasted if what you say is true...

I think Matarbari has some special tasks. It is mainly to serve the Japan-built power stations and some future industries nearby. However, it will not be limited to Japanese interest because the port is our sovereign property.

I was talking about the way Singapore runs as a transit point. Ocean-going ships anchor there and the feeder ships from the surrounding countries load or unload their goods to or from the large ships. BD also does the same and there is no doubt it will continue this way.

Do not please think a deep seaport is a sure way for the large ships to come and anchor. BD is a very tiny market for them. They cannot come here because the cost will be high that neither the shippers nor BD can afford.

I believe it was a good decision by the GoB not to fall into the Chinese trap in a large Sonadia port. Very sound decision.

You are only talking about container ship but the dirty cargoes like coal, grains, stones, iron ore etc have to come directly to matharbari and can not be transshipped via singapore.

Nowadays, coals are shipped also in dry containers on large ships. Moreover, it is possible to bring the bulk carrier ships to Matarbari port where the goods can be unloaded to feeder ships for delivery to Payra and other points including river points when needed.

However, note that a bulk carrier ship needs at least 18m of the draft. I do not know how deep will be Matarbari. So, I am not sure about the possibility.