What's new

China refused to give WHO officials Covid data that would help find outbreak source


Chinese scientists refused to share key data on Covid-19 that might have helped locate the origin of the deadly virus.

Investigators from the World Health Organisation on a fact-finding trip requested raw data on patient records but were rebuffed by officials.

Disagreements became so tense that they sometimes erupted into shouting matches, it has been reported.

For 27 days in January and February, a team of 14 experts for the WHO led a mission to trace the origins of the pandemic - but failed to find any conclusive answers.

Several allege their Chinese counterparts were frustrated by the team’s persistent questioning and demands for data, reports the New York Times.

Officials in China urged the investigators to embrace the government's narrative about the virus - and not believe reports about the Wuhan wet market or that the virus was started in a lab.


Thea Kølsen Fischer, a Danish epidemiologist on the team, said: “It was my take on the entire mission that it was highly geopolitical.

"Everybody knows how much pressure there is on China to be open to an investigation and also how much blame there might be associated with this.”

Frustrated in their efforts, nonetheless the WHO team compromised with their report on Covid-19.

They praised the Chinese government’s transparency, but pushed for more research about the early days of the outbreak in Wuhan in late 2019.

The team asked for details about the first patients - and possible ones before that.

“We asked for that on a number of occasions and they gave us some of that, but not necessarily enough to do the sorts of analyses you would do,” said Dominic Dwyer, an Australian microbiologist on the WHO team, referring to the confirmed cases.

Chinese scientists acknowledged they had discovered 92 people hospitalized in Wuhan as early as October 2019 with the Covid-like symptoms of a fever and coughing.

The Chinese experts said they had found no trace of Covid-19 in those people, but the tests were incomplete.

The WHO team is expected to release a full report about its findings in coming weeks.

Dominic Dwyer,



Expect screams and howls of FakeNews in 3...2...1

So US media isn't to be trusted, propaganda manipulation here.

"We did receive access to data....New data included env. & animal carcass testing, names of suppliers to Huanan Market, analyses of excess mortality in Hubei, range of covid-like symptoms for months prior, sequence data linked to early cases & site visits w/ unvetted live Q&A etc. All in report coming soon!"

"Hear! Hear! It's disappointing to spend time w/ journalists explaining key findings of our exhausting month-long work in China, to see our colleagues selectively misquoted to fit a narrative that was prescribed before the work began. Shame on you"
 
Last edited:
It is rather strange that the US official who is questioning all this is from US National Security Department.
I saw it over CNA this morning. He is not even a virologist nor a Medical Doctor.

is this a US strategy to distract the world so that the WHO investigators cannot go and inspects US Biological Laboratories in question? :coffee:
 
China is doing just fine.

LOL. WHO announced Wuhan is not the source of Covid and the Wuhan lab leak is not likely.
These are the two big elephants in the room and the two conspiracy stories by Trump and Pompeo.

China stopped the virus and is now cleared by an international body.

Heaven is truly smiling at China.

No one announced Wuhan is not the source of the virus. In fact, the Wuhan market theory came from Chinese doctors. If it wasn't for those Chinese doctors who -inadvertently- exposed what's happening in Wuhan, the Chinese would have continued hiding it to this day.
 
No one announced Wuhan is not the source of the virus. In fact, the Wuhan market theory came from Chinese doctors. If it wasn't for those Chinese doctors who -inadvertently- exposed what's happening in Wuhan, the Chinese would have continued hiding it to this day.
LOL.. Are you joking? Smoking too much western grass media? Wuhan theory is spread by western media of Chinese eating bat. They seems to be very prepared of whats happening there beforehand Chinese says anything. In fact, there is no bat sold at wuhan wet market. I am wondering how they are so prepare of the script beforehand? Maybe informed by Fort Detrick counterpart of what's going to spread , prepared by US?

Plus the Chinese doctor initial treating the Chinese patient were wrong to claim it as SARS. In fact, its a new strain of coronavirus which is the reason why Chinese government shut them up becos they are wronged.
 
Of cos you dont think so becos you are biased and spew nonsense all based on false news.

Just poking a little fun and actually wasn’t being serious.

So basically, anyone who doesn’t agree with you = spewing fake news.

Cool.. Good to know 🤪
 
No one announced Wuhan is not the source of the virus. In fact, the Wuhan market theory came from Chinese doctors. If it wasn't for those Chinese doctors who -inadvertently- exposed what's happening in Wuhan, the Chinese would have continued hiding it to this day.
Errrr...... WHO just said that. Have you read the news ?
 
LOL.. Are you joking? Smoking too much western grass media? Wuhan theory is spread by western media of Chinese eating bat. They seems to be very prepared of whats happening there beforehand Chinese says anything. In fact, there is no bat sold at wuhan wet market. I am wondering how they are so prepare of the script beforehand? Maybe informed by Fort Detrick counterpart of what's going to spread , prepared by US?

Plus the Chinese doctor initial treating the Chinese patient were wrong to claim it as SARS. In fact, its a new strain of coronavirus which is the reason why Chinese government shut them up becos they are wronged.


You do know that COVID 19 is SARS, right? At the time they just didn't know the exact virus strain. Until the cause of the SARS cases was confirmed to be a new Coronavirus strain. And again, the Chinese are the ones who linked the early COVID cases to the market, not 'western media'. I'm not saying it necessarily originated from the market, or from the animals in the market, but this 'theory' originated from Chinese sources.
Errrr...... WHO just said that. Have you read the news ?

Provide your sources from the WHO please. What they said is that they don't have enough data yet to reach a definite conclusion on the origin of the virus, and obviously they started with the Wuhan market because that's where the first cases appeared according to Chinese reports.
 
Last edited:
Sharing patient information is illegal. Civil Code Article 1226: Medical organizations and employees thereof must maintain privacy of patients and personal information. Those who share, reveal or publicize personal information or medical records are liable for civil damages.

根据《民法典》第一千二百二十六条的规定,医疗机构及其医务人员应当对患者的隐私和个人信息保密。泄露患者的隐私和个人信息,或者未经患者同意公开其病历资料的,应当承担侵权责任。



This does not apply when the world needs to know the facts of the most dangerous virus for 100 years.

What is China trying to hide here?
 
This does not apply when the world needs to know the facts of the most dangerous virus for 100 years.

What is China trying to hide here?

Chinese people's rights are worth less than yours? Or you pay tax to China and get a say in what China does?
 
Chinese people's rights are worth less than yours? Or you pay tax to China and get a say in what China does?


The right of the world to know the truth is worth far more than a few patients rights in China.

What exactly are the Chinese trying to hide here?
 
The right of the world to know the truth is worth far more than a few patients rights in China.

What exactly are the Chinese trying to hide here?

You can get those records by seizing them by force. Go ahead and try.
 
Back
Top Bottom