Tergon18
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2013
- Messages
- 152
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
How do you find the relevant info in the spur of moment?
Are you talking about the Adi Shankara part? Its all over the internet. Just Google him.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
How do you find the relevant info in the spur of moment?
Even to Google you have to know a bit about it BEFOREHAND.Are you talking about the Adi Shankara part? Its all over the internet. Just Google him.
Even to Google you have to know a bit about it BEFOREHAND.
What?
Tell him something newWhat?
Iam a Punjabi what have I got to do with a u.p dweller or lets say a madrasi, except we both breatheThe OP really is trying hard to find a different history than that of the Indian sub continent.
1)by the logic that a "Pakistani" is the child of Indus (the OP states this in 1965), then Bangladesh should never have been Pakistan
2) What is the problem with having a shared heritage with India? you can stil go your separate ways. having a shared history does not mean you need to have a shared future.
3) More than finding your own roots to be Unique, it feels like this person is more bent on denying India the history of the IVC/Harappan civilization.
The Mehrgarh and Andronovo culture have proved that there can be a shared civilization that have later branched out into different peoples
Iam a Punjabi what have I got to do with a u.p dweller or lets say a madrasi, except we both breathe
Edit : Why an American is getting annoyed on what I.V.C folks claim -------
The OP really is trying hard to find a different history than that of the Indian sub continent.
1)by the logic that a "Pakistani" is the child of Indus (the OP states this in 1965), then Bangladesh should never have been Pakistan
2) What is the problem with having a shared heritage with India? you can stil go your separate ways. having a shared history does not mean you need to have a shared future.
3) More than finding your own roots to be Unique, it feels like this person is more bent on denying India the history of the IVC/Harappan civilization.
The Mehrgarh and Andronovo culture have proved that there can be a shared civilization that have later branched out into different peoples
My favourite pastime - Ancient history..
finished the crash course 3 times over, Scot chestworth's ancient history twice. currently on columbia university's Richerd Bulliet's class on ancient history and valley civilizations.
I had to look up where Punjabi was but its right there along the plains of sub continent India. Its an interesting culture up there. I can share a few insights if you are up for it on a different thread - complete with the flow of peoples from the Andronovo Culture to Mehrgarh to Harappa and then into present Pakistan/India
That is a region the size of Europe. Does Portugal and Latvia have same history? Whilst there maybe some convergence - at the end day everybody is part of the globe but that does not mean what happens in Balochistan is going to have much impact in Bengal. They al have their own currents in the wash of history. It is when one does not have anything that you feel you need to "piggy back" others.plains of sub continent India.
That is a region the size of Europe. Does Portugal and Latvia have same history? Whilst there maybe some convergence - at the end day everybody is part of the globe but that does not mean what happens in Balochistan is going to have much impact in Bengal. They al have their own currents in the wash of history. It is when one does not have anything that you feel you need to "piggy back" others.
And "India" had Burma, even Aden and modern Dubai part of it. Do we draw some conclusions from that? If your so pent up about East Bengal what about Burma being part of India?
And did you know up till 1840s Indian soldiers recieved extra pay when serving in Sindh and Punjab [what is now Pakistan] because the Indus region was percieved to be "foreign"?
Excerpt