Pro-Israeli debate on this is highly irrational, and blatantly immoral.
It's like: 'So? it's okay if they do it.'
Israelis didn't exist before May 1948. A Palestine with a vast Arab majority who had land held by that majority did exist. They were expelled from their homes if they didn't flee, if they didn't move by force they'd be systematically killed. Please do read up on the various massacres of Palestinian population centers. It was ethnic cleansing and nothing short of a war crime. So an immoral method to an immoral cause, the immoral cause being to grab a land off a people, displacing many and turning many into refugees. Please do research the Al Nakba.
Anybody who claims that they had a right is a hypocrite, plain and simple.
Arabs and Jews are fellow Semites to begin with. They have intermarried with each other for millenniums. Herod the Great was half Arab for instance. There are no Hebrews left anymore for a reason.
The closest to them are the Samaritans who number less than 1000 people today. Ironically they have always lived in what is now Palestine/Israel without any problems with their Arab cousins.
Samaritans - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The ancient Hebrews either assimilated with nearby Arabs, migrated or went extinct. The populations of what is now Israel/Palestine have changed many times over the past centuries/millenniums due to invasions, wars, famines etc.
Most of the Jews of today have close to no historical or genetic relations to those ancient Hebrews. Moreover Hebrews were not the first inhabitants of what is now Palestine/Israel. The Semitic Canaanites were.
Canaanite - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Besides Arabs have lived in the Levant for 3000 years. Basically that region is just a mixture of various ancient Semitic people and non-Semitic people.
The modern-day Palestinains have a much stronger claim on that land than Arabs turned Jews from across the Arab world (from Morocco to Yemen), East Europeans and various Africans have. Genetic tests confirm this, recent history confirms this etc.
I am sure that the Dravidians could claim all of South Asia by that logic. Despite too being migrants at some point.
Dravidian peoples - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
In fact 99% of the entire American, Canadian etc. population should return to where they came from.
Ignorant and idiotic comments by the usual Indian (anti-Muslim) suspects who have nothing to do with the ancient ME. Nothing new.
this thread is the perfect example how every thread on pdf eventually ends up becoming a India-Pakistan troll war.......with all the trash talk ,,,may be its time for bringing in the nuclear war,,
n i thought we were the undisputed champion in that category.
