BMW 3 Series or Mercedes A class

[Indus Pakistan]

buy a Mercedes E class 2014-2015

Back in late 1990s I had a E-class Merc but it handled like a ship. The Beemers handle like they are stuck on rails ...

 

[maximuswarrior]

Cars are very nicely maintained here in Europe and most of the people use for it for work purposes. I am only concerned about the reliability and fuel economy since i am gonna commute quite much.

Reliability wise BMW and Mercedes are perfectly fine as long as you maintain them regularly as others have pointed out. However parts and maintenance is more expensive as opposed to other cars.

When you are looking for fuel efficiency both BMW and Mercedes are definitely not the best. These are predominantly luxury brands.

Be careful when purchasing second hand German cars. Especially when mileage is high.

 

[Muhammad Omar]

Buy Audi A4 instead of BMW or Mercedes

 

[war&peace]

BMW 3 is much better but it depends on the condition and trim level of the used cars you are going to choose from. BMWs are fun to drive more like Audi while Merce are more towards luxury so you have to choose according to your liking. I would go with BMW 3 series if I was in your place.

To be fair same applies to MBs, Audi's. The only issue I had was last year the auto caused some problem.

@bold, the crown prince

 

[maximuswarrior]

Buy Audi A4 instead of BMW or Mercedes

I am a huge Audi fan. They are built like a tank and extremely powerful. However, all of these cars are built on the same principle. These are luxury brands. They aren't cheap even second hand. If the mileage is low they are obviously more expensive. Brand new you pay a hefty sum.

However, I must admit that almost every brand nowadays produces generally speaking quality cars. Japanese, South Korean, European and American. It will be quite hard to spot an unattractive car as design has become so refined and improved.

If fuel efficiency is a prime concern there are tons of better alternatives. You don't have to compromise on quality.

I personally drive a VW Golf 7 GTI. Not nearly as luxurious as Mercedes or BMW, but I have tuned some aspects of my car. I like to refine the car and it can smoke many stock BMW's and Mercs. Cars are indeed a second wife. My wallet knows this. Right know this car is sufficient for our small family. As the family grows I will have to look for another car.

 

[MMM-E]

Back in late 1990s I had a E-class Merc but it handled like a ship. The Beemers handle like they are stuck on rails ...

2013 saloon E class is the best option for low income families (for second hand )

BMW3 Audi A3 A4 Mercedes A / C sucks waste money

 

[war&peace]

First of all mileage, mileage, mileage. That's the main thing that dictates price. Now considering its 2-3 years older, it should have a millage of about 70,000 or less. Nothing higher. Secondly none of these cars are gonna be easy on the wallet. The service is what's gonna get ya. Also I've been told to stay away from secondhand mercs, BMW, or any of those luxury cars. They tend to come with a lot of issues. If you really want one, save up for a new one. My 2 cents.

Buying a 2-3 years old car is really a smart thing to do because most of depreciation occurs in the first three years and afterwards it stays pretty much the same depending on the condition. Rather, I have friend in USA who only buy 3-4 years old car, repairs it (if needed) and sells at a higher price than the purchasing price. BMWs are reliable and 2-3 old are in pretty decent condition generally.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

Buying a 2-3 years old car is really a smart thing to do because most of depreciation occurs in the first three years and afterwards it stays pretty much the same depending on the condition. Rather, I have friend in USA who only buy 3-4 years old car, repairs it (if needed) and sells at a higher price than the purchasing price. BMWs are reliable and 2-3 old are in pretty decent condition generally.

Oh ya, that's a given, always buy used cars, it's just that some are better then others.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

2013 saloon E200 is ideal car for low income families

No idea about Germany but in UK Merc E200s are not for 'low income' family unless they buy a old cronk. It would fit more in middle income bracket car. As I said I had one in 1997-2000. It was nice, spacious but handled like ship.

 

[war&peace]

No idea about Germany but in UK Merc E200s are not for 'low income' family unless they buy a old cronk. It would fit more in middle income bracket car. As I said I had one in 1997-2000. It was nice, spacious but handled like ship.

Ship or spaceship

 

[Asimzranger]

Buy new eco hatch or sedan i would suggest
https://www.mazda.co.uk/cars/mazda3-hatchback/

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Ship or spaceship

The ride was extremely smooth but around bends when pressed it would wallow about. UK is not like USA. Most roads are twisty and narrow. So it was not great fun driving it. Although the front hood with MB tri-star looked amazing.

 

[Muhammad Omar]

I am a huge Audi fan. They are built like a tank and extremely powerful. However, all of these cars are built on the same principle. These are luxury brands. They aren't cheap even second hand. If the mileage is low they are obviously more expensive.

However, I must admit that almost every brand nowadays produces generally speaking quality cars. Japanese, South Korean, European and American. It will be quite hard to spot an unattractive car as design has become so refined and improved.

Reasons to buy Audi in Pakistan

If I talk about Audi A4
The mileage it gives is 11-13 KMPL in city while it hits easy 16 KMPL on the Highways / Motorways which is almost same as mileage of Toyota Corolla in Pakistan while the BMW 5 series I drive last was giving 9-11 KMPL and 14-15 KMPL on highways yeah difference is minor

Audi Centers and maintenance
Well Deewan Motors of BMW is just milking the customers if you go just for the maintenance of your car they are over charging

Audi Maintenance Cost

• Fluid levels’ check
• Exterior and under-body visual check
• Interior and electrics inspection
• Audi Service history stamp/record
• Oil filter replacement
• Engine oil replacement
• Interior / Exterior cleaning

All the above mentioned things of Audi A4 cost 9000-12000 rupees PKR and A3 cost 8000-9300 rupees

While if you see the Maintenance cost of BMW A3 starts from 11000 if I talk about BMW 320i While BMW 318i cost 14000 rupees and above while you have to wait for spares months or weeks cause many spares are imported on order

 

[Sinnerman108]

Guys i am planning to buy second hand car (2015/2016), and i am leaning towards BMW 3 series (saloon) and Mercedes A class. If any one have experience with both cars can you tell which one is better with fuel economy and is easy to maintain/ easy on wallet.

a. None of the two are saloons !

b. Where are you located ?

c. What kind of a drive are you looking for ?

 

[maximuswarrior]

Buying a 2-3 years old car is really a smart thing to do because most of depreciation occurs in the first three years and afterwards it stays pretty much the same depending on the condition. Rather, I have friend in USA who only buy 3-4 years old car, repairs it (if needed) and sells at a higher price than the purchasing price. BMWs are reliable and 2-3 old are in pretty decent condition generally.

3-4 year old cars are perfectly fine. The goal should be to find a car with low mileage. BMW and Mercedes are not fuel efficient or wallet friendly.