What's new

Big Helmand offensive in the offing

Status
Not open for further replies.
Be it Mufti, Qazi or what ever name you want to give, No where in Islam is written that you blow yourselves up kill innocents in the name of God & then 'emotionally black mail people' using Religion to get your things done...

You can not find any hadith about blood transformation because 1400 years ago transformation technique was not available , but now Mufti's allowed it to save life.

I agree with you killing innocient people is haram by any means.
 
and how about those who were killed due to deliberate act of the Taliban? more 75% of all casualties are due to the taliban attacks? I asked you about those school children and journalist who were killed by the taliban, arent they muslims? that is 2 example out thousands.

If any body involved in killing innocient civilian, it is considered harm and should be punished.

But you have to provide evidence for innocient killing , i think Mullah Omar Shourah and Shariah court which is still intact will provide justice.
 
which elected gov you are talking about? can you tell me please?

Election of shourah member has very strict criteria which is mentioned in Hadith books , any mufti or Alim Deen can explain you in detail.
 
Election of shourah member has very strict criteria which is mentioned in Hadith books , any mufti or Alim Deen can explain you in detail.


that is not election. there is a difference between election and selection. people never voted for the taliban, they are not people's representatives. you better say a bunch of taliban selected each other for the posts they think it is theirs.
 
If any body involved in killing innocient civilian, it is considered harm and should be punished.

But you have to provide evidence for innocient killing , i think Mullah Omar Shourah and Shariah court which is still intact will provide justice.


i provided you with tones of evidence, all these reports from different sources. do you think it was islamic when they beheaded that young journalist?
 
i provided you with tones of evidence, all these reports from different sources. do you think it was islamic when they beheaded that young journalist?

Islam Shariah has its unique system of justice , please read it to understand or consult Mufti for further clarification.
 
Unless the Shourah means keeping a gun at someone's head and asking him to elect you, I dont see how its applicable here..

The Ruling System and Administration in Islam (441562):

The course presents concepts and practices related to governance and administration: Islamic public policy; jurisdiction; selection of political leaders; the shourah council; principles of public administration; audit and accountability; decision making within Islamic legal ruling.

Jurisprudence and Legislation(Fiqh Wa Tashree) : An-Najah National University : Palestine
 
The Ruling System and Administration in Islam (441562):

The course presents concepts and practices related to governance and administration: Islamic public policy; jurisdiction; selection of political leaders; the shourah council; principles of public administration; audit and accountability; decision making within Islamic legal ruling.

Jurisprudence and Legislation(Fiqh Wa Tashree) : An-Najah National University : Palestine

What are you trying to say except copying and pasting from a course syllabus of a master's degree??

Shura by definition means consultation. Who do Taliban consult?? Other Taliban?? c'mon, dont hide behind religious text to prove a points. Incidently Egypt's governing body is also called a Shura council with a hell of a difference.. Look it up..
 
Islam Shariah has its unique system of justice , please read it to understand or consult Mufti for further clarification.

Look, I dont need to read anything here, I give you 2 EXAMPLES OF TALIBAN ATROCITIES OUT OF THOUSANDS and you tell me if it is islamic or unislamic:

Taleban kill Afghanistan reporter

Ajmal Naqshbandi worked as a guide for visiting reporters
The Taleban in Afghanistan have killed an Afghan reporter abducted last month with an Italian journalist.
The group said it had killed Ajmal Naqshbandi because the government had refused to meet its demands to release senior figures from prison.

Italian reporter Daniele Mastrogiacomo was released after five Taleban members were freed in exchange. The driver, Sayed Agha, was beheaded last month.

Italian Prime Minister Romano Prodi has condemned Mr Naqshbandi's killing.

The two reporters and their driver were captured on 6 March in Helmand province.

Shohaabuddin Atal, a spokesman for Taleban commander Mullah Dadullah, said: "We killed Ajmal today because the government did not respond to our demands."

Italian deal

The Afghan government's intelligence services spokesman, Saeed Ansari, confirmed Mr Naqshbandi had been killed.


Mr Mastrogiacomo was freed in an exchange with Taleban prisoners

Tom Koenigs, UN special envoy to Afghanistan, said: "I condemn this senseless murder unreservedly and call on the authorities to bring those responsible to justice."

In Italy, Mr Prodi said he "learned with anguish" of Mr Naqshbandi's death. "We strongly condemn this absurd crime," he said.

Ajmal Naqshbandi worked as a guide and translator for visiting foreign reporters.

He was abducted with Mr Mastrogiacomo and their driver at a Taleban checkpoint and originally accused of spying for the British army.

The reporters' driver was beheaded to put pressure on negotiations for their release.

The BBC's Mark Dummett in Kabul says after intense lobbying from the Italians, a deal was done. Five Taleban were allowed to go and Mr Mastrogiacomo was set free.

Our correspondent says there was outrage in Afghanistan that the government would firstly bow to its enemy's demands and secondly that it would save a foreigner but not an Afghan.

The Taleban are still holding five government medics and two French aid workers along with three Afghan colleagues. Their fate will be decided next, they say.

President Hamid Karzai has ruled out any more hostage deals with the Taleban.

"[Mr Mastrogiacomo] was an extraordinary situation and won't be repeated again," Mr Karzai said on Friday. "No more deals with no-one and with no other country."





The lane leading to the Baghlan sugar factory is lined with trees. All of them have been painted white at the base, but one is now blackened.
This is where a suicide bomber detonated explosives last week.

In all, around 70 people died here. More than 100 people were injured.

The bomb, laced with ball bearings, targeted a delegation of MPs, but most of the victims were schoolboys, there to welcome the visiting dignitaries.

In the confusion after the blast, bodyguards working for the MPs opened fire.

When we arrived in Baghlan, north of Kabul, survivors and the bereaved clustered round us in minutes, eager to tell their stories.



Most of the injured were schoolboys gathering to greet the MPs

Mahmad Jaweid, 15, was on crutches. He was one of the walking wounded - one of the lucky ones.

He had been brought by his teacher to welcome the MPs. He ran away when he heard gunfire but was injured in the leg.

Shafiqullah, 18, lost two of his brothers in the blast. One of them was 10, the other 11.

'Enemies of Afghanistan'

After 30 years of conflict, Afghans have had to get used to violence. But this bombing shocked the country profoundly.

Partly because of the high number of deaths, partly because so many of the dead were children. And partly because no-one has claimed responsibility.

Many people blame what they call "the enemies of Afghanistan" - a phrase that can cover the Taleban, other insurgents or the factions led by various warlords.


Representatives of the government should not use bodyguards who have no experience and no judgement

Mohammad Fahim, teacher

But they also blame the government, for failing to protect them and their children.

Waladaji Barakat, a farmer, lost one of his sons and another was injured.

He said he would continue to send his sons to school once the period of mourning was over and the school had reopened. But one of his neighbours said he was withdrawing his children.

And all of them agreed, they would never send their children to greet visiting officials again. They did not trust the government to protect their children from attacks.

Teacher shortage

But whether the school will be able to reopen is unclear.

Five of its teachers were among the dead.

Since 2001 and the fall of the Taleban, the number of schools in Afghanistan has skyrocketed. In a small town like Baghlan, finding so many qualified teachers will not be easy.

For Mohammad Fahim, one of the teachers who was unharmed, the suicide bomb meant the loss of five of his colleagues. One of them was also his father.



Ribbons mark the place where the bomb exploded

"Representatives of the government should not use bodyguards who have no experience and no judgement. When the bomb went off, the bodyguards opened fire and killed some of our young people."

He pointed out two school exercise books belonging to a 16-year-old pupil, still lying on a dusty wall opposite the spot where the bomb went off.

He would never claim them now.

Ribbons in the colours of the Afghan flag - red, green, black and white - were tied round a nearby tree. No other visible marks remained.

Rumours that it might have been a roadside bomb, a landmine or a rocket attack circulated in the immediate aftermath of the explosion.

But there were no marks on the pavement. And all the eyewitnesses we spoke to confirmed it was a suicide bomb.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom