What's new

BBC: The Bin Laden Conspiracy?

Which version do you believe

  • American/Pakistani govt version

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • Seymour Hersh version

    Votes: 2 40.0%
  • Truth somewhere in between

    Votes: 2 40.0%

  • Total voters
    5
  • Democrats wanted an exit strategy for which they needed a 'victory'
  • Democrats needed to win the 2012 elections as Obama's ratings were down.
  • US Govt needed to convince its people that they had achieved 'something' in Afghanistan
  • Pakistan wanted the war in Afghanistan to end as it was destabilizing Pakistan.
  • Pakistan wanted to wipe out our hands from the decade old dirt and start afresh
  • Pakistan wanted to do it in a way which would save us the backlash of AQ and its allies hence letting US kill him instead of killing him ourselves.
US and Pakistani interests intertwined and we manufactured a falling of the curtain, US used its enormous media machine to sell it to the world while we took the flak and played dumb. Waited for a year and its business as normal. End of story.
 
Last edited:
.
Doesn't US operate airbases in Afghanistan?

that wasn't my point... i was talking about easy accessibility.

Plus that area is close to Afghan border as well.

"google maps" shows indian towns in kashmir to be easier in travel to abbotabad than from afghanistan... the helicopters being american will be acceptable to both india and pakistan... i have read the india angle somewhere...

snapshot1.png
 
.
that wasn't my point... i was talking about easy accessibility.



"google maps" shows indian towns in kashmir to be easier in travel to abbotabad than from afghanistan... the helicopters being american will be acceptable to both india and pakistan... i have read the india angle somewhere...

View attachment 231096
Mere bhai that border is heavily guarded and why should indian government allow americans to use india airfields?
American have their own bases in Afghanistan
 
.
Mere bhai that border is heavily guarded and why should indian government allow americans to use india airfields?
American have their own bases in Afghanistan

usa army and indian army have done joint training in indian kashmir before... what's to stop usa military from having helicopters there??

also, let us remember the joint operation to smuggle dalai lama in 1958.

  • Democrats wanted an exit strategy for which they needed a 'victory'
  • Democrats needed to win the 2012 elections as Obama's ratings were down.
  • US Govt needed to convince its people that they had achieved 'something' in Afghanistan
  • Pakistan wanted the war in Afghanistan to end as it was destabilizing Pakistan.
  • Pakistan wanted to wipe out our hands from the decade old dirt and start afresh
  • Pakistan wanted to do it in a way which would save us the backlash of AQ and its allies hence letting US kill him instead of killing him ourselves.
US and Pakistani interests intertwined and we manufactured a falling of the curtain, US used its enormous media machine to sell it to the world while we took the flak and played dumb. Waited for a year and its business as normal. End of story.

1. as me and jaanbaz have indicated, bin laden most probably died long back... i had read kidney failure but jaanbaz's vid has benazir saying murder.

2. the raid was in middle of 2011, with the libya and syria wars well underway... the american media machine had found two leaders to demonize.

3. qaeda was being used by nato heavily in the libya/syria regime-change plan... what would usa government gain by having bin laden killed??
 
.
usa army and indian army have done joint training in indian kashmir before... what's to stop usa military from having helicopters there??



1. as me and jaanbaz have indicated, bin laden most probably died long back... i had read kidney failure but jaanbaz's vid has benazir saying murder.

2. the raid was in middle of 2011, with the libya and syria wars well underway... the american media machine had found two leaders to demonize.

3. qaeda was being used by nato heavily in the libya/syria regime-change plan... what would usa government gain by having bin laden killed??

Because Pakistan is america's ally, raid originating from India would have caused a lot of embarrassment to the Pakistani government and would have heavily stained the relationship to a point beyond any redemption,
 
.
raid originating from India would have caused a lot of embarrassment to the Pakistani government and would have heavily stained the relationship to a point beyond any redemption,

you are right... though we must keep the second-origin theory open as the raiding party is a mutual friend.

maybe one of the military pdf members from india or pakistan can try to get the real story of the raid. :D
 
.
It was a drama
How could he lived that long he was on dialysis since 2001
 
.
Truth will be revealed in about 30 years time.

Just like in Liaqat Ali Khan's case.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom