What's new

Battle of ALCMs : BrahMos A vs Pakistan’s Ra’ad

even babur has lower range than what pakistan publicise according to some reliable sources :D
And An Indan keyboard warrior knows this

Raad do not violate the range restriction. So there is no bypassing.
According to another loser this is South African muspsow. So i posed a question if we bought it off shelf. The range is 350Km How comes it didnt ring any bells in MTCR ?

What do you have to show off, anyway ? 15 patents an year at USPTO ? Turbofan engines brought off-the-shelf ?
LOL. again brain farting, right? typical scoring brownie points. Th efact to the matter is we have the capability. Now you can whine about it all day long, but aint gonna change the fact

I Know You trolling

But I can Post a Scientific Literature & Patents of Brahmos Missile

But i assure you you cannot post Single genuine Scientific or Published Literature in case of your babur development Excpt media blogs and Articles


If you want we can start a Thread
Does it really matter ? we have the capability. thats what matters in the end of the day
 
And An Indan keyboard warrior knows this


According to another loser this is South African muspsow. So i posed a question if we bought it off shelf. The range is 350Km How comes it didnt ring any bells in MTCR ?


LOL. again brain farting, right? typical scoring brownie points. Th efact to the matter is we have the capability. Now you can whine about it all day long, but aint gonna change the fact


Does it really matter ? we have the capability. thats what matters in the end of the day

As far as capabilities go Brahmos is
Better
 
As far as capabilities go Brahmos is
Better
Nope not at all. considering the sheer industrial strength India has and pool of engineer. I strongly belief India could have done lot better on its own. But that its all about vision. In your case your vision is limited by comparing everything with that of PAkistan, a country six time smaller your size. Simply pathetic
 
LOL. again brain farting, right? typical scoring brownie points. Th efact to the matter is we have the capability. Now you can whine about it all day long, but aint gonna change the fact

That doesn't prove anything. Indians too can brag about Brahmos, while our own LFRJ technology is still in works.

considering the sheer industrial strength India has and pool of engineer. I strongly belief India could have done lot better on its own. But that its all about vision.

Guess_Livefist_SLIDE.jpg
 
For anyone who's interested. This is an informative post from @gambit


Is it possible to intercept Brahmos with a CIWS ?

Gambit's answer : Sure, but the problems of detection and tracking remains. You need to keep in mind that CIWS will be at ground level, therefore most susceptible to line-of-sight issues. When the Brahmos breaks horizon, the gun will have only literally seconds to reorient itself and fire. This short time span require equally precise radar information as if you are relying on a missile's radar to make its interception.

Question by me : lets say that the radar can track the target at distance of 8km but the gun can engage at 3 km, so can the target be intercepted when it's speed is 2 km/s ?

Gambit's answer : Assume radar tracking and gun reorient is perfect. It does not matter if target is supersonic. If the gun can engage at 3km, which in this case the assumption is head-on, then target speed is not an issue. The gun radar will calculate target speed, estimate when it will reach that 3km point, then fire just before the target reach that 3km point. If radar tracking and gun response are perfect, then bullets and target will meet at 3km distance out.

You should understand that in a head-on intercept, and continue to assume that tracking is perfect, the only reason why target approach speed is important is IF you want to avoid shrapnel. Because the intruder is coming so fast, even if you successfully hit him, there is still forward momentum at supersonic speed for a lot of small masses, still capable of doing a lot of damages if not kill something/someone.

So if we return to that 3km engagement distance, if radar tracking and gun reorient is not as good as you like, even though your bullets may intercept the intruder, that interception may be at 100 meters instead of 3km, spraying you with supersonic shrapnel. But let us say that your AWACS alerted you to a supersonic intruder, your gun reorient to the indicated direction and your gun radar begin transmitting. The moment the supersonic intruder breaks your horizon view, gun radar will have a solution and you will have interception at 3km distance out.

If you are defending something else that the intruder is going after, then the gun solution will lead the intruder, in other words, the bullets will be at an estimated point AHEAD of the intruder's flight and you still will have an interception at 3km distance out. In this situation, the lead depends on the off angle between you and whatever it is that you are defending.


Source: https://defence.pk/threads/brahmos-cant-be-intercepted-in-next-20-years.258714/page-11#post-4425874


Brahmos isn't the first hypersonic AShM. Similar Russian systems have been around for some time and NATO has continued to rely on the usual Gun and Missile based CIWS for their interception.
If you are relying on CIWS intercepting the Brahmos at 2-3KM then you are in BIG trouble. Furthermore, the Bhramos-A will not be employed as a AShM only but a full spectrum ALCM.
 
Raad is hoax. So far I saw only videos it flight.

Is there any launch/separation video or hitting the target?
 
I am not sure why did Manticore edited thread... Brahmos is co developed missile by both of India- Russia.... just like JF -17 for Pakistan.. when you guys consider JF 17 home grown ,why not us ....
 
That doesn't prove anything. Indians too can brag about Brahmos, while our own LFRJ technology is still in works.



Guess_Livefist_SLIDE.jpg
A poster doesntnprove anything. Even if I believe you, the brahmos is still a joint venture
 
what a weird comparison, the brahmos is a anti ship missile whilst the raad is a standoff missile
Ra'ad is nothing but Denel MUPSOW which was originally itended for RSAF cheetahs
you could be on to something here, both of them are red

45dfe09bd4b01_large.jpg
raad.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom