Assam Run Over By Bangladeshis | The Debate With Arnab Goswami.

[Homo Sapiens]

Don't faint, but have you thought of the possibility that they might be West Bengali Muslims? You wouldn't know unless you knew enough Bangla to distinguish accents. I do know, and I know that there are Bangladeshis in India.

If you are from west Bengal then will understand what I am saying, I don't think, a Bangladeshi person from Rajshahi and a Indian muslim from bordering district of Malda and Murshidabad have much difference in accent.Same is true for a Bangladeshi from Jessore and a Indian muslim from Nadia or 24 Parganas district.Same rule also apply for Bangladeshi districts and Assamese districts next to each other.Not all west Bengal muslim speak in standard Bengali and not all Bangladeshi speak in regional dialect.Jessore,Kushtia region of Bangladesh is the birth place of Bengali dialect which later known as standard Bengali.

 

[padamchen]

Not a proof doc.

Should India pay for the inability of the Bangladesh state to provide all.its citizens with an identity?

Do illegals anywhere in the world (Mexicans crossing into the US for instance) carry identity on them?

Cheers, Doc

 

[Joe Shearer]

If are from west Bengal then will understand what I am saying, I don't think, a Bangladeshi person from Rajshahi and a Indian muslim from bordering district of Malda and Murshidabad have much difference in accent.Same is true for a Bangladeshi from Jessore and a Indian muslim from Nadia or 24 Parganas district.Same rule also apply for Bangladeshi districts and Assamese districts next to each other.Not all west Bengal muslim speak in standard Bengali and not all Bangladeshi speak in regional dialect.Jessore,Kushtia region of Bangladesh is the birth place of Bengali dialect which later known as standard Bengali.

While you are right, I must then conclude that the groups I met (so many times) were from around my part of the country, as it was easy to distinguish their talk from standard Bengali. Incidentally, even in 'standard' Bengali, one can make out a Midnaporean from a south 24 Parganas person, from one from Birbhum. And none of them sound like the accents of my parentage - Dhaka and Barisal.

 

[RowdyRathore]

THE CONGRESS?
I'd rather cut my throat.

That's the problem; TINA.

I mean none of the political party have left to vote on except BJP,
Congress has been turned into a joke & third front (tho they don't have much ground)could be much worst than Congress.

 

[Joe Shearer]

I mean none of the political party have left to vote on except BJP,
Congress has been turned into a joke & third front could be much worst than Congress.

Very well said.

 

[Mage]

Should India pay for the inability of the Bangladesh state to provide all.its citizens with an identity?

Do illegals anywhere in the world (Mexicans crossing into the US for instance) carry identity on them?

Cheers, Doc

If you can't find the documents then what would you do? Round them up and take them close to BD border and start firing at them so they run to BD?

You can't expect BD to take whoever you claim to be an illegal Bangladeshi.

I mean none of the political party have left to vote on except BJP,
Congress has been turned into a joke & third front (tho they don't have much ground)could be much worst than Congress.

Go left. Join the revolution.

 

[RowdyRathore]

Go left. Join the revolution.

Left is dead now, what they did is what they got as payback, in a country like India that system wasn't meant to work in first place.

 

[Mage]

Left is dead now, what they did is what they got as payback, in a country like India that system wasn't meant to work in first place.

I was joking. I agree with you. This communism and socialism are not good for poor countries. Once the country is rich you can implement some socialist ideals to it but not for a developing country.

Communism can work if you can apply it strictly like the Chinese while having a free open market policy. But that's a rare example.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

There are crossings, I am not denying it and neither are you.

The elephant in the room is that the entire surplus cattle population of India lands up in Bangladesh, and the smuggling across the border is a huge source of income for the border forces on guard on either side.

A lot of illegal crossing is due to cattle smuggling.A cow which smuggler buy in India with just 5 thousand Rupees, fetch that same cow in Bangladesh equivalent of 50 thousand Rupees.Just by border crossing, they get 10 times profit! This is too much to ignore for a lot of people in the border areas.And they are even willing to take risk of their life to do it.So there is a vast criminal network operating in border region for cattle smuggling, which also encourage other illegal activities.This nexus of illegal crossing, other crimes and death by BSF could have broken if there were a legal channel to import cattle from India.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Left is dead now, what they did is what they got as payback, in a country like India that system wasn't meant to work in first place.

I think he was pulling your leg.

I was joking. I agree with you. This communism and socialism are not good for poor countries. Once the country is rich you can implement some socialist ideals to it but not for a developing country.

Communism can work if you can apply it strictly like the Chinese while having a free open market policy. But that's a rare example.

@RowdyRathore

LOL.

He was.

 

[RowdyRathore]

I think he was pulling your leg.



@RowdyRathore

LOL.

He was.

Haha

Communism can work if you can apply it strictly like the Chinese while having a free open market policy. But that's a rare example.

Communism didn't work in China also until 1970s they were more poor than us.
I'd call CCP a Capitalist Authoritarian Regime, but how they figured out to keep their state owned entities on track should've to be studied well. & i believe now is the time for them to ease some restrictions on their people as they're getting rich their 100s of thousands of millions moving to Western countries Canada & US under Immigrant Investor Programme to escape Chinese Authoritarian Regime & find a suited lifestyle.

 

[padamchen]

There I agree, within limits. Rounding up and deporting cannot apply to children born on Indian soil, not according to the Indian constitution. And since the CRPF will find it hard to nurse a three month old baby, the mother has to stay on as well. Unless we encourage her to earn a living prostituting herself, so must the father.

Let's keep this from becoming a replay of Trump's election campaign.

State foster care.

What the Sri Lankans did to rehabilitate Tamil war orphans.

Cheers, Doc

If you can't find the documents then what would you do? Round them up and take them close to BD border and start firing at them so they run to BD?

You can't expect BD to take whoever you claim to be an illegal Bangladeshi.


Go left. Join the revolution.

Identify and get them in one place. That's the important bit.

Put them to work. So that the state does not need to pay for their upkeep out of our pockets.

I wouldn't gather them along our eastern border at all.

I'd rehabilitate them.alongside Pakistan.

In the Thar.

Not an inch of useful land should be wasted on freeloading illegals.

And definitely not where they can melt away.

Cheers, Doc

 

[CHACHA"G"]

Bd is very small country with very large population. Where do you suppose Bd people will go if more land needed to live. We can not go to west Pakistan, can we?

You Indian should have thought about the consequences before breaking up Pakinstan into half. Ab Sambhalo...

Muslim Bd is not complete without Assam, Orissa, Bihar and Maghribi Bengal. Land of Nawab Saraj ud daulah, we are his Janasheen

nasrun min Allahi wa fathun qareeb.

I can say you put things very interestingly!!!!! Indian did a mistake in 70s , For how long they can control BDeshis or there Govt ?????? Time will change .
And for last line that will happen one day , I m very sure about it , but only if BDeshis realise that India is there enemy and they make sure a pro BD Govt not b!tch for or from India.
Only one advice for you people , Come out of hate of Pakistan , leave 70s behind , change your Govt and system ,upgrade your economy and add billion$$ to your defence bagged and be a normal Muslim country (not secular or extremist ).

 

[Mitro]

They are there before independence and indigenous people are busy drink and routine where these people work hard and multiply in great number .

 

[chatterjee]

-!!India is the 'supa powa' . The most developed country with 100% of employment rate. Population below poverty line is 0%. Indians are more white than white people. No one poop on the street. Happiest and most secured nation in the world. Champion in the HDI. People from all over the world come India for a better future, economic improvement. 200000000000 million poor Bangladeshis are living in India illegally to become rich like Indians.!!

-Son wake up! It's morning u need to go to school.

-