Arun Shourie on NaMo

[Dillinger]

Also respect Sushma ji greatly. She is an Indian.

And I find "Stephen-ian" pseudos like Mani Shankar Aiyar the biggest put offs.

Shourie is a Stephanian too and a real Secularist in many ways.

Ek kaam karo, yeh "pseudo-secular", "sickular" shabd use karna band karo. Either your ideology is secular or not secular, what you claim is not important- people have eyes and ears and they should be able to judge ki banda ya party sahi maine me secular hai ki secular hone ka dhong kar raha ya rahi hai, agar dhongi (you know who I'm pointing towards) hain to seedhe label them as NOT SECULAR. Semantics are important.

 

[Indo-guy]

Either way i think its too late for the govt. , either Modi comes to power or if congress comes back, then i think we may end up with an Egypt like situation.... i know it sounds laughable.. Soo many people are upset and angry , it only takes one small spark for the whole thing to blow over ...

Egypt like situation is unlikely in country like India !
I say very unlikely not impossible ....

I would have personally liked to have revolution happened in India ...but given India's democratic set up with enough space to vent up anger ...it will not happen.... For situation to explode like in Egypt you need decades of oppression with no way to vent out which results in revolution ...

It's 'good' as well as 'not good' for India .

I believe India has enough resilience to bounce back ...too much pessimism is not good for us !

Hopefully new government at center next year will break the vicious circle !!!

 

[Indo-guy]

Shourie is a Stephanian too and a real Secularist in many ways.

Ek kaam karo, yeh "pseudo-secular", "sickular" shabd use karna band karo. Either your ideology is secular or not secular, what you claim is not important- people have eyes and ears and they should be able to judge ki banda ya party sahi maine me secular hai ki secular hone ka dhong kar raha ya rahi hai, agar dhongi (you know who I'm pointing towards) hain to seedhe label them as NOT SECULAR. Semantics are important.

Much damage to our Nation has been perpetrated by this 'profession' of "Pseudo- Secularism " ... Most surprising section of our population has allowed themselves to be used as " Vote-banks" ....all these words are absolutely sickening ...and real insult to very concept of democracy ...

I see no difference between Pseudo-secularism and Communalism ! They are one and same thing !!!

 

[Dillinger]

Much damage to our Nation has been perpetrated by this 'profession' of "Pseudo- Secularism " ... Most surprising section of our population has allowed themselves to be used as " Vote-banks" ....all these words are absolutely sickening ...and real insult to very concept of democracy ...

I see no difference between Pseudo-secularism and Communalism ! They are one and same thing !!!

AND ergo the semantically correct terms should be used, quite a few of our babus are divisive and entrenched in identity politics, the terms that is apt is "divisive" not "pseudo-secular". That's what I am getting at. Lets call a spade a spade even if the said spade has been bedecked as richly as a groom- ab use ghode pe bitha ke baraat to nahi nikalwao ge na, kuch bhi karlo woh toh sirf gaddha khodne me kaam ana hai. We should get our labeling right when the need for labeling arises.

 

[sardar1987]

WHY IS SO MUCH TIME BEING WASTED ON SUCH USELESS DISCUSSIONS!!

 

[Umair Nawaz]

Yes the same Arun Shourie whose community was massacred and exiled out forcefully by 'pious peaceful' Muslims from Kashmir.

So such type of Kuttas cab become head of their political parties.

How Disgusting.

 

[Indo-guy]

WHY IS SO MUCH TIME BEING WASTED ON SUCH USELESS DISCUSSIONS!!

If it is indeed useless , you could have spared yourself that wastefulness !!!

Shows that it is not all that useless as you think !!!

 

[Umair Nawaz]

He never wrote any "book against islam".

there is a Guy Arun Shourie who is a Bengali Indian n is a big critique of Islam.

I hope its not him.

 

[sardar1987]

If it is indeed useless , you could have spared yourself that wastefulness !!!

Shows that it is not all that useless as you think !!!

we must think of economy right now,,,,not some speculations on 2014 although congress must be out at all costs

 

[Dillinger]

So such type of Kuttas cab become head of their political parties.

How Disgusting.

Better than a mujahid running around with DPC. A man has the right to criticize any religion and any religious figure including Mohammad, what is sacred and beyond criticism for you or me need not be the same for others. Learn to cope with valid criticism and arguments against your religion.

 

[Umair Nawaz]

Better than a mujahid running around with DPC. A man has the right to criticize any religion and any religious figure including Mohammad, what is sacred and beyond criticism for you or me need not be the same for others. Learn to cope with valid criticism and arguments against your religion.

Shutup Kiddo.

Dont speak about something u dont know.

 

[janon]

So such type of Kuttas cab become head of their political parties.

How Disgusting.

Who are you referring to as "kuttas", the people who got massacred and exiled from their beautiful homeland in Kashmir, or the ones who did the massacre?

 

[Dillinger]

Shutup Kiddo.

Dont speak about something u dont know.

Standard ad hominem, hallmark of intellectual poverty. Them madrasas must be losing their edge.

 

[Umair Nawaz]

Who are you referring to as "kuttas", the people who got massacred and exiled from their beautiful homeland in Kashmir, or the ones who did the massacre?

Now i dont have a single doubt why Muslims hate India. and it is called Israel of South Asia.

 

[janon]

Now i dont have a single doubt why Muslims hate India. and it is called Israel of South Asia.

Muslims don't hate India, in fact they live with more rights and freedoms in India than in many of the so called pure lands. There is a reason that India has more muslims than the arab world, in fact the second or third biggest muslim population on earth. They don't get massacred for belonging to the wrong sect, and that's just one example of how they are better off in India than in the land of the pure.

Anyway, your reply has nothing to do with my post. I asked a simple question. Who were you referring to as "Kuttas", in post number 66? The people who got massacred, or the people who did the massacring?