An Afghan refugee’s appeal to Pakistan’s prime minister

[hussain0216]

No sale!!!

We gave Afghanis the opportunity to be loyal and they chose namak harami

Go home Afghanis

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

noooo we will be fucked up

We already are.

 

[maximuswarrior]

Right...I'm not worried about what the world would say...I know that their stay was to be temporary...and had it been JUST AFGHANS...I would say no problem...send them all back.

My argument is for the Pakistanis...those Afghans who are not found to be against Pak(not involved in anti Pak activities)...and have Pakistani families(spouses/children)...if they are sent back...
What are we to do with their Pakistani family members? Hold their Pakistani family members back in Pakistan and tear apart families? Or send these Pakistanis to Afghanistan(which u say is safe according to India)?

Obviously any Afghan(whether refugee or illegal immigrant), if he/she has no Pakistani family members should be sent back right away...but it's a little more complicated in case of those who have families here.

The complexities like marriage, family, etc. are there whether we like it or not. They are not a separate issue and have to be addressed when deporting someone out of the country. Which option would u pick? Would u only send back Afghanis and hold back their Pakistani family members? Or would u also send their Pakistani family members to Afghanistan?

There is absolutely no way to find out whether an Afghan living inside Pakistan is anti-state or otherwise. It is mission impossible. That should however not serve as the gauge to repatriate Afghans. The real gauge is that Afghan refugees had a temporary stay in Pakistan. Time has come for Afghans to return to Afghanistan and rebuild their own nation. Time is up.

Those Pakistani family members who married Afghan nationals brought it upon themselves. They should have known better. More importantly, why did these individuals marry an Afghan fully knowing he/she belongs to a hostile nation which dislikes our state and even claims our territory? I have some serious questions about the loyalty of such Pakistanis. They have no issues with getting married to hostile Afghans, but cry rivers when Pakistan has to send them back.

My solution is to send such Pakistanis along with their Afghan wife or husband.

 

[Imran Khan]

We already are.

but that will be next lavel they will gain power of gov offices have role in policy making they will have jobs in nadra army airforce navy passport office FO etc

 

[Dark-Destroyer]

If there families are born in Pakistan they should be granted citizenship when Pakistanis go abroad it's the same thing their families are granted citizenship why are we being hypocritical we will take citizenship of other nations but won't give it

 

[maximuswarrior]

If there families are born in Pakistan they should be granted citizenship when Pakistanis go abroad it's the same thing their families are granted citizenship why are we being hypocritical we will take citizenship of other nations but won't give it

Pakistanis don't mass flee to another nation as refugees. Most Pakistanis seeking citizenship have economic reasons. Those Pakistanis who seek refugee status are also repatriated when the situation becomes safe in country of origin. If Afghans seek Pakistani citizenship based on economic security they need to apply from Afghanistan through the official channel. I am sure Pakistan can look on a case to case basis. You are comparing apples with oranges.

Did you know that most NATO nations are today declining even temporary stay for Afghans? Those Afghan refugees who are already in NATO countries are being sent back forcefully.

Don't question the hospitality of Pakistanis. If we were that bad we wouldn't have kept Afghans for so long in our country.

 

[Imran Khan]

wow million pakistanis live in arab world rich east asians like mal brunai etc whom got nationality there ? only few countries give nationality by birth

If there families are born in Pakistan they should be granted citizenship when Pakistanis go abroad it's the same thing their families are granted citizenship why are we being hypocritical we will take citizenship of other nations but won't give it

wow million pakistanis live in arab world rich east asians like mal brunai etc whom got nationality there ? only few countries give nationality by birth

If there families are born in Pakistan they should be granted citizenship when Pakistanis go abroad it's the same thing their families are granted citizenship why are we being hypocritical we will take citizenship of other nations but won't give it

 

[maximuswarrior]

but that will be next lavel they will gain power of gov offices have role in policy making they will have jobs in nadra army airforce navy passport office FO etc

This is how bad things have become:

HDP leader Ahmed Ali Kohzad arrested in murder case

https://www.dawn.com/news/1435138/hdp-leader-ahmed-ali-kohzad-arrested-in-murder-case

They are contesting elections. Pakistanis have developed a bad habit of turning a blind eye to all the wrongs happening in our society.

 

[AZ1]

Don't give citizenship it will create mess and add negative to PTI vote bank for sure.

 

[Crystal-Clear]

Imran will be history if he tries to give citizenship to namak haram afghans . ( i am a hardcore pti suppprter /voter ) .

wow million pakistanis live in arab world rich east asians like mal brunai etc whom got nationality there ? only few countries give nationality by birth.

they took refuge in our country . there is a difference between refugee and a person with legal visa and prc .
.
plus
.
afghans arnt loyal to Pakistan at any level . they will leave no opportunity to harm us .

 

[Kabira]

Don't give citizenship it will create mess and add negative to PTI vote bank for sure.

They can't give citizenship alone. If such decision is taken it will be with everyone on same page, kind of like FATA merger etc

 

[Imran Khan]

عمران خان کوئی پاگل دا پتر ہے ۔ ہمارے پاس ہزار ہا مسائل پڑے ہوئے اور جا کر کراچی مین انکو ٹھیک کرنے کی بجائے ایک اور فتنہ کھڑا کر آیا بی سی ۔ ابے پانی ہے نا بجلی کچرے کا ڈھیر بن گیا کراچی کچی آبادیاں سیوریج پر بنی ہیں شہر کی جی ڈی پی تمام اس سائز کے جنوبی ایشین شہروں سے کم ہے ۔ اور چلا ہے بھوسڑی کا نیشنلتی بانٹنے ۔ عوام پہلے ہی وہاں تقسیم در تقسیم ہے لسانیت پر اس نے جا کر اوپر تیل ڈال دیا ۔ جن کے پاس پاکستانی نیشنلٹی ہے انکے سارے مسائل حل کر لیے تم نے ؟

 

[AMMT]

We should provide citizenship to refugees lived in country for 10 years and more. Also their children who born in Pakistan should be eligible for citizenship.

All those who are against this should be ashamed. Remember Pakistan is made for poor not for ignorants.

When one class of people allow outsiders to destroy neighbors then what to expect from such class of people. Losses happened on both side and spoiler took an advantage.

How many dollars earned from war on terror by killing your own brothers and selling your sisters. Where’s your commando? Mush

Lal masjid, baldia factory, balochistan operation, model town, rivers sold to rivals etc. History is full of corruption and injustice. Look at current judicial system, can’t able to arrest corrupts and murderers.

 

[Dark-Destroyer]

wow million pakistanis live in arab world rich east asians like mal brunai etc whom got nationality there ? only few countries give nationality by birth


wow million pakistanis live in arab world rich east asians like mal brunai etc whom got nationality there ? only few countries give nationality by birth

That's limited to the middle East in Europe they do give nationality to children of immigrants asylum seekers and refugees

Pakistanis don't mass flee to another nation as refugees. Most Pakistanis seeking citizenship have economic reasons. Those Pakistanis who seek refugee status are also repatriated when the situation becomes safe in country of origin. If Afghans seek Pakistani citizenship based on economic security they need to apply from Afghanistan through the official channel. I am sure Pakistan can look on a case to case basis. You are comparing apples with oranges.

Did you know that most NATO nations are today declining even temporary stay for Afghans? Those Afghan refugees who are already in NATO countries are being sent back forcefully.

Don't question the hospitality of Pakistanis. If we were that bad we wouldn't have kept Afghans for so long in our country.

I didn't question the hospitality of Pakistanis I am just stating that as there is no harm in accepting the children as Pakistan's and I believe it's not as bad as it's being made out

 

[BATMAN]

Anyone who lives in Pakistan for 10 years... should get citizenship.
Those born in Pakistan, if lived 5 years should be given citizenship.
Those Afghans, whom Zardari regime imported and even gave them ID cards during his rule, such Afghans should be arrested along with Zardari and Rehman Malik.