Alexander the Great/ Mauryans/ Graeco-Bactrians

[Indus Pakistan]

But overall, the Indo-Aryan populations which constitute the majority of both countries do share some similarities.

Tell me where in the world can you find two countries [neighbours] with no similarities ~ with exception of migrant nations? This mantra that is brought up all the time has no meaning. It is stating the obvious.

All human beings are actually 99.99999 the same. And that includes a Bantu Negro, a Eskimo, a Nordic Swede, a Pygmy Austro-Aboriginal from India or a Mongol.

But while India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, Myanmar share similiarities but they do have differance. Each has a diferant recipe for it's national gene pool. Leaving the Dravidian, Austro-Aboriginals of India strongly dominating south and east of that country who have minimal presence in Pakistan even the Indo-Aryans in both countries have degree of differance. Primarily the IA of India have a higher degree and frequency of Ancestral South Indian inheritence then in Pakistan.

 

[Hamza913]

Volumes have been written about the ancestry of the Mauryas, and none of the references even hint at a Punjabi origin. How on earth did our pocket propagandist come to that conclusion?

I'm pretty sure he either just got confused over the fact that Chandragupta Maurya studied in Taxila, or mistyped what he meant.

 

[Joe Shearer]

I'm pretty sure he either just got confused over the fact that Chandragupta Maurya studied in Taxila, or mistyped what he meant.

I see. Yes, it is a possibility, but why doesn't he say so himself? The mistyping is improbable; the remark was in a context where the Punjabi antecedents of the emperor were aligned to many other aspects of Maurya rule, but perhaps there was an impression that Chandragupta's earlier presence there pointed to his origins there. Again, if he was in Taxila, how did that make him a Punjabi?

 

[Pakistani E]

Look at your posts and of Pan Islamic Pakistan. It is you people who were saying that it is not shared but only Pakistan''s history.
It is me who said in my first comment that it is shared.
When you arrogantly refused my comments, then I showed you people the mirror with DNA evidence of Rakhigadhi skeletons.

Pakistanis have every right to say that. This is a Pakistani forum after all. Indians wander around claiming everything anyway. No harm with Pakistanis taking pride in their history.

You didn't show me any mirror. You need to read more in to Rakhigarhi DNA results further, it doesn't prove the point you're trying to make.

 

[Pakistani E]

nomadic goat f**king

Man, why are you so obsessed with goat f*king? Second post I've seen within 20 minutes from you about this. What's going on?

 

[Cobra Arbok]

Tell me where in the world can you find two countries [neighbours] with no similarities ~ with exception of migrant nations? This mantra that is brought up all the time has no meaning. It is stating the obvious.

All human beings are actually 99.99999 the same. And that includes a Bantu Negro, a Eskimo, a Nordic Swede, a Pygmy Austro-Aboriginal from India or a Mongol.

But while India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, Myanmar share similiarities but they do have differance. Each has a diferant recipe for it's national gene pool. Leaving the Dravidian, Austro-Aboriginals of India strongly dominating south and east of that country who have minimal presence in Pakistan even the Indo-Aryans in both countries have degree of differance. Primarily the IA of India have a higher degree and frequency of Ancestral South Indian inheritence then in Pakistan.

I believe that is what I said. My position is a moderate one, between India and Paksitan have nothing in common and India and Pakistan are completely different. With that being said, I differ from you in my belief that although the Indo-Iranian populations of Paksitan(pashtos and Balochis) are completely different from all the populations of India, most of Pakistans Indo Aryan Populations(mainly Punjabis and sindhis) are not too different from most Indo-Aryan populations of India, except maybe those on the far East. Like I said, although there may be the genetic differences

Man, why are you so obsessed with goat f*king? Second post I've seen within 20 minutes from you about this. What's going on?

that was in response to his aboriginal comment. But you are right, such language is inapropriate. I will avoid using it from now.