AgNoStiC MuSliM
ADVISORS
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2007
- Messages
- 25,259
- Reaction score
- 87
- Country
- Location
It is none of your business what they are selling - some Sunni scholars also claim Shia are 'selling lies to the world', so next we'll see the State calling Shia non-Muslims and open discrimination against them?They can call what they want to call but the problem is they are selling lies to the world.
Good, then there should be no issue with the Ahmadis practicing their faith as they please and calling themselves what they wish since 'even ignorant, uneducated Muslims' know the difference.Even an ignorant, uneducated Muslim knows well that for becoming a Muslim you have to accept the finality of Prophethood of Last Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there is no prohphet after him.
That is for Allah to decide, since only He knows the heart of an individual, and not for mortals on this earth.And anyone who claims is a a kazzab and liar and he/she would be out of Islam.
That is absurd - they think themselves Muslims - you have no right to force your opinion upon them. You can preach your beliefs in a peaceful manner that Ahmadi beliefs are not true (as can they) but you have no right to force your religious beliefs on another community by passing laws against them.Mosques are worship places for Muslims and if non-Muslims want to call their worship places as moques or masjids they can but if they are doing so just to fool the world and prove that they are Muslims then here is the difference.
Off topic - you have no right to place a test on being a Muslim - this is solely Allah's responsibility.
OK all the qadyani members on the forum just recite the kalima tayabba or accept that Muhammad (PBUH) is the last prophet of Allah and there is no Prophet after him. Then i will accept you as Muslims. And those who have claimed false prophethood after Muhammad (PBUH) are liars and kazzabs. Are you ready to do that?????
Glad to here that.We/I condemn these bigots for such kinds of violence and here i will support security and safety for qadyanis.
There is no precedent of killings of murdits in Islam and Quran so I do NOT support this bigotry.
Then why are we forcing Ahmadis to practice their faith as WE want (compulsion) and placing restrictions on how they practice it?We are ok with that as Quran clearly says that there is no compulsion in faith .
Quran does not state that people have the right to judge whether someone is a Muslim or not and pass laws on that issue - using your argument the State should be judging every individual on whether he is 'Muslim' or not, if he drinks, committed a crime, does not have a beard, committed adultery etc. etc.Quran also clarifies who is a Muslim and who is NOT so as per Quran we are not ready to accept murdits as Muslims.
There is no instruction in the Quran calling for ordinary people, scholars or politicians, to pass judgment on the faith of other people - that is solely up to Allah.