A Vision of a New Combined Arms Philosophy & Doctrine

[Joe Shearer]

All thanks to you my dear friend! Always glad to see your input and always learning from them.



And what do you think Pakistan has deeper pockets than your favored state? : )

Precisely not. So it is better to talk reality, not pie-in-the-sky.

 

[Armchair]

If you are able to spend time, start from north, using google earth, lowest level, and you'll be able to trace the EXACT defensive lines of IA. Would be difficult, but useful.

I remember you showed me the Pakistani line on Google Map around 2012. I'll try searching for them but I think the map here shows their position roughly.

 

[PanzerKiel]

I remember you showed me the Pakistani line on Google Map around 2012. I'll try searching for them but I think the map here shows their position roughly. View attachment 624982

This rough business wont get you anywhere. Go deep.

 

[Armchair]

If you are able to spend time, start from north, using google earth, lowest level, and you'll be able to trace the EXACT defensive lines of IA. Would be difficult, but useful.

Panzerkiel is this the line?

 

[PanzerKiel]

Perhaps you could help your apt pupil by informing him that water obstacles are not usually found in the desert.

Actually there, on both sides. Only require water charging for which everything is ready. Defences are already prepared. I am attaching a file of a DCB in desert, bunkers every 100 m can are visible.

Panzerkiel is this the line?
View attachment 624983

Tell me, why arent yo zoomin btw?

 

[Joe Shearer]

Actually there, on both sides. Only require water charging for which everything is ready. Defences are already prepared. I am attaching a file of a DCB in desert, bunkers every 100 m can are visible.

I am gobsmacked.

Tell me, why arent yo zoomin btw?

 

[ali_raza]

Perhaps you could help your apt pupil by informing him that water obstacles are not usually found in the desert.

indra canal

Actually there, on both sides. Only require water charging for which everything is ready. Defences are already prepared. I am attaching a file of a DCB in desert, bunkers every 100 m can are visible.



Tell me, why arent yo zoomin btw?

are these the bunkers?

 

[Joe Shearer]

indra canal

As it happens, it lies some distance from the border, and I never thought of it as a defence against attack. I am not sure what @PanzerKiel was referring to, in #320. In 71, there was nothing between Longewala and Jaisalmer.

 

[ali_raza]

As it happens, it lies some distance from the border, and I never thought of it as a defence against attack. I am not sure what @PanzerKiel was referring to, in #320. In 71, there was nothing between Longewala and Jaisalmer.

the pics i posted r defensive forts on indian side

 

[Joe Shearer]

the pics i posted r defensive forts on indian side

Much appreciated. Let me go through them.

 

[Armchair]

Tell me, why arent yo zoomin btw?

Just to show the overall picture. The Pakistani lines are much deeper but I think (and am suprised) a part of the Pakistani line seems to have changed (??) New canals I'm assuming.

 

[Joe Shearer]

the pics i posted r defensive forts on indian side

Those are not bunkers, those are walled compounds, totally indefensible against any substantial attack. Actually, only the last is of a walled compound, and it does not look as if it could hold out against an infantry company. I suspect @PanzerKiel had something more substantial in mind.

 

[Armchair]

@Joe Shearer don't take the cooking pot comment to heart, for us its an enemy engaged in genocide and ethnic cleansing against Muslims. This is how we talk about such an enemy. You're always welcome to have a cup of tea as a noncombatant.

Joe did you really not know about the water obstacle and bunkers? I'm surprised.

If you zoom to the line I've shown you'll see them. @Joe Shearer

 

[Joe Shearer]

@Joe Shearer don't take the cooking pot comment to heart, for us its an enemy engaged in genocide and ethnic cleansing against Muslims. This is how we talk about such an enemy. You're always welcome to have a cup of tea as a noncombatant.

It seems that our standards differ. Trash talking will not win 'you' wars, it will only show you as bad losers. As for tea, my Darjeeling is good enough, thank you very much; the day you have your own victories against to India to celebrate, do let me know.

Joe did you really not know about the water obstacle and bunkers? I'm surprised.

Not in the south.

 

[Armchair]

It seems that our standards differ. Trash talking will not win 'you' wars, it will only show you as bad losers. As for tea, my Darjeeling is good enough, thank you very much; the day you have your own victories against to India to celebrate, do let me know.



Not in the south.

You feel that your standards differ but reality is, if your family members were being lynched, raped, pillaged, burnt, hanged, your standards would magically change. Our Muslim brothers and sisters are facing this from India in Kashmir and now all over northern India.

The day you can watch your sister and mother being raped and have a stiff upper lipped conversation over tea, do let me know. Muslims are one family and our hearts bleed wherever our people suffer such horrendous and state sponsored atrocities.

@PanzerKiel this is where everyone thinks PA and IA will duke it out with maneuver warfare and tank battles galore.