A question to both intelligent Bangladeshis and Bangladeshi Poodle Indians

[VikingRaider]

I think many Bangladeshi ( both AL an non AL ) already expressed their point of view here . Almost everybody believe that it was limited under 3 lakh from both side .

I have posted an interview of Dr Ahmed Sharif who gave a reference of journalist Nirmal sen and said that the death number was limited to 2.5 lakh from both side .

However since there was no way to know the exact figure, so I believe the real number should be , " Countless " instead of 3 millions .

 

[Nilgiri]

at least 10,000 innocent people were killed on 25 March night.

It included lot of your best people too, very smart intelligent people. Deliberately targeted in universities, courts and high-acumen area of society in general.

i.e Intelligentsia decapitation...BD took a very big loss long term from it. It has been explained to me in most somber terms by my close friend's father and my friend as well. There was a big envy in play too (toward Bengal historic status and general respect to its value and proving of intelligence, wealth and societal temperance).

It is actually what propelled his father to join the resistance as freedom fighter (seeing the events of that night and following nights and days as young man, and knowing the straw on camel back is long pushed beyond)...significant because he was very devoted to concept of Pakistan personally, and still today has a great love for Pakistani people, cricket team, aesthetic etc. In fact I see much similar in notable BD members of this forum too.

He is quite well known corporate business owner today in BD...his hard work and dedication paid off....but of course the history and personal experience cannot and can never be forgotten.

His son here in Canada in our university days told me so much I would otherwise not have understood about BD. 99.9% of Indians do not get that opportunity so they are very uneducated about it.

@Joe Shearer

 

[VikingRaider]

Sarmila Bose fan detected.

Brother, nothing should be regarded as absolute truth unless you can count every single dead body .

I don't agree with sharmila bose as she took Pakistani side one sidedly .

But 3 millions claim without slightest logic doesn't seem right to me.

If we claim something, we have to prove it .

Genocide is such accusations that will cause a nation a parmanent damage .

Germany is still not allowed to form an offensive military power ( correct me please if I am wrong ).

At least holocaust has many concrete evidences .

But when someone question about our 3 million figure, chamchas became so offensive, as if it is a blasphemy .

That's not the right thing IMHO bhai .

 

[X-ray Papa]

Brother, nothing should be regarded as absolute truth unless you can count every single dead body .

I don't agree with sharmila bose as she took Pakistani side one sidedly .

But 3 millions claim without slightest logic doesn't seem right to me.

If we claim something, we have to prove it .

Genocide is such accusations that will cause a nation a parmanent damage .

Germany is still not allowed to form an offensive military power ( correct me please if I am wrong ).

At least holocaust has many concrete evidences .

But when someone question about our 3 million figure, chamchas became so offensive, as if it is a blasphemy .

That's not the right thing IMHO bhai .

TBH if its burma then i will believe the numbers, because i find it strange that the pakistanis randomly went around killing people.
Obviously its a war, some innocent lives are lose, but 3 million in 9 months, thats crazy.

 

[VikingRaider]

TBH if its burma then i will believe the numbers, because i find it strange that the pakistanis randomly went around killing people.
Obviously its a war, some innocent lives are lose, but 3 million in 9 months, thats crazy.

It"s even very hard for the Burmese butchers to kill 3 millions in just less than 9 months . Some chetona khors aka offshoot of leftists who have been infesting AL since Pakistan time are sometimes looks too inept to spread propaganda.
If Hitler killed 6 million people in 5 years then how come that any nation can kill 3 millions in just less than 8 months ?

Besides no nation will suffer alone,even if. Burmese try to arrange such massive murder,others will try to prevent it.

Our neighbor pretend that they were our savior. So if really Pakistanis murdered such amount where were they ? Why didn't they raise the issue in security council?

There should be a limit of spreading propaganda , but it looks they are too dumb to understand that .

So finally three lakh is acceptable maybe ,but still everyone has this right to ask evidence if even we claim 3 lakh instead of 3 million.


@X-ray Papa

 

[X-ray Papa]

It"s even very hard for the Burmese butchers to kill 3 millions in just less than 9 months . Some chetona khors aka offshoot of leftists who have been infesting AL since Pakistan time are sometimes look too full to soread propaganda.
If Hitler killed 6 million people in 5 years then how come that any nation can kill 3 millions in just less than 8 months ?

Besides no nation will suffer alone,even if. Burmese try to arrange such massive murder,others will try to prevent it.

Our neighbor pretend that they were our savior. So if really Pakistanis murdered such amount where were they ? Why didn't they raise the issue in security council?

There should be a limit of spreading propaganda , but it looks they are too dumb to understand that .

So finally three lakh is acceptable maybe ,but still everyone has this right to ask evidence if even we claim 3 lakh instead of 3 million.


@X-ray Papa

Its AL after all, a pro-indian magis whom doesnt give a shit about bangladesh. All they care about earning money and living in a foreign country.There is no doubt they spreed propaganda too.

That General in 2008 should either take total control of bangladesh or give to muhammad yunus or whoever is pro-bangladeshi and wants best for bangladesh. Because of this khanki General , pro-indian munfiqs has taken control.



As for the neighbors, like i said they the most delusional people on earth. Why would they want to take it to the security council, about muslim killings muslims? In fact they are happy about. They came to divide pakistan and did it. Savior my ***.

 

[VikingRaider]

As for the neighbors, like i said they the most delusional people on earth. Why would they want to take it to the security council, about muslim killings muslims? In fact they are happy about. They came to divide pakistan and

No disagreement. Well said.

 

[American Pakistani]

It included lot of your best people too, very smart intelligent people. Deliberately targeted in universities, courts and high-acumen area of society in general.

i.e Intelligentsia decapitation...BD took a very big loss long term from it. It has been explained to me in most somber terms by my close friend's father and my friend as well. There was a big envy in play too (toward Bengal historic status and general respect to its value and proving of intelligence, wealth and societal temperance).

It is actually what propelled his father to join the resistance as freedom fighter (seeing the events of that night and following nights and days as young man, and knowing the straw on camel back is long pushed beyond)...significant because he was very devoted to concept of Pakistan personally, and still today has a great love for Pakistani people, cricket team, aesthetic etc. In fact I see much similar in notable BD members of this forum too.

He is quite well known corporate business owner today in BD...his hard work and dedication paid off....but of course the history and personal experience cannot and can never be forgotten.

His son here in Canada in our university days told me so much I would otherwise not have understood about BD. 99.9% of Indians do not get that opportunity so they are very uneducated about it.

@Joe Shearer

My Bangladeshi friend also told me how Bharti terrorists were checking lungis and killing whoever was Muslim. They were envy too and they wanted the revenge of 65 loss when Bengalis annihilated bhart. Bharti terrorist army also killed 20k Bengalis a day & consumed their bodies, whoever remained was painted with Pakistani flag so to show it was pakistan.

You don't have anything else to do other than playing your Bharti sport of propaganda to see others fight while you enjoy?

@Imran Khan @I S I

Look at your buddy.

@to pic

Afaisee here in United States, most Bangladeshis does not hate Pakistanis. But yes there are many brainwashed who believe 3 lakh or 30 lakh were killed. It's all due to their Haseena regime who brainwashed them.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Both BAL and PA establishments were suffering from the syndrome of WE vs THEY. However, in the case of BAL it was constituted by civilian people. On the other hand, it was the govt PA troops that indiscriminately killed in Dhaka to show their stupid prowess.

There is a gulf of difference in these two establishments. If 10,000 people were not killed every day of the war, at least 10,000 innocent people were killed on 25 March night.

Any genuine, credible, irrefutable and compelling evidence for the above claims? If YES then remember to forward them to the International War Crimes tribunal at the Hague.

 

[Bilal9]

@krash bhai - this is a superfluous unproductive troll-bait thread in my opinion. A sticky 1971 thread already exists. I have no idea, why this question was not posed there, instead a separate thread was created.

IMHO - this discussion is fifty years too late and has no possible potential to add to the normalization of relations and friendship between our two countries. All the thread can do is spread hate and mudslinging.

There are a few other troll-bait threads too - created in the last few days. Too many Bangladesh haters, who knows which country they belong to, regardless of flag.

 

[DalalErMaNodi]

Bal er thread.

Even Bangladeshis here are arguing over semantics ???

Are you all insane ?


Pathetic.

I wouldn't even comment here, were it not for the fact that my countrymen are making some absurd comments on this thread.

 

[Michael Corleone]

The number was popularized after yahya said to kill 3 million of them... I guess his words became fact post war.
I would rather concentrate on the crimes committed than numbers claimed. The evidence is there for anyone in Dhaka museums... tons of skeletons filling the room, pictures of dead intellectuals filling the swamp, a fridge that had a chair in it that was live (supposedly to freeze and shock at the same time) countless other evidences and factual representations of a genocide. I rather concentrate on the crime committed than numbers as it’s impossible to keep accurate numbers in a war where both govt. were not even in the same land

I think owing to increasing tensions, there should have been a plebiscite and if begalis wanted a separate country, they should have been given.
Its a mistake on part of Pakistani establishment at the time. Its not feasible to control an eastern portion thousands of kms away with an enemy airspace in between. Its only possible with free will and if they detected bengalis want to separate, they should have been given a fair referendum.
Bangladesh was going to separate anyway, but this way, we would still be allied and would have good relations.

Wrong. Bangladeshi people didn’t want independence until democracy was lost in Pakistan... at most autonomy would have been granted if the war didn’t happen... but thank the fool who fired the first shot

Germany is still not allowed to form an offensive military power ( correct me please if I am wrong ).

More like Germans are not interested in war, perks of being in an inclusive society with first world privilege

 

[VikingRaider]

More like Germans are not interested in war, perks of being in an inclusive society with first world privilege

My perspective of the comparison was different though.

 

[alhindi]

This thread is about the 1971 Pakistani Civil War which lead to the creation of another Muslim country in South Asia, courtsey of Indian state-sponsored terrorism.

Date of the military operations
Started: Friday, 26 March 1971
Ended:Thursday, 16 December 1971

Result: 265 days

Bangladeshi people are brainwashed into believing 3 million Bangladeshis were killed in 265 days.

3,000,000 claimed deaths / 265 days = 11,320 deaths daily

That would mean 265 mass graves with at least 11,320 dead bodies.

How many and where exactly are these mass graves with at least 11,320 dead bodies in them?

3 lakh is a possibility .

 

[TNT]

The number was popularized after yahya said to kill 3 million of them... I guess his words became fact post war.
I would rather concentrate on the crimes committed than numbers claimed. The evidence is there for anyone in Dhaka museums... tons of skeletons filling the room, pictures of dead intellectuals filling the swamp, a fridge that had a chair in it that was live (supposedly to freeze and shock at the same time) countless other evidences and factual representations of a genocide. I rather concentrate on the crime committed than numbers as it’s impossible to keep accurate numbers in a war where both govt. were not even in the same land


Wrong. Bangladeshi people didn’t want independence until democracy was lost in Pakistan... at most autonomy would have been granted if the war didn’t happen... but thank the fool who fired the first shot


More like Germans are not interested in war, perks of being in an inclusive society with first world privilege

Bengalis really wanted to separate, one unit was also not acceptable to them.
The thing is, its mostly sabotage and propaganda. I read an account where indian stooges killed bengalis brutally and portrayed it as torture n killing by Pakistan army. When u collude with an enemy like india, then they will do many things. The irony is those hindus still hate u as much as us. The 3 million nmbr is fake and media created and nothing more. Though i agree there were things that hapenned because it was a war.
So now either we can move on or just kept stuck in past.