What's new

proposal for a new division of south asia

Status
Not open for further replies.
You should write that in Greek, because its the only classical language which a classical language speaker should learn, stop speaking non-Classical Germanic-French cocktail called English. :girl_wacko::girl_wacko:

net migration is to south... no need to waste time learning hindi...
 
Afghanistan and Bangladesh do not speak this language.. And definitely, Dravidian parties will never accept a solution like this (Even I wont). Remember Bengali was the reason for breaking of Pakistan. This will bound to fail.. India is a diverse country. We need to respect its diversity .
And what of Militants who want to establish a Worldwide Islamic state? I have concerns with my country's borders opened to Pakistani tribal areas and radicalized militants, and to BD, where their workforce will enter our country at large and natives will be at a disadvange..
Germany took more than a decade to recover from its unification with East Germany, that too when its population is less and W.Germany was rich with funds from USA and Europe. Now Imagine India. It will take a century, and the geography of India in the said Union ,will again take 30 years to reach where it was at 2013 again.
All countries had their chances. Its just now India is utilizing its chances. Thanks but no thanks.
Mate maybe you are not fully aware but many of south indian and Bangla as well as Afghan people have assimilated Hindi as well. I have met many of them personally. Thank you. Even my best friend is A malyali only.
 
net migration is to south... no need to waste time learning hindi...

But why you speak non-Classical English. Write that in Greek, that's the only living Classical language from Europe and keep your honor of speaking a classical language, English is a Germanic-French cocktail of Anglo-Saxons and Normans. :omghaha::omghaha:
 
But why you speak non-Classical English. Write that in Greek, that's the only living Classical language from Europe and keep your honor of speaking a classical language, English is a Germanic-French cocktail of Anglo-Saxons and Normans. :omghaha::omghaha:
dafaq.. i am against only hindi.. my mother tongue is great english is useful what is the need for bimaru hindi?
 
dafaq.. i am against only hindi.. my mother tongue is great english is useful what is the need for bimaru hindi?

You are insulting your classical language and signature by learning non-classical Germanic-French cocktail English. Go learn some Greek and speak in Greek only with white people and boycott English if you respect your classical language. :laughcry:
 
Solve the Kashmir issue first and then talk about all that. I am not in favour of Communism. Democracy is better choice but we can make our country Democratic Socialist republic where political system is democratic and economic system is socialist.

We cannot live with Indian. Today's generation will not allow to do that. South Asia cannot unite again unless there is some powerful policies giving all rights to the citizens.

The partition for British was necessary. The put the hate towards each other in both majors groups i.e. Muslims and Hindus so one of them demand for separate state. Muslim did demand and they got it. Now South Asia became divided and kept fighting each other all these years. Now, west has controlled Pakistan first and now it is India's turn.
 
You are insulting your classical language and signature by learning non-classical Germanic-French cocktail English. Go learn some Greek and speak in Greek only with white people and boycott English if you respect your classical language. :laughcry:

are u from bimaru state? cause you dont make any sense ...
 
yes we do think differently. i want so much to compare india to european union, but even europeans are more similar to each other than indians, and they are a continent. the biggest divide in india is the dravidian/indo aryan languages, which have 100% separate histories and cultures and origins (european languages are similar). then you take the fact that europeans actually have a common religion, christianity, whereas indians have many religions with different heritages. also account for the fact that europeans are all one race, whereas indian race varies from indo aryan in north to mongoloid in NE and then dravidian mediteranean down south (haplogroups/charts/etc) and then an ASI component throughout

overall it is too complicated. if india were more like europe i could understand. when a british person goes to africa, he says "i am european" and is still prideful... but indians are literally different in every single way so i don't think i could be like that.

Great, now tell me how many South Indians care about your Aryan-Dravidan bullcrap. :girl_wacko:
 
this thread is from an idea of @Ravi Nair and from further discussion with @FaujHistorian... though the presented region is south asia, the solution can be for every place humanity lives... presently and in future...

there was one urgent need for the british ensuring division of india in 1947... to have buffer states for countering the influence of communism/socialism in the southern hemisphere... if you look at the world map, and imagine that map in 1945... you will see presence of communism to the north of india ( china, soviet union )... to the west of india ( iran, afghanistan, west asia )... to the east of india ( present day indonesia and malaysia ).

tariq ali's book, "street fighting years", speaks of the massacre of indonesian communists in the 1960's.

the indian communist party was started in 1921 and had good influence... there were famous socialists, among them iqbal and bhagat singh... the western bloc after 1945 feared that if they didn't do something fast, south asia would become another domain of socialism... hence the partition, arranged by the british, encouraged hiddenly by usa... and their further meddling in afghanistan and iran... division of the land east of afghanistan into india and pakistan has only made south asians use nationalism as cover for their inherent biases and wrong cultures.

but speaking of the present... i see the problem called south asia to be among the top-five most problematic issues in the world... and ravi's post reminded me of muammar gaddafi's solution to kashmir... south asia, the continuous land-mass from afghanistan to bangladesh can be divided into administrative zones and the division must not be based on present lines ( culture and language )... the governance must be based on socialism ( jamahiri... i will explain jamahiriya in another thread )... the official language must be english in each zone, plus the cultural language must be hindi ( in present times, hindi is essentially urdu )... no other language must be permitted... no village must be permitted... every habitation must be a city... all weapons presently with national militaries must be confiscated.. those militaries converted into police force, of course with machine guns and armored personnel carriers ( like brdm 2 ) and helicopters ( like ka-50 ).

the above kind of division among humanity is the necessary future... the solution is as simple as people reading, talking with others over tea, accepting... the solution becomes impossible to achieve if people continue their unnecessary hatreds and nationalism...

@Ravi Nair @FaujHistorian @Spring Onion @Imran Khan @hinduguy @KingMamba @genmirajborgza786 @jbgt90 and everyone other south asian.

@Syrian Lion @Mahmoud_EGY @Ceylal @senheiser @Peter C @vostok @Götterdämmerung and all other peoples can also contribute.



No, Thanks.


No, why should we even consider that? Most of the Indians are happy with Partition.
 
are u from bimaru state? cause you dont make any sense ...

That's not an issue here, now come to the point, speakers of classical language should only learn a classical language like Greek, I heard even Mandarin is a classical language. Boycott English. :buba_phone::feminist::dirol:
 
Mate maybe you are not fully aware but many of south indian and Bangla as well as Afghan people have assimilated Hindi as well. I have met many of them personally. Thank you. Even my best friend is A malyali only.
Hindi is not widely understood in Kerala..But sizeable younger generation speaks/understand hindi..mainly due to Bollywood influence..
 
Hindi is not widely understood in Kerala..But sizeable younger generation speaks/understand hindi..mainly due to Bollywood influence..

I heard most of the Malayalis study in CBSE schools in the gulf.
 
A confederation between "India-Pak-BD" is the way to go

ANP socialist minister of Pakistan Ghulam Ahmed Bilour ,had suggested this , & I support it

Bilour proposes confederation with India
A confederation between India, Bangladesh, Nepal and Bhutan is indeed possible at a later stage of our development - both social and economic.
The reason is that on average, Bangladeshis are rational people, they are not the Islamist variety, jihad loving, 'kafir' hating kinds.

With Pakistan, a confederation only means suicide for the rest of the group.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom