What's new

Erecting a monument to Jinnah in Bangladesh

why not erecting the monument of Mahatma Gandhi in Pakistan as he is the real force behind the AAZADI of Indian sub-continent.
What are your view to this mr. thread starter.
I would certainly like to know.

First of all there is no such thing as Indian Subcontinent, either it is South Asia, Subcontinent or Indo-Pak.

Secondly it was not only Gandhi, there were several figures of Pakistan who fought bravely & that include the Great Jinnah, Allama Iqbal, Sir Sayyed, Aga Khan.
 
Bangladesh wouldn't exist in the first place without Jinnah.

Hell, that piece of land, whatever you want to call it, wouldn't exist without him.
 
Lest face it, Jinnah was the pioneer of muslims freedom and identity in the Indian subcontinents and without Jinnah efforts back in 1947, there would be no Bangladesh today. While the Banglis haste to shamelessly erect a monument to Indra, whose actions indirectly led to massacare of thousands of Banglis however they have some explaning to do in regards with Jinnah.

I am looking for some rational arguments in this regards. Because if they refuse to recognise Jinnah, then Pakistan should rightfully invoice them for all expenses, investments and war losses incurred from 14-Aug 1947 uptil December 1971.
Bro, it is impossible. Let me tell you why!

Bangladeshis do not support pakistan in open. Because you will be called as Rajakar by awamileague supporters. It is applicable from supporting Pakistani cricket team to drinking pakistani sezan juice... They ( specially bd hindu) will rename you rajakar if you do anything that favors Pakistan. this is why people keep their brotherhood affection secret. And is only discussed within house, friend circle and internet.
moreover, we, post independent generation have been taught nothing about his role in 1947. He is considered villain because of his speech ' urdu and urdu only will be the state language of Pakistan ''
 
BTW thread is useless & must be closed, there is no monument of Jinnah or Allama Iqbal in Pakistan than why we ask a totally different country to build it?
 
Bangladesh wouldn't exist in the first place without Jinnah.

Hell, that piece of land, whatever you want to call it, wouldn't exist without him.

Jinnah is the grand father of Bangladesh and Sheik Mujib is the father of Bangladesh .
 
Let the bangladeshis erect a monument of whomever they want and makes them happy. Its nothing to do with indians or us
 
From my knowledge, isn't building statues of people haram in Islam?

I don't think it's allowed in my country. Never seen a statue of any of our past great leaders here.

Edit : Oh monument, not statue. My bad.
 
From my knowledge, isn't building statues of people haram in Islam?

I don't think it's allowed in my country. Never seen a statue of any of our past great leaders here.

Edit : Oh monument, not statue. My bad.

bangladesh is not islamic republic. There are many statues here and there.. Although recently a statue was damaged by people. Then, govt. erected a statue /monument of Quran there.
 
Well its just that the ppl of bengal should realize that whatever their griefs were with West Pakistan it shouldn't affect the truth that in the absence of a capable leader as Jinnah we both would have been under occupation.
 
Well its just that the ppl of bengal should realize that whatever their griefs were with West Pakistan it shouldn't affect the truth that in the absence of a capable leader as Jinnah we both would have been under occupation.

Thats a fair point but its up to the bangaladeshis. Its not for us to tell them who or what they should erect
 
Lest face it, Jinnah was the pioneer of muslims freedom and identity in the Indian subcontinents and without Jinnah efforts back in 1947, there would be no Bangladesh today. While the Banglis haste to shamelessly erect a monument to Indra, whose actions indirectly led to massacare of thousands of Banglis however they have some explaning to do in regards with Jinnah.

I am looking for some rational arguments in this regards. Because if they refuse to recognise Jinnah, then Pakistan should rightfully invoice them for all expenses, investments and war losses incurred from 14-Aug 1947 uptil December 1971.




how dare u call us shameless, u the most miserable , ****** creature of the earth . massacre, atrocities all the inhuman activities are part of ur pathetic culture. we showed ur originality and made u bow before us in 71, remember it cowards. u call urself muslims, i spit on u people who r debasing such a great religion. when u raped our women , murdered unarmed ppl of same religion , then where was brotherhood. u r cursed ppl anyhow, though I don't know how, but the outcome shows. be well soon or u will have nothing left but badgering.

we love Indira Gandhi, we respect mahatma Gandhi and we will do, cause we r real muslims, and we don't say wrong about our friends who not only saved us but also feed our 1 corore ppl during that crucial stage.

our great, great, magnanimous, benign prophet the Mohammad told us for being merciful, helpful to helpless and be sorry for any wrongdoing ,and u the businessmen in the name of Islam , despite his command doing the same thing repetitiously. may the great Almighty ALLAH forgive u.


do u think that we will join ur suicide mission anytime , whenever u call us in the name of Islam. ohh ... try us. many illiterate freaks joined u, no doubt, obviously beyond their consent .

it was told , no one but the Muslims themselves will destroy each other. and I believe u r the forerunner. other ways and means can b found in lieu of outrageous animosity.

last of all, jinnah is responsible for all the misgivings and tearing the nation apart. what he has got after severing a country, a nation, nothing but a obstinately stubborn and worthless nation, that will soon prove themselves as an unsuccessful in UN.
 
how dare u call us shameless, u the most miserable , ****** creature of the earth . massacre, atrocities all the inhuman activities are part of ur pathetic culture. we showed ur originality and made u bow before us in 71, remember it cowards. u call urself muslims, i spit on u people who r debasing such a great religion. when u raped our women , murdered unarmed ppl of same religion , then where was brotherhood. u r cursed ppl anyhow, though I don't know how, but the outcome shows. be well soon or u will have nothing left but badgering.

we love Indira Gandhi, we respect mahatma Gandhi and we will do, cause we r real muslims, and we don't say wrong about our friends who not only saved us but also feed our 1 corore ppl during that crucial stage.

our great, great, magnanimous, benign prophet the Mohammad told us for being merciful, helpful to helpless and be sorry for any wrongdoing ,and u the businessmen in the name of Islam , despite his command doing the same thing repetitiously. may the great Almighty ALLAH forgive u.


do u think that we will join ur suicide mission anytime , whenever u call us in the name of Islam. ohh ... try us. many illiterate freaks joined u, no doubt, obviously beyond their consent .

it was told , no one but the Muslims themselves will destroy each other. and I believe u r the forerunner. other ways and means can b found in lieu of outrageous animosity.

last of all, jinnah is responsible for all the misgivings and tearing the nation apart. what he has got after severing a country, a nation, nothing but a obstinately stubborn and worthless nation, that will soon prove themselves as an unsuccessful in UN.

Are you really bengali? Most bengalis I come accross dont have this type of views
 
@ Pakistanis

It seems you abandon us. Well there are two types of Bangladeshis, one anti-PK and another is pro-pk. So you can take a half chance here for sure.

Best of luck.

@ Bangladeshis

I think the major problem if you say you like Pk, now, is Pk's current terrorism problem. Now they will say you that "you are supporting a failed state, they are extremist" instead of "Razakar". And really you will not get anything to say that "no, Pk is ok".

Otherwise, suppose there is not killing in Pk, there is nothing wrong to say openly that you like PK bros. If they tell you Razakar then tell them Dalal of India, lol.
 
Are you really bengali? Most bengalis I come accross dont have this type of views

He is hardcore league supporter who brought up reading anti Pakistani books and story based on atrocity in 1971 . And thinking only that before independence we had nothing we had every thing in 1947 and would have earn many thing if we are with India .
 

Back
Top Bottom