Complete ban on Israeli users

[masterchief_mirza]

Israel - then Indians - then perhaps Iranians - then Americans - why not Bengalis?

then articles will be going up that all agree upon - never a debate - just always agree and have the same mindset?
Dear o dear - learn educate and debate put them in their place - show them your opinion and debate. If not you are going to be left with a lifeless forum.

 

[Musings]

This only work if the opposing side is educated and not troll. We have plenty of Pakistani users that offer opposing views. We don't need indian sitting in Delhi telling us about internal politics of Pakistan, like wheat crisis or corrupt judges.

Ye well that’s why we have mods - Not bigging the mods up but I’ve in my short stay seen immediate action on trolling - why not let them come on - debate and embarrass them by making look like twats. Taken me a bit of time and now for example I know twaty Indians and respond accordingly- banning them outright would mean you lose some that actually want to debate - are you telling me we aren’t good enough to debate and give them responses with interest? Would become a boring place if there’s was just like minded people

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Ye well that’s why we have mods - Not bigging the mods up but I’ve in my short stay seen immediate action on trolling - why not let them come on - debate and embarrass them by making look like twats. Taken me a bit of time and now for example I know twaty Indians and respond accordingly- banning them outright would mean you lose some that actually want to debate - are you telling me we aren’t good enough to debate and give them responses with interest? Would become a boring place if there’s was just like minded people

Plenty of good reasons to keep your enemies closer than your friends etc etc.

 

[Aspen]

Plenty of good reasons to keep your enemies closer than your friends etc etc.

If you find even one useful post from an Israeli on this site, I will eat my words. Good luck

 

[Falcon29]

Yes, there are quite a few

That's the point , they are a few people and don't post much. I don't see a reason to ban people on an international forum.

 

[TNT]

I initially agreed but now i think no one should be fully banned based on nationality or religion or sect.

 

[Salman876]

Israel is Teacher of our Only Enemy. They are relevant.

 

[Aspen]

That's the point , they are a few people and don't post much. I don't see a reason to ban people on an international forum.

It's not about how many there are but what they post

Israel is Teacher of our Only Enemy. They are relevant.

Exactly. Snakes think alike

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

I think we should ban any member who supports oppression or genocide against Palestinians or Kashmiris.

It should be an immediate ban.

This would probably result in bans for every Indian member, but that should be our red line.

This only work if the opposing side is educated and not troll. We have plenty of Pakistani users that offer opposing views. We don't need indian sitting in Delhi telling us about internal politics of Pakistan, like wheat crisis or corrupt judges.

This is a very important point here. Some of the Pakistani members are not much different than Indians, esp some of the ultra liberals, ethnix supremacists, and agnostic/atheist (not you bro @AgNoStiC MuSliM .)

 

[Aspen]

I think we should ban any member who supports oppression or genocide against Palestinians or Kashmiris.

It should be an immediate ban.

This would probably result in bans for every Indian member, but that should be our red line.

This is a very important point here. Some of the Pakistani members are not much different than Indians, esp some of the ultra liberals, ethnix supremacists, and agnostic/atheist (not you bro @AgNoStiC MuSliM .)

Fully agree

 

[Pakistani E]

Do some people think of anything else beyond banning/shutting out people who have a different background/opinion/view? I commend the admins of this forum for having a relatively free and open environment. Hope it continues.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

For members interested in the views on Israel of Pakistani members, they can be found here. Some of the views were surprising.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/why-...y-themselves-support-india-against-us.668228/

 

[MastanKhan]

I have no idea why Israelis were even allowed onto this site in the first place.

Every Israeli on PDF should be banned permanently, not one of them has ever contributed anything useful on this site.

Hi,

You have a moderator over here who is an ashkenazi jew and you are crying over israeli jews---.

 

[Mugwop]

Outrageous demand! Most israeli posters who joined this forum had discussions on military hardware only.
They didn't care much about our rivalry with india and stayed outta it.

 

[Genghis khan1]

It’s an online forum. Unless someone is spreading Spam or have a pattern of creating rubbish / propaganda Thread. No one should be banned.