Sever ties with India, Pakistan tells Afghanistan

[INDIC]

We also have Kababs all over Pakistan, does that make us all Iranians? We have Burgers, Pizzas does that mean we share culture with westerns?


You can't differentiate between UP & Punjab and discussing culture here?

Punjabis in Pakistan has shifted to culture of UP. Your national language is also from UP. So, how you claim you have nothing common with UP.

 

[Areesh]

What is it stupid day or are your generally this obtuse ??
A nation is defined by its people ..passage of crown does not redefine a country..British crown passed on from Romans to Saxons to Normans like a hockey puck ..does it mean Britain ceased to Britain became different nation every time crown changed hands?

Going by your stupid definition every country in this world including Pakistan existed for centuries and has a history of thousand years behind them. The name doesn't even matter. People used to live in these territories for centuries just like India. But the truth is that even modern Britain is way different from the Britain of 1900. You can't say Modern Britain and the Britain under the rule of Normans are the same. It is completely stupid.

If we stick to your logic ..then you should say modern Pakistan came into existence on 16 Dec 1971.. as both geographical and physical identity of 'united' Pakistan changed that day and two new nations came into being with completely different maps.

For the nth time. Modern Pakistan came into existence on 14 August 1947 when it gained freedom from British India. On 16 December it just lost a portion of its territory. Doesn't change the fact that present Pakistan used to exist even before that and Islamabad was the capital even before 16 December 1971.

Well India has existed for centuries

Yeah right. And so does every other country in this world in one way or the other.

it was medieval India and before that ancient India..but those are just time periods.

Before that it was British India and Mughal India and Hindu India and Buddhist India. Not the modern India.

India is not just a nation state, it is a civilization, which has existed and grown by absorbing and absolving different many other civilizations.

Again. Applies to every other country in one way or the other. Doesn't change the fact that modern India came into existence on 15 August 1947.

It is understandable why this idea make you crib like an insecure little girl.

We are actually laughing that how stupid you are.

The idea your "hamsaya" is centuries old civilizations can be frightening ,

The idea that our hamsaya is delusional and is facing issues of self praise is even more frightening. Such type of people are dangerous after all.

when you realize your own nation was merely an afterthought, created just because two politician could not share power,

Well that's what you think. If you think so, go abuse Nehru for it. We don't believe in this.

is also perhaps one the reason many Pakistanis try to associate with Arab civilization.

The whole Muslim world is related to Arab civilization because of the religion thing. Anyways this is a separate debate.

in 1947 born "Republic of India" not "India"

India existed thousands of years before birth of Islam and their "Allah"

And Japan existed even before the planet earth existed.

Oops that is as false as the notion that modern India existed for thousands of years.

 

[Sugarcane]

Punjabis in Pakistan has shifted to culture of UP. Your national language is also from UP. So, how you claim you have nothing common with UP.

LOL!!! In Pakistan we are being blamed that we have done Punjabization in everything and you are saying we shifted to UP culture

in 1947 born "Republic of India" not "India"

India existed thousands of years before birth of Islam and their "Allah"

And we took land from mars and imported people from moon and created country "Pakistan" on 14th Aug 1947

 

[INDIC]

LOL!!! In Pakistan we are being blamed that we have done Punjabization in everything and you are saying we shifted to UP culture

Punjabization is in economic term in cultural term its Urdufication. Lots of Punjabis want to speak Urdu like Urdu of Awadh. I even saw Pakistani singers singing the song in Brajbhasha mixed Urdu.

 

[Sugarcane]

Punjabization is in economic term in cultural term its Urdufication. Lots of Punjabis want to speak Urdu like Urdu of Awadh. I even saw Pakistani singers singing the song in Brajbhasha mixed Urdu.

You have to learn more about Pakistan

 

[Argus Panoptes]

It's thinking like this that keeps Pakistanis cowed and enslaved rather than free. It took the Russians forty years to break out of such deluded paranoid thinking. Where are the Pakistanis willing to put down the Argus Panopteses in their midst?

There is nothing wrong with my thinking. Imagine yourself as a American, with a military alliance between Canada and Mexico and the Caribbean States, and then tell me you wouldn't feel encircled with Mexico claiming back its territories including Texas, California, New Mexico and few other States. Remember how you guys went nearly ballistic in 1962 fearing the USSR was moving in to close? Same thing here.

 

[Solomon2]

There is nothing wrong with my thinking. Imagine yourself as a American, with a military alliance between Canada and Mexico and the Caribbean States -

More accurate analogy would be to imagine myself an American who insists that Mexico can't have a Canadian Embassy and all the officers of its military and police must serve at the pleasure of the United States government.

An "alliance" between Afghanistan and India? Pakistan might push them into one, yes, but they'd hardly be interested if Pakistan was more interested in making peace with its neighbors rather than dominating or conquering them, yes?

 

[RazPaK]

Punjabis in Pakistan has shifted to culture of UP. Your national language is also from UP. So, how you claim you have nothing common with UP.

Lmao.

We real Punjabis consider Lahore as commercialized Punjabis and even they are more Punjabi than Indian Punjab.


Perhaps it is time to broaden your horizons before making face palm type generalizations.

 

[SamantK]

Many Pakistanis accuse us of bullying countries in our neighborhood, then they justify bullying Afghanistan for national interest, against India. Why these double standards?

Pakistanis are doing what they feel is the best way, correct or otherwise only time will tell. If one looks at the history of Pakistan and Afghanistan, the former's plans have always backfired cause they wanted a more than normal influence in the latter.

For India it will be good if it backfires again even otherwise keeping Pakistan busy on its western border will not be very difficult even post 2014 withdrawal..

 

[RazPaK]

Many Pakistanis accuse us of bullying countries in our neighborhood, then they justify bullying Afghanistan for national interest, against India. Why these double standards?

Pakistanis are doing what they feel is the best way, correct or otherwise only time will tell. If one looks at the history of Pakistan and Afghanistan, the former's plans have always backfired cause they wanted a more than normal influence in the latter.

For India it will be good if it backfires again even otherwise keeping Pakistan busy on its western border will not be very difficult even post 2014 withdrawal..

Looks like you haven't studied Pak-Afghan history enough.

Stop with the hot air and research more.

 

[SamantK]

Lmao.
[/B]
We real Punjabis consider Lahore as commercialized Punjabis and even they are more Punjabi than Indian Punjab.[/B]


Perhaps it is time to broaden your horizons before making face palm type generalizations.

His statement seems inacurrate but can you explain the bolded part about how you are a real Punjabi and more Punjabi than Indian Punjab? Who gave this certificate?

 

[SamantK]

Looks like you haven't studied Pak-Afghan history enough.

Stop with the hot air and research more.

Don't pass these one liners you are famous for, either refute my statements case by case or let it go.

 

[RazPaK]

In Maula Jatt I saw real Punjabis wearing Lungi-Kurta instead of Shalwar Kameez.

So you are basing your historical deductions on a film?

Punjabis wear shalwar kamiz, ya shalwar chador aur dhoti.


Instead of those films have a look at this and gain some knowledge.

 

[KingMamba]

Many Pakistanis accuse us of bullying countries in our neighborhood, then they justify bullying Afghanistan for national interest, against India. Why these double standards?

Pakistanis are doing what they feel is the best way, correct or otherwise only time will tell. If one looks at the history of Pakistan and Afghanistan, the former's plans have always backfired cause they wanted a more than normal influence in the latter.

For India it will be good if it backfires again even otherwise keeping Pakistan busy on its western border will not be very difficult even post 2014 withdrawal..

No Pakistani thinks India is a bully, a bully can actually inflict damage on those weaker than it. India despite being stronger than Pakistan cannot do sht ergo India is not a bully. India is a punk that needs to stop killing innocent kashmiris.

 

[W.11]

Your passport changed in 1971 with the removal of Bengali language.

lol what a pathetic reason, you are s dumb as elephant