Wombs available for surrogacy in India - ethical issues

[acetophenol]

Mentality of medieval ages? hmm... than why is this not happening in other countries? ............. these women are not doing it for humanity...... rather the money$$................

we all know that you are really trying hard to bash india.
and good luck for you.

i do accept that my country is becoming a hub for surrogate mothers,mostly due to their financial situation.
but i am proud of them because rather than going for shameless activities like prostitution,they have chose to pick up a noble option.
becoming a surrogate mother,even if its for a money,is a noble option as it gives life to the dreams of a couple.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Some more education for you. It is common all over the world.

The Spin Doctor | Burgeoning Surrogacy Industry In China Raising Legal & Moral Issues - The Spin Doctor

China Grapples with Legality of Surrogate Motherhood -- china.org.cn

Its a flourishing business in india... infact india is the hub of surrogate pregnancy ... making hundreds of millions of $$ while on a small account in china.. where they r considering to ban it... coz its immoral?

Get it???

 

[ashokdeiva]

Selling a part of ur body.... its like prostitution.... u get paid... u deliver...

The guy is not even from Medival Age, but Stone age... where science and people psycology has grown and we see people who think otherwise. Don't you think before you write.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Think of it this way, your family's bread winner has passed away or is a drunk abuser,
your mom has to find a way to feed the family and child , unable to make ends meet with occupation like labour.
She"ll have finally 2 choices
1.Prostitution
2.this thing you call shameful

What would you want her to do?

Besides in nations like Pakistan and India where infant and maternal mortality rates are high ,surrogacy can be of help as it enables a women to better understand the precautions to take during pregnancy,

Thts cool... but dont u think its immoral? what about impregnation?

But i guess... its immoral to us...coz ........... Its not allowed in our religion.

 

[ashokdeiva]

Thts cool... but dont u think its immoral? what about impregnation?

But i guess... its immoral to us...coz ........... Its not allowed in our religion.

Do not bring in Religion here, if one day its found that all men are losing their potentiality due to some virus and them will you still say that your Religion says only natural sex to give birth. if that is your argument there wont be a Muslim to uphold its principles

 

[acetophenol]

sef-delete

 

[justanobserver]

But i guess... its immoral to us...coz ........... Its not allowed in our religion.

And this was your intention from the start of the thread.

Yes, the land of the pure is morally superior. Thank you come again.

 

[Perceptron]

Do they do it for the money? like these indian women? is america the hub of commercial surrogate pregnancy? Heck no!

Do you think that many of them do it for free ? As a utopian idealist ? You can read this link and answer that query for yourself. Regarding your 2nd question, there is no single global hub of surrogacy, it happens all over the world, in Israel, China, in United States etc. What is more bothering and shameful more than the surrogacy is the maternal mortality rate in Pakistan, which shows how bothered is the GoP to improve basic healthcare there.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

And this was your intention from the start of the thread.

Yes, the land of the pure is morally superior. Thank you come again.

Whats ur intention when u open threads abt Pakistan?

Dont shoot the messenger dude... lets discuss not throw cheap shots(typical of u guys).


@ace yes it is.

 

[acetophenol]

Thts cool... but dont u think its immoral? what about impregnation?

But i guess... its immoral to us...coz ........... Its not allowed in our religion.

in islam,artificial insemination is haram too.

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

Thts cool... but dont u think its immoral? what about impregnation?

But i guess... its immoral to us...coz ........... Its not allowed in our religion.

there is no impregnation here , the embryo or zygote is merely inserted into the womb of woman who can conceive a child, not the man's sperm.

From an ethical perspective it has its own set of pro and anti arguments , but surrogacy as an alternative to prostitution i support it.

 

[Dalai Lama]

Dont shoot the messenger dude... lets discuss not throw cheap shots (typical of u guys).

Practice what you preach dude!

 

[IndoCarib]

Its a flourishing business in india... infact india is the hub of surrogate pregnancy ... making hundreds of millions of $$ while on a small account in china.. where they r considering to ban it... coz its immoral?

Get it???

So it is immoral because we are making millions ? Whats wrong in getting paid for a service ? Agreed there are moral and ethical issued, but comparing it to prostitution is preposterous. Although China has banned it , it is still popular with some couples

Baby boom for surrogate mothers despite ban

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Do you think that many of them do it for free ? As a utopian idealist ? You can read this link and answer that query for yourself. Regarding your 2nd question, there is no single global hub of surrogacy, it happens all over the world, in Israel, China, in United States etc.

The thing is ur country is a hub n its considered OK.. unlike the countries ur talkin abt... in the link it raises the question.. for $ or love!? in china its considered bad n not widely practised... in israel its regulated with very strict laws only considered in extreme cases..
Legal regulation of surrogate motherhood in Israel. [Med Law. 2001] - PubMed result

What is more bothering and shameful more than the surrogacy is the maternal mortality rate in Pakistan, which shows how bothered is the GoP to improve basic healthcare there.

U know whats more shameful? trolling in a thread tht doesnt have anything to do with Pakistan....... Anyways do u know the mortality rate in india? and tht the indian govt HIDES the real rate n uses FAKE figures? Probably not... so lets keep it clean...

 

[IndoCarib]

there is no impregnation here , the embryo or zygote is merely inserted into the womb of woman who can conceive a child, not the man's sperm.

From an ethical perspective it has its own set of pro and anti arguments , but surrogacy as an alternative to prostitution i support it.

He doesn't know the technology involved ! So he thought it is prostitution ! Some people are still in caves !

Some more education for Pakistan nationalist

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Surrogate+Motherhood