What's new

Woman, daughter publicly tortured in Muzaffargarh

we can forget the people but what abt police many times police also don't take any action only because they think it's a wastage of time and afford.

That problems in many south asian countries, bangladesh, pakistan and india , due to poverty and corruption, if teh culprit is froma wealthy well connected family, th epoor poilce officer would get insulted abused and maybe out of a job
 
.
we can forget the people but what abt police many times police also don't take any action only because they think it's a wastage of time and afford.

what is your assessment or view in this regard ?? i mean why police do so ?

Such incidents as i had said happened in Subcontinent (India, Pakistan both) in the past too. so what is the solution viz a viz role of society ??
 
.
I do not know if I should comment as this is an internal matter of Pakistan, but unfortunately this is a sign of social insensitivity creeping into the society, especially the subcontinent.

The onlookers stand there and watch everything going on as if it is a puppet show. Nobody ever think that today it is someone else's mother, daughter, wife who is being tortured, but tomorrow it could be his/her mother, wife or daughter. People have lost empathy towards others' suffering. Subcontinent was not like this. We were poor, but never uncivilized and barbaric to this degree.

The reasons for this downfall in social moral character and self-centric behavior are getting quite clear, but no use of discussing these here.:undecided:
 
.
That problems in many south asian countries, bangladesh, pakistan and india , due to poverty and corruption, if teh culprit is froma wealthy well connected family, th epoor poilce officer would get insulted abused and maybe out of a job

yes it's a huge fault of system...
 
.
I do not know if I should comment as this is an internal matter of Pakistan, but unfortunately this is a sign of social insensitivity creeping into the society, especially the subcontinent.

The onlookers stand there and watch everything going on as if it is a puppet show. Nobody ever think that today it is someone else's mother, daughter, wife who is being tortured, but tomorrow it could be his/her mother, wife or daughter. People have lost empathy towards others' suffering. Subcontinent was not like this. We were poor, but never uncivilized and barbaric to this degree.

The reasons for this downfall in social moral character and self-centric behavior are getting quite clear, but no use of discussing these here.:undecided:



You can very well comment on it because its not an internal issue rather a social issue which is common in almost all regional countries.
 
.
what is your assessment or view in this regard ?? i mean why police do so ?

Such incidents as i had said happened in Subcontinent (India, Pakistan both) in the past too. so what is the solution viz a viz role of society ??

India , Pakistan and Bangladesh share practically the same social regards for the rights of women. Womens rights is basic window dressing in the form of appointing one or two top politicians including PMs etc to the nation but plain disregard for the rights of women on the ground. These nations should engage in a full spectrum of womens rights including domestic violence interdicts which are simple to obtain and empower or places a duty on a police officer to arrest an offender in a domestic violence situation. Crimes such as rape and molestation must be made priority crimes. They must be quickly investigated and quickly decided in a court. School education must emphasise the rights of women as being non negotiable. Here in Africa there is a motto which is taught in schools that "if you strike a woman then you strike at the soil of your nation". South Asia needs to quickly move up to international norm and take a no nonsense approach towards women and childrens rights.
 
.
Women stripped for retribution
July 05, 2010

In yet another act of brutal violence against women, a 50-year-old woman was stripped in public and her 12-year-old daughter was beaten in Moza Bair Band, a little village near Sultan city on Sunday, in a bid to settle a family feud. Such incidents of violence on women seem to be on the increase, say observers, who add that the police usually side with the culprits as seems to be the case in this incident.

So far the police had been unhelpful to the victims. What is worse is that only two members of the gang that assaulted the women have been apprehended till now, because police have allegedly succumbed to political pressure.

The incident occurred early on Sunday morning, when a group of 14 men led by locals Safdar and Mirza approached Allah Wasai and her young daughter Ashraf Mai as they were working in their fields, witnesses said.

They were seeking to take revenge on Allah Wasai’s family because her son, Saddam, allegedly had illicit relations with Safdar’s young daughter, Fatima.

Safdar and Mirza and their accomplices captured the mother and the daughter at around 9 am and stripped the mother naked, beating both relentlessly.

During the fray, Allah Wasai’s daughter managed to escape and ran away from the scene, begging passersby to help her mother who, she said, was being beaten to death.

According to locals, Allah Wasai was beaten continuously for three hours in front of a large group of onlookers who did nothing to help the woman. “This is torture,” said a local resident, visibly shaken. “About 100 people were gathered around, watching as the woman was stripped and beaten. I came forward and said, ‘Give her some clothes, for God’s sake’.”

When the police were finally summoned to the scene they took Allah Wasai and her daughter to the local police station and then dropped them off to the hospital, said Altaf, the officer in charge of the investigation. A medical examination has not yet been conducted.

When asked whether the police had ensured that the women were given a proper medical examination, he retorted that it was not the police officer’s job to guarantee that a check up had taken place. Altaf refused to answer further questions.

Locals said they do not have any faith in the police or in the doctor who took Allah Wasai into his care, as they alleged that both the police and the doctor had been bribed by local influential people.

The police at Sultan police station have registered a case under section 354 of the penal code, but the victims maintain that the police have not registered the case under clauses that correspond to the crimes the gang committed.

Ghulam Mustafa, Allah Wasai’s husband, appealed to the authorities to take action on his wife’s case.

“No action has been taken against my wife’s attackers. There is a lot of political pressure on the people here,” he said. Near tears, Mustafa added that he had spent a lot of time at the hospital in Sultan city and at the police station, but could not get the police to mobilise their forces in any effective manner. “The people involved are land owners,” Mustafa said. “They have a lot of political backing. We are poor people, we can’t do anything.”

After the assault began receiving more attention in the public the police did manage to apprehend two suspects Akbar and Jamil. The rest of the attackers, included the alleged instigators Safdar and Mirza, are still at large.

This incident comes just a week after a report by the Aurat Foundation on violence against women was released, which stated that crimes against women had increased by 13 per cent in 2009. The most crimes against women were reported to have taken place in the Punjab, said the report.

Umme-Laila Azhar of the Aurat Foundation condemned the incident and confirmed that violent incidents of a similar nature seemed to be increasing rather than decreasing.

She linked crimes against women to several factors including poverty. According to Azhar, the general population is growing increasingly frustrated at their worsening economic condition and men are taken their anger out on women, who are treated as commodities.

She also blamed lax media regulation policies for the upward trend in crime. “The media widens the distance between the haves and the have-nots,” she said. She said no policies had been implemented to make the media more sensitive so as not to create resentment between different segments of society.

Commenting on the frequent use of women as tools to gain retribution, she said: “This is a feudal mindset.” She said education could help end this practice, and conceded that in the interim, ‘influential’ people will still have the power to influence the police and other authorities.

Meanwhile the victim’s family, who have appealed to the Chief Minister of Punjab to ensure that the perpetrators are brought to justice, wants speedy action on the case.

“I appeal to you, I appeal to everyone…” said Mustafa. “How can anybody allow such atrocities to take place?”

Published in The Express Tribune, July 5th, 2010.


Woman and daughter stripped, thrashed
By Malik Tahseen Raza
Monday, 05 Jul, 2010

MUZAFFARGARH: Fourteen people are reported to have stripped naked a woman and her daughter on Saturday and thrashed them in the presence of a large number of people in Shehr Sultan, a town near Mirwala.

Sources said the suspects got hold of 50-year-old Allah Wasai and her 14-year-old daughter Ashraf Mai when they came out of their home in Berwali to go to their fields.

They then proceeded to teach the women “a lesson for the wrongdoing of Allah Wasai’s son”.

SHO Mahboob Tangwani said the main accused, Safdar, alleged that Allah Wasai’s son Saddam Husain had an affair with his daughter. He and his 13 accomplices held the woman and her daughter at gunpoint, stripped them naked and thrashed them.

A large number of people were there but none of them came forward to rescue the women from the assailants.

Local resident Allah Ditta later informed police.

A police team freed the women from the accused and gave them clothes.

A case was registered against the 14 accused, including Safdar, Mirza Khan, Siraj, Haji Afzal, Jameel, Akbar and Athar under 354/148 and 149 sections of the Pakistan Penal Code. Akbar and Jameel have been arrested.

According to police, the accused justified their action and said that a dispute over distribution of irrigation water had caused a clash in which people from both sides were injured.
 
.
I will expect the usual remarks of how the police are corrupt and how the culprits managed to get away with political interference, clearly side stepping the fact that a large crowd watched a woman and a girl beat up and thrashed.

What a public. Shame on our populace that watches woman get stripped and tortured and that too in public.
 
.
Wait wait wait. Your telling me 100 people watched a women get stripped and beaten for 3 damn hours ?

And it was caused over a water dispute ?

:disagree::hitwall:

Blows my mind. :blink:
 
.
I'm suprised no one had the balls to come up to those women beaters and ring their bells in the worst possible way imaginable.
 
.
Wait wait wait. Your telling me 100 people watched a women get stripped and beaten for 3 damn hours ?

And it was caused over a water dispute ?

:disagree::hitwall:

Blows my mind. :blink:

not water dispute, the woman's son had an affair with someone who was related to the attackers.
 
.
Shame, Those 14 men should be hang in public! and people should get one lash at least per person for not doing anything beside standing there.
 
.
not water dispute, the woman's son had an affair with someone who was related to the attackers.

According to police, the accused justified their action and said that a dispute over distribution of irrigation water had caused a clash in which people from both sides were injured.

I was referring to this part not that having a affair would make a difference. This is backward stuff man anyway you want to look at it. 100 people did nothing ? Are these people weaklings ?

Again these things are beyond me. I don't have the brain to understand or comprehend such acts. Must be a tribute to my humanity i guess.
 
. . .

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom