Why We Reject Indian Media SSP Mirpur Story?

[Areesh]

Because it is flawed and bogus. And why is it flawed is explained below:

The Indian media reports on Wednesday came up with some Indian journalist who talked to a SSP of AJK police in Mirpur presenting himself as his senior IG Mushtaq. During this conversation SSP Ghulam Akbar of AJK police intelligence branch manged to accept Indian claim of surgical strikes in AJK and also accepted casualties of "terrorists" in it.

There are however a few reasons and facts to deny and reject this "proof" of Indian media.

1. The biggest gap in this whole news report is that there is no IG Mushtaq in AJK police. The name of the IG of AJK police is Bashir Memon.

https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/103134-Bashir-Memon-appointed-AJK-IGP

2. There is however an IG with the name of Mushtaq in Pakistan. This is IG Mushtaq Sukhera who is IG of Punjab Police and not AJK police which is different.

3. IG Mushtaq Sukhera is IG of Punjab Police and hence has no relation with any event happening in AJK. So it obviously makes no sense that some SSP would talk about events happening at LOC to IG punjab who is neither superior to him nor he is answerable to him.

4. IG Mushtaq Sukhera is a Punjabi. Now if an Indian journalist would try to pose as IG Mushtaq Sukhera then it is nearly impossible that a SSP in AJK would fail to recognize him given hindi accent of the Indian journalist.

5. The Indian journalist posing as "IG Mushtaq" kept on using Hindi words like "Barhiya Barhiya" but a senior SSP of AJK police "intelligence" failed to catch his not so Punjabi accent. This looks to be improbable for a senior police officer like SSP.

6. There was however a SSP Ghulam Akbar in AJK police but that was around 5 years ago back in 2011. It is obvious that SSP Ghulam Akbar wouldn't be posted in the same rank and place even after 5 years.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/164250/ajk-postings-reshuffle-in-police-ehtesab-bureau/

7. As said in point 6 the SSP Ghulam Akbar is now posted in Muzaffarabad and not in Mirpur. A local journalist from Peshawar has confirmed that.

https://twitter.com/x/status/783728039813222400

8. So there is no IG Mushtaq in AJK police and no Ghulam Akbar in Mirpur.

Conclusion: I don't think it is difficult to decide with above facts that this "proof" by Indian media for supposed surgical strikes was nothing but a load of crap meant to deceive Indian nation. The purpose of this thread is to present all the facts about this "proof" in one thread so that whenever an Indian member comes up with this "proof" we would have the exact direct link to refute it.

Thank You.

@Tipu7 @Windjammer @Emmie @Bratva @Oscar @coffee_cup @shah1398 @Aviator23 @Mentee @Side-Winder @Zarvan @Major Sam @Dazzler @Arsalan

 

[Kabira]

Its funny Indians are always caught red handed when ever they open the mouth lol

 

[Ghareeb_Da_Baal]

Its funny Indians are always caught red handed when ever they open the mouth lol

or they can prove their story by positively identifying the named person is real . if not, they need to back down from their si ji tomorrow claim. Lets see where we end up!

 

[In arduis fidelis]

Because it is flawed and bogus. And why is it flawed is explained below:

The Indian media reports on Wednesday came up with some Indian journalist who talked to a SSP of AJK police in Mirpur presenting himself as his senior IG Mushtaq. During this conversation SSP Ghulam Akbar of AJK police intelligence branch manged to accept Indian claim of surgical strikes in AJK and also accepted casualties of "terrorists" in it.

There are however a few reasons and facts to deny and reject this "proof" of Indian media.

1. The biggest gap in this whole news report is that there is no IG Mushtaq in AJK police. The name of the IG of AJK police is Bashir Memon.

https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/103134-Bashir-Memon-appointed-AJK-IGP

2. There is however an IG with the name of Mushtaq in Pakistan. This is IG Mushtaq Sukhera who is IG of Punjab Police and not AJK police which is different.

3. IG Mushtaq Sukhera is IG of Punjab Police and hence has no relation with any event happening in AJK. So it obviously makes no sense that some SSP would talk about events happening at LOC to IG punjab who is neither superior to him nor he is answerable to him.

4. IG Mushtaq Sukhera is a Punjabi. Now if an Indian journalist would try to pose as IG Mushtaq Sukhera then it is nearly impossible that a SSP in AJK would fail to recognize him given hindi accent of the Indian journalist.

5. The Indian journalist posing as "IG Mushtaq" kept on using Hindi words like "Barhiya Barhiya" but a senior SSP of AJK police "intelligence" failed to catch his not so Punjabi accent. This looks to be improbable for a senior police officer like SSP.

6. There was however a SSP Ghulam Akbar in AJK police but that was around 5 years ago back in 2011. It is obvious that SSP Ghulam Akbar wouldn't be posted in the same rank and place even after 5 years.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/164250/ajk-postings-reshuffle-in-police-ehtesab-bureau/

7. As said in point 6 the SSP Ghulam Akbar is now posted in Muzaffarabad and not in Mirpur. A local journalist from Peshawar has confirmed that.

https://twitter.com/x/status/783728039813222400

8. So there is no IG Mushtaq in AJK police and no Ghulam Akbar in Mirpur.

Conclusion: I don't think it is difficult to decide with above facts that this "proof" by Indian media for supposed surgical strikes was nothing but a load of crap meant to deceive Indian nation. The purpose of this thread is to present all the facts about this "proof" in one thread so that whenever an Indian member comes up with this "proof" we would have the exact direct link to refute it.

Thank You.

@Tipu7 @Windjammer @Emmie @Bratva @Oscar @coffee_cup @shah1398 @Aviator23 @Mentee @Side-Winder @Zarvan @Major Sam @Dazzler @Arsalan

Icing to the cake add the ary news interview of IG AJK from tonight's news! He destroyed any shred of resemblance to reality this claim had!

Indians are becoming pathological liars and they have the audacity to label us as liars

 

[Pandora]

Indian have taken out the word shameless from their dictionary officially. They present bogus evidence only to get red face infront of entire world.

 

[Thəorətic Muslim]

People need to understand the difference between Yellow Journalism and direct news-conferences given by the Military or Prime Minister or his Office

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Because it is flawed and bogus. And why is it flawed is explained below:

The Indian media reports on Wednesday came up with some Indian journalist who talked to a SSP of AJK police in Mirpur presenting himself as his senior IG Mushtaq. During this conversation SSP Ghulam Akbar of AJK police intelligence branch manged to accept Indian claim of surgical strikes in AJK and also accepted casualties of "terrorists" in it.

There are however a few reasons and facts to deny and reject this "proof" of Indian media.

1. The biggest gap in this whole news report is that there is no IG Mushtaq in AJK police. The name of the IG of AJK police is Bashir Memon.

https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/103134-Bashir-Memon-appointed-AJK-IGP

2. There is however an IG with the name of Mushtaq in Pakistan. This is IG Mushtaq Sukhera who is IG of Punjab Police and not AJK police which is different.

3. IG Mushtaq Sukhera is IG of Punjab Police and hence has no relation with any event happening in AJK. So it obviously makes no sense that some SSP would talk about events happening at LOC to IG punjab who is neither superior to him nor he is answerable to him.

4. IG Mushtaq Sukhera is a Punjabi. Now if an Indian journalist would try to pose as IG Mushtaq Sukhera then it is nearly impossible that a SSP in AJK would fail to recognize him given hindi accent of the Indian journalist.

5. The Indian journalist posing as "IG Mushtaq" kept on using Hindi words like "Barhiya Barhiya" but a senior SSP of AJK police "intelligence" failed to catch his not so Punjabi accent. This looks to be improbable for a senior police officer like SSP.

6. There was however a SSP Ghulam Akbar in AJK police but that was around 5 years ago back in 2011. It is obvious that SSP Ghulam Akbar wouldn't be posted in the same rank and place even after 5 years.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/164250/ajk-postings-reshuffle-in-police-ehtesab-bureau/

7. As said in point 6 the SSP Ghulam Akbar is now posted in Muzaffarabad and not in Mirpur. A local journalist from Peshawar has confirmed that.

https://twitter.com/x/status/783728039813222400

8. So there is no IG Mushtaq in AJK police and no Ghulam Akbar in Mirpur.

Conclusion: I don't think it is difficult to decide with above facts that this "proof" by Indian media for supposed surgical strikes was nothing but a load of crap meant to deceive Indian nation. The purpose of this thread is to present all the facts about this "proof" in one thread so that whenever an Indian member comes up with this "proof" we would have the exact direct link to refute it.

Thank You.

@Tipu7 @Windjammer @Emmie @Bratva @Oscar @coffee_cup @shah1398 @Aviator23 @Mentee @Side-Winder @Zarvan @Major Sam @Dazzler @Arsalan

Don't take it too seriously. It was just the script for a new bollywood blockbuster movie.

 

[In arduis fidelis]

What were they thinking before airing this?Like seriously!Do they have an iota of brain cells left in their thick skulls!!

 

[The Eagle]

Indian Media = everything is possible.

Just connect the recent and a famous attempt. Arnab found Dawood Ibrahim in Karachi and even got the landline number, obtained a fake PTCL bill and made a call as well which ended in humiliation. Then after, referring Pathankot, aArnab and media found all the Spices, SIM cards, salt, syringes, panadol, call to Mother and GF as well as Biryani etc for Pakistani connection that too during an undergoing Op, lasts more than a day and way before completion yet ended with humiliation. The same media (DGMO statement I think as well) found out Pakistani marking on weapons recovered in Uri incident yet ended with NIA report as no markings, further humiliation. Media claimed Pakistan isolated and no Pakistan-Russia exercises but further humiliation.
Then after line of control violation and an attempt to teach PA a lesson for Indian public consumption which caused heavy damage as well as further humiliation as soon as claimed as so-called strike. Now an unknown SP of SB and an I.G that has nothing to do with with such area now further humiliation. However, such claim of an I.G from Punjab, a failed attempt of Punjabi accent, SP of Special Branch from Kashmir, seems like an attempt to manipulate NS opposition within Pakistan to make them believe that NS being NaMO's best friend or his team is helping India out while maligning the credibility of officials yet ending in another humiliation as no such I.G or SP are relevant in this matter.

 

[Post Colonnial]

hey Pak posters...I caution you to be very careful and not make total asses of yourselves. I do not know if this story is real or false but if a journalist actually did a phone interview it is likely that there is a recording.

 

[sohailbarki]

hey Pak posters...I caution you to be very careful and not make total asses of yourselves. I do not know if this story is real or false but if a journalist actually did a phone interview it is likely that there is a recording.

Yes, there will be a recording which indian will have recorded through impersonator. SSP and IG usually have dozens of conversations and meetings and they know each other pretty well.

 

[graphican]

hey Pak posters...I caution you to be very careful and not make total asses of yourselves. I do not know if this story is real or false but if a journalist actually did a phone interview it is likely that there is a recording.

India has no credibility and it is getting more and more desperate to prove its point. This behavior is only natural and expected, so we totally get why India is producing these smokes.

But indian smoke is only making its face dark, and India is totally not getting it. Good!

 

[Post Colonnial]

India has no credibility and it is getting more and more desperate to prove its point. This behavior is only natural and expected, so we totally get why India is producing these smokes.

But indian smoke is only making its face dark, and India is totally not getting it. Good!

don't worry about Indian credibility. they have managed to push you guys down in the eyes of almost all countries by simply giving your generals some rope to hand themselves ! and then it is a simple matter of exposing that.

it is up to you to save your credibility ...

 

[xyxmt]

don't worry about Indian credibility. they have managed to push you guys down in the eyes of almost all countries by simply giving your generals some rope to hand themselves ! and then it is a simple matter of exposing that.

it is up to you to save your credibility ...

This is the best part, you people believe your media, only a 10 year old can believe that bullshit
which basically confirms that Indian are slave mentality due to centuries of outsider ruling them, they never quesiton authority and say Yes Sir on everything.

Pakistan today is more connected in the world than India and that too without our PM knocking at someone's door every week and making it rock star tamasha, you people are so screwed up by Bollywood you even make your PM's visit an Item Song.

 

[Imad.Khan]

hey Pak posters...I caution you to be very careful and not make total asses of yourselves. I do not know if this story is real or false but if a journalist actually did a phone interview it is likely that there is a recording.

And who are you to caution us, this forum is called Pakistan defence, if you don't like it then go make your own.