Why many Pakistanis view Indians as the monsters across the border

[Stephen Cohen]

Pakistan is 7 times smaller than india, yet we took a big portion of kashmir, opened up a vital route to China snd blocked india from central asia and Afghanistan

Tou cant do anything if you dont gave balls, its what indians always forget

You know ; IF you had NOT attacked Kashmir in 1947
you would have GOT the whole state in a few years

That Maharaja would have been ousted in a few years

But your haste and greed spoiled your chances

Similarly if you had NOT attacked India in 1965 ; India would Not have taken the
revenge in 1971

1971 was the revenge for 1965

 

[Zahoor Raja-Jani]

East Pakistan

Kid east Pakistan is pre decided thing by military and political leadership if today we have them we will be the most weak nation in entire world where country is in two parts and any time Indian can threat us to divide Pakistan so we decided to leave them as another independent Pakistan as u r military experts who curse Mrs Ghandhi for this.

 

[AMCA]

Let this discussion for proper thread who lost how much. Just ask any indian military professional about our strength. Who stop IA in 2002 to invade us..and now game is total change India develop cold start and spend billions and we put cold water on it with Nasr.
Now stop further derail.

Well you may ask any Pakistan military personnel and he will agree with me on the ground Pakistan lost in that very war. Nasr is a complete joke for a cold start as that would result in further nuclear attacks on Pakistan's territory.

Kid east Pakistan is pre decided thing by military and political leadership if today we have them we will be the most weak nation in entire world where country is in two parts and any time Indian can threat us to divide Pakistan so we decided to leave them as another independent Pakistan as u r military experts who curse Mrs Ghandhi for this.

baby!! Why did you go for war and get yourselves humiliated if the so cold political and military brass were gonna give up Bangladesh for good?

 

[Zahoor Raja-Jani]

Well you may ask any Pakistan military personnel and he will agree with me on the ground Pakistan lost in that very war. Nasr is a complete joke for a cold start as that would result in further nuclear attacks on Pakistan's territory.

But your military leadership does't agrees with you after boasting cols start for year now they are claiming they don't have such plan at all, its simply no exists in Indian military planing what a joke.

 

[AMCA]

During kargil indian military was a joke

It melted away as Pakistan forces punched through and occupied vital territory

If it wasent for the international pressure and our weak domestic politicians bowing to that pressure and restraining the military india would have been disgraced



And this is the sum total of indian/hindu bravery

Our forces were stuck 1000 miles away from home with a hostile local population and no supply lines

If only hindus had such favourable odds over the last 1000 years

Fear not the bengalis have done a admirable job of reducing the hindu population in Bangladesh

Lol so much for your failure to defend your land? why did you accept it if you cannot defend it?

 

[hussain0216]

You know ; IF you had NOT attacked Kashmir in 1947
you would have GOT the whole state in a few years

That Maharaja would have been ousted in a few years

But your haste and greed spoiled your chances

Similarly if you had NOT attacked India in 1965 ; India would Not have taken the
revenge in 1971

1971 was the revenge for 1965

Nonsense, look at the map

If india controls kashmir it juts out into the indian ocean has a direct link with Afghanistan and central Asia and Pakistan is stuch in between

The plan was always to deny kashmir to Pakistan even though it was a muslim majority state bordering us and sharing our faith and culture

It was through immense effort that we took vital parts of Kashmir linking us to China and blocking india from central asia

The rest of Kashmir is our right as a Muslim state





Bangladesh was always going to happen it was ungovernable as one state, india just took advantage its the only thing it can do as it dosent have the courage to attackPakistan

 

[Zahoor Raja-Jani]

Well you may ask any Pakistan military personnel and he will agree with me on the ground Pakistan lost in that very war. Nasr is a complete joke for a cold start as that would result in further nuclear attacks on Pakistan's territory.



baby!! Why did you go for war and get yourselves humiliated if the so cold political and military brass were gonna give up Bangladesh for good?

We did't opertunist Sam manik shah misguided the Mrs Ghandi for this adventure.

 

[AMCA]

But your military leadership does't agrees with you after boasting cols start for year now they are claiming they don't have such plan at all, its simply no exists in Indian military planing what a joke.

Really? May I know which military leader said so?

 

[Zahoor Raja-Jani]

Really? May I know which military leader said so?

Google it don't ask for spoon feeding its in the news many times where your political and military leadership deny this.

 

[AMCA]

We did't opertunist Sam manik shah misguided the Mrs Ghandi for this adventure.

We liberated your land and thats what counts. Now how inefficient your army or political brass were does not count for explanation.

 

[Zahoor Raja-Jani]

We liberated your land and thats what counts. Now how inefficient your army or political brass were does not count for explanation.

Now its time to leave it since you lost u r mind. have a good day.

 

[AMCA]

Google it don't ask for spoon feeding its in the news many times where your political and military leadership deny this.

Am not asking to be spoon fed, atleast not from you anyways. This is what your problem is, cannot defend or back up your claims.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Nonsense, look at the map

If india controls kashmir it juts out into the indian ocean has a direct link with Afghanistan and central Asia and Pakistan is stuch in between

The plan was always to deny kashmir to Pakistan even though it was a muslim majority state bordering us and sharing our faith and culture

It was through immense effort that we took vital parts of Kashmir linking us to China and blocking india from central asia

The rest of Kashmir is our right as a Muslim state





Bangladesh was always going to happen it was ungovernable as one state, india just took advantage its the only thing it can do as it dosent have the courage to attackPakistan

Are you aware that Jinnah REJECTED a DEAL over Kashmir

Patel had offered him a deal

Take Kashmir and Give up your claim to Hyderabad

Jinnah said he wanted Hyderabad

But he got nothing

The Terms and conditions of partition were very clear
States had the right to choose

The Kashmir Maharaja choose India only because and after you Attacked him

If you had been patient ; whole Kashmir would have come to you

 

[AMCA]

Now its time to leave it since you lost u r mind. have a good day.

Finally you found exit.. By bye..

 

[hussain0216]

Lol so much for your failure to defend your land? why did you accept it if you cannot defend it?

West Pakistan cant keep east pakistan if it didn't want to be one nation, it is is still a muslim majority state where hindus have been decimated, 1000 miles was simply a bridge too far


Even if we succeeded against all odds we would have had to give up east bangladesh it just wasent working as one state