What's new

Why is China interfering in Pakistan's domestic affairs ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay comrade so what's your problem with us bootlicking Chinese? If you're not strong in this world then your other option is to get backing from a stronger power to defend against a numerically stronger foe i.e. India, now that could change if Pakistan was a democratically stable country with a growing economy. Is Pakistan politically stable that it can attract investors from countries other then China? We are a nuclear country with polio and dengue fever rampant through parts of the country, any Mullah can wake up one day and start riots with his zombie followers so if you're a foreign investor watching the news Pakistan is the last place anyone would want to invest, we still have massive problem with poverty and you're questioning our boolicking habits. Maybe if we put our house in order we could one day start helping our ummah brothers but lets help our own ummah(Pakistanis) first.

Fair points and argument.

China should refrain from interfering in internal matters of Pakistan.



Not only that also the way Chinese dealt with Hong Kong protesters.

Folks in Hong Kong have seen nothing. Wait till Chinese lose their patience. It is going to worse than Tianamen square.
 
.
Sorry, I missed the tweet and I can't locate it on Google.
Would someone be kind enough to tell me what the tweet said.
Thanks in advance.
 
.
Everything sold to China even my Pakistani sisters got sold against there will to comfort aethiest bed .

Pti imran pmln nawaaz all the same sell off everything cheap

I rate how India deal with the Chinese and stick up middle finger at them
 
. .
Everything sold to China even my Pakistani sisters got sold against there will to comfort aethiest bed .

Pti imran pmln nawaaz all the same sell off everything cheap

I rate how India deal with the Chinese and stick up middle finger at them
That's how it works.
We give India the middle finger, the Indians give the Chinese the middle finger, the Chinese give the Americans the middle finger, the Americans give the middle finger to anyone they want.
The Indians aren't doing anything extraordinary or unique.
 
. . .
It just shows that PTI government is indeed incompetent compared to previous one.
Foreign policy cant be changed in year it required years to turn around... no one is intresting buying Pakistanies believe me cuz we keep garbage and those who are smart rich resourseful we export them willingly
Bas ilzam hi lagana hai tay lai jao..sanu ki!
 
.
Japan and Germany today are pivotal states. Both dominate global trade and exert massive influence. And carry enormous influence through soft power right across the globe. Everybody respects them. They respect them for fighting like true warriors. German/Japanes fighting ability is famous. After defeat they fought in peace just as bravely as they fought in war and today are rip roaring success stories. Some of the most developed, prosperous countries in the world. Just look at Pakistan roads. Everything decent that rolls on them is Japanese.


But Japan and Germany are world class because USA subsidizes their security concerns to the fullest extent..This means that the best USA engineers go to defence industries and not to consumer oriented industries..Whereas best engineers of Germany and Japan go to autombiles and electronics..I feel this is part of the reason why their products are top notch..But there is no taking away from the fact that Germany had BMW,Mercedes Benz,Porsche Audi (Auto Union) even before the war...and Japan remains the first non-white country to defeat a white superpower in full on modern war...1905
 
.
first non-white country to defeat a white superpower in full on modern war...1905
And how did they do that?

  • go full westoxified?
  • go full desified?
Then we have the other case in modern times of a "non-white" country defeating European hegemony. Tha was Ataturk in 1919. What did he do?

  • go full westoxified?
  • go full desified?

Something to think about it.
 
.
Ataturk is white..... so are rest of the Turks who are nothing but Turkified Greek. What are you smoking over there?

China interferes in Pakistan because it can. Expect more of that later on as China becomes richer and powerful.
 
.
Ataturk is white..... so are rest of the Turks who are nothing but Turkified Greek. What are you smoking over there?

China interferes in Pakistan because it can. Expect more of that later on as China becomes richer and powerful.

Whole subcontinent have been slaves for centuries.. It is just recently they have achieved so called freedom... It will take another decades/centuries for them to realize and stand on their own feet. Till then , it is either going to US / China.
 
.
And how did they do that?

  • go full westoxified?
  • go full desified?
Then we have the other case in modern times of a "non-white" country defeating European hegemony. Tha was Ataturk in 1919. What did he do?

  • go full westoxified?
  • go full desified?

Something to think about it.

Well in case of Japan they completely whitified themselves in a matter of exactly 52 years. Not only they embraced Western rationalism, Western Evidence based thinking but they took in lock,stock and barrel Western culture as well. Even now Japanese are some of the greatest connossieurs of Western clothing and Western Classical Music. Yamaha is world's greatest producer of Western style grand pianos,guitars along with of course some very fine racing motorcycles. The bombing of their ports and bay in 1853 by Col Percy put them in an existential crisis. Interestingly China was also put in an existential crisis a few decades before by the West through its Opium Wars. Both China and Japan started to modernize.

China tried by lurching towards republicanism (devolving the power of the monarch)
Japan tried by strengthening absolute monarchy

May be there is some lesson in there for other non-white countries.

But in the end Japan succeeded and China failed. Why?

I have some strong opinions on this, and to borrow your term the latent desification of 19th century China was an order of magnitude more than that was present in Japan. By latent desification I mean absurd respect for the supernatural

1) Even in 1900 during the Boxer Rebellion,the Chinese thought that their Taoist powers would make them impervious to Western weapons. One can very well imagine how the Rebellion fared against Western Powers

2) Japan had a better understanding of reality and progress of history. Almost Graeco-Roman in spirit. Case in point: By the 19th century ,Japan already had meticulous record keeping of Sumo tournaments in the order of a few hundred years

3) The supernatural element in Japanese religious texts (I have read a few translations) is extremely reduced.


4) Of course the West itself got whitified when they shook off Christianity and embraced Modern secular rationalism in the 1700s........
from 300 AD to 1700 AD, West itself was reeling under an ideology that was foreign to their soul. Greek philosophy and Roman ingenuity is the true Inheritance of the West.

There is a reason why Aurangzeb could defeat the Europeans in the 1600s..But the Mughals,Marathas,Tipus,Sikhs and other powerful Muslim and Hindu dynasties could not do the same in the 1700s and 1800s. The change that the European soul was undergoing was rapid


5) But I would say all is not bad regarding Christianity. Christianity kept racism in check in the Christendom.Racial supremacist theories are more of a natural consequence of Graeco-Roman urge to slice and dice nature under the umbrella of taxonomy.Whereas St. Paul's and Islam's message is that of universalism. (no Jew,no Roman,no Ethiopian under Christ sermon....)


6) I feel Atatürk also violently pursued this same policy of rationalism and secularism and he remains an enigma. Even Germans to this day have quiet respect for him and make lavish documentaries regarding him on German state television stations (most probably to piss the more religious minded Turks off)...That modern-day Turkey managed over 700 years to keep itself from getting run over by invaders, inspite of not being an island,is something that needs close study from geo-politics enthusiasts (saving the 12 year interregnum at the hands of Timur, who tortured the Turkish sultan and reportedly raped his wife and daughter)
 
Last edited:
.
Well in case of Japan they completely whitified themselves in a matter of exactly 52 years. Not only they embraced Western rationalism, Western Evidence based thinking but they took in lock,stock and barrel Western culture as well. Even now Japanese are some of the greatest connossieurs of Western clothing and Western Classical Music. Yamaha is world's greatest producer of Western style grand pianos,guitars along with of course some very fine racing motorcycles. The bombing of their ports and bay in 1853 by Col Percy put them in an existential crisis. Interestingly China was also put in an existential crisis a few decades before by the West through its Opium Wars. Both China and Japan started to modernize.

China tried by lurching towards republicanism (devolving the power of the monarch)
Japan tried by strengthening absolute monarchy

May be there is some lesson in there for other non-white countries.

But in the end Japan succeeded and China failed. Why?

I have some strong opinions on this, and to borrow your term the latent desification of 19th century China was an order of magnitude more than that was present in Japan. By latent desification I mean absurd respect for the supernatural

1) Even in 1900 during the Boxer Rebellion,the Chinese thought that their Taoist powers would make them impervious to Western weapons. One can very well imagine how the Rebellion fared against Western Powers

2) Japan had a better understanding of reality and progress of history. Almost Graeco-Roman in spirit. Case in point: By the 19th century ,Japan already had meticulous record keeping of Sumo tournaments in the order of a few hundred years

3) The supernatural element in Japanese religious texts (I have read a few translations) is extremely reduced.


4) Of course the West itself got whitified when they shook off Christianity and embraced Modern secular rationalism in the 1700s........
from 300 AD to 1700 AD, West itself was reeling under an ideology that was foreign to their soul. Greek philosophy and Roman ingenuity is the true Inheritance of the West.

There is a reason why Aurangzeb could defeat the Europeans in the 1600s..But the Mughals,Marathas,Tipus,Sikhs and other powerful Muslim and Hindu dynasties could not do the same in the 1700s and 1800s. The change that the European soul was undergoing was rapid


5) But I would say all is not bad regarding Christianity. Christianity kept racism in check in the Christendom.Racial supremacist theories are more of a natural consequence of Graeco-Roman urge to slice and dice nature under the umbrella of taxonomy.Whereas St. Paul's and Islam's message is that of universalism. (no Jew,no Roman,no Ethiopian under Christ sermon....)


6) I feel Atatürk also violently pursued this same policy of rationalism and secularism and he remains an enigma. Even Germans to this day have quiet respect for him and make lavish documentaries regarding him on German state television stations (most probably to piss the more religious minded Turks off)...That modern-day Turkey managed over 700 years to keep itself from getting run over by invaders, inspite of not being an island,is something that needs close study from geo-politics enthusiasts (saving the 12 year interregnum at the hands of Timur, who tortured the Turkish sultan and reportedly raped his wife and daughter)
Fantastic post. 10/10

Ataturk is white
This is not about -

  • white
  • brown
  • yellow
  • red
  • black
This is more to do with modernism and socio-political orders that provide the formula for success. Japanese are not white but were the first as stated by @Juggernaut_is_here to westernize [modernize] themselves and defeated a white country - Russia in 1905. They did so by copying the west and beating them with their own medicine. The purged themselves of their own'desi' society by bringing widespread reforms that laid the making of a westoxified Japan. Incidentally many Persians, Tajiks, Afghans and some Pakistani's are as white if not more whiter then Turks but that is not what informs success. If that was the case Japan would be no where and Greece would be a superpower. The reality is the reverse. Greece is a begger country.
 
.
This is more to do with modernism and socio-political orders that provide the formula for success. Japanese are not white but were the first as stated by @Juggernaut_is_here to westernize [modernize] themselves and defeated a white country - Russia in 1905. They did so by copying the west and beating them with their own medicine. The purged themselves of their own'desi' society by bringing widespread reforms that laid the making of a westoxified Japan. Incidentally many Persians, Tajiks, Afghans and some Pakistani's are as white if not more whiter then Turks but that is not what informs success. If that was the case Japan would be no where and Greece would be a superpower. The reality is the reverse. Greece is a begger country.
Then you should use the word "European", "Western European" etc. You just said non-White country but majority of Turks are white so it doesn't make any sense.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom