I guess this argument can go on and on.
There are no real proofs to prove or disprove, only the motives are established and evident in the bitter animosity which the two countries have been engaged in.
The fact remains that India is the most hostile country to Pakistan.
The fact remains that India is cutting off the water supply of Pakistan in a systematic fashion and the weaker the Pakistan state becomes the stronger a position India will be in to dismiss any objections Pakistan has on this most critical flash point.
I am saying this keeping in mind the population of the two mighty neighbors, their demand for electricity and agricultural requirements which all of you people should understand...do take a moment to realize what it shall imply to deprive Pakistan of such a resource which actually is life itself...I see a terrible and most horrible war for resources and certainly India knows it as well...perhaps it also drives India to have a weak and destabilized neighbor which is too deep in the proverbial S H I T to actually have a coherent plan to take on India in a peaceful yet aggressive manner (backed by military/diplomatic pressure) and negotiate a proper settlement.
The fact remains that India and Pakistan are not over the issue of Kashmir even despite a sincere effort by Pakistan (against the wishes of many people) to curb down on Kashmir militant groups, do we need absolute zero crime rate etc. in Kashmir to ensure that India also tries to cool down in its tone with Pakistan?
There is no such thing as absolute peace and heavenly crime free zone which Pakistan can ensure in Kashmir...either accept Pakistan's efforts and truly walk down the road of understanding or let us declare that we shall remain enemies forever...The way i see it is that Pakistan is looked down upon by India and India is always lobbying against Pakistan even on trivial issues, this is what i genuinely feel over the past 10-15 years when i look at all the issues, conflicts and statements on the global stage.
Mind you this statement comes from a person who is quite open to the idea of this elusive peaceful coexistence which we all seek, however i say this much...death before disgrace!
Even a most prosperous state like US was hit by its own avenging son timothy in Oklahoma so please do not pretend that all of India's problems originate in Pakistan and have nothing to do with internal issues, there are all sorts of issues and people in every country...certainly seeing the TTP and their atrocities, i am convinced that there has to be peace between India and Pakistan for any long term stability in this region.
If we truly want stability then we should have had a much more mature relationship by now but that is not the case...India was all too willing to go to war at least twice in the recent decade and thank god that Pakistan had the nukes otherwise i am sure we would have seen just how mature even India is when dealing with Pakistan.
You may conclude that i am bashing India here but my point is very simple...despite being a large democracy having great stability and peaceful intent, India does indeed never miss a chance to threaten and ridicule Pakistan on all fronts...
The nuclear tests, the recent mobilization of our armies...all were in the backdrop of quite aggressive posture and all encompassing threats...
do you really not see that being the smaller country Pakistan can never ever take these threats lightly?
I am just trying to make a point that so far India has just been giving lip service when it comes to peace with Pakistan whereas Pakistan did indeed change its policy on Kashmir...so we shall dance this dance till the tune changes and for that India also needs to show some faith and do something concrete.