Why India has never seen a military dictatorship.

[pakdefender]

Geographic proximity to both Pakistan and China

Also the states are first line of defence for New Delhi.

Above map is incorrect , following is correct

 

[Crixus]

You can take Kashmir only in maps enjoy it and Congrats

Above map is incorrect , following is correct

View attachment 318493

 

[pakdefender]

You can take Kashmir only in maps enjoy it and Congrats

Tum indian log , chalakiyan dikhatay hu by posting maps that are incorrect , you think , as in indian you can come to Muzaffarabad if it is part of india as shown in your maps ? get real

The real delusional fools are you indians , actually in reality Kashmir is yours on maps and on paper only

 

[Crixus]

Who knows future in 1960s same thing can be said about Dhaka for Indians and we are not interested in Pakistani Occupied Kashmir .keep it and be happy

Tum indian log , chalakiyan dikhatay hu by posting maps that are incorrect , you think , as in indian you can come to Muzaffarabad if it is part of india as shown in your maps ? get real

The real delusional fools are you indians , actually in reality Kashmir is yours on maps and on paper only

 

[Śakra]

Above map is incorrect , following is correct

View attachment 318493

Lol 1st Kashmir, now pakistan is claiming Hindu Jammu and Buddhist Ladakh?!?! What next, Sikh Punjab and Adivasi MP?

 

[Crixus]

They can even claim Australia , NZ and Spain ..haven't you heard that literacy rate is going down in our neighborhood

Lol 1st Kashmir, now pakistan is claiming Hindu Jammu and Buddhist Ladakh?!?! What next, Sikh Punjab and Adivasi MP?

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

the armed forces are seperated and its for he reason to avoids coups. as opposed to most countries where they are all joined.
so if hypothetically the indian army started a coup the navy and airforce would still be there to prevent it

Not like that. India is huge. Military in itself has 5 commands. Its impossible to take head of every command in coup plans. Secondly, Delhi is not India. Capturing PM alone in a coup has no value. Until unless, you capture 30 states Chief Ministers and their ministers and put them under house arrests. Arresting someone like Jaya, Mamata, Chandra Babu Naidu will bring lots of people into streets, uncontrollable mobs. How many people can Army kill?

Killing people will fail the coup itself. India is huge. Its a advantage. The only ever possibility of India being in a dictatorship was the presence of Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose. Indian people would never think twice of installing him as their king, even 10 years of Nehru rule.

 

[greenwood]

Not like that. India is huge. Military in itself has 5 commands. Its impossible to take head of every command in coup plans. Secondly, Delhi is not India. Capturing PM alone in a coup has no value. Until unless, you capture 30 states Chief Ministers and their ministers and put them under house arrests. Arresting someone like Jaya, Mamata, Chandra Babu Naidu will bring lots of people into streets, uncontrollable mobs. How many people can Army kill?

Killing people will fail the coup itself. India is huge. Its a advantage. The only ever possibility of India being in a dictatorship was the presence of Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose. Indian people would never think twice of installing him as their king, even 10 years of Nehru rule.

Military in itself has 5 commands? How to operate 5 commands at the same time!

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Military in itself has 5 commands? How to operate 5 commands at the same time!

There are Generals above them who co-ordinate things. Like provincial ministers headed by Prime Minister.
Plus, there are paramilitary wings, Navy, Air Force, State Police forces whose responsibility is towards State government.

 

[MilSpec]

The Nation of India governs the Military, unlike Pakistani Military that governs the nation.

Not like that. India is huge. Military in itself has 5 commands. Its impossible to take head of every command in coup plans. Secondly, Delhi is not India. Capturing PM alone in a coup has no value. Until unless, you capture 30 states Chief Ministers and their ministers and put them under house arrests. Arresting someone like Jaya, Mamata, Chandra Babu Naidu will bring lots of people into streets, uncontrollable mobs. How many people can Army kill?

Killing people will fail the coup itself. India is huge. Its a advantage. The only ever possibility of India being in a dictatorship was the presence of Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose. Indian people would never think twice of installing him as their king, even 10 years of Nehru rule.

It also has to do culture and discipline.
Indian Military knows it's mandate, and does what it is supposed to do. Power Hunger has never been in the culture of the armed forces. Their salvation and pride is in the battle field, not in closed corridors of New Delhi.

 

[Apprentice]

The Nation of India governs the Military, unlike Pakistani Military that governs the nation.

It also has to do culture and discipline.
Indian Military knows it's mandate, and does what it is supposed to do. Power Hunger has never been in the culture of the armed forces. Their salvation and pride is in the battle field, not in closed corridors of New Delhi.

False. its pride is in raping Muslim women.

Go read Sunder Lal Committee Report about what your army did to Muslim women and people in Hyderabad (Operation Polo)

 

[greenwood]

There are Generals above them who co-ordinate things. Like provincial ministers headed by Prime Minister.
Plus, there are paramilitary wings, Navy, Air Force, State Police forces whose responsibility is towards State government.

"There are Generals above them....."
Do India has position like Commander-in-chief?

 

[MilSpec]

"There are Generals above them....."
Do India has position like Commander-in-chief?

The President of India is the Commander in Chief of all forces.

 

[greenwood]

The President of India is the Commander in Chief of all forces.

President is symbol / formal chief, who is actually commanding all forces in India?

 

[kaykay]

"There are Generals above them....."
Do India has position like Commander-in-chief?

Each command is under a Lt. Gen....COAS( chief of army staff) is the one whom they all reports.