Why I am not against granting citizenship to Banghalese / Biharise while opposing Afghans.

[hussain0216]

Bengalis who chose Pakistan over the traitors in Bangladesh are fine

How can we deny them citizenship


The Afghani's are simply disloyal, we cant feed disloyal snakes

 

[Maarkhoor]

Take them to Punjab and KPK, that's what Sindhi and Baloch nationalists wants. Sitting in islamabad completely oblivious to the sentiments of provinces was not enough that they want to make policies for other provinces? Sindhi and Baloch are becoming minority in their own provinces. The decision was unnecessary and will fuel regionalism, provincialism.

I am from Sialkot and we gave our own land to Biharese, go and check there is huge Bihari colony in my city.

 

[Crystal-Clear]

afghans shouldn't be given nationality at any cost they were refugees and they hate us from the bottom of their hearts .

 

[Max]

I am from Sialkot and we gave our own land to Biharese, go and check there is huge Bihari colony in my city.

Tell this to Sindhi and Baloch..

We need to end the provinces.

It will not resolve the issue, in Sindh it will rather cause civil war.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

It will not resolve the issue, in Sindh it will rather cause civil war.

I think there is a danger that Sindh could see a civil war in the future between the Israeli style settlers who think they blessed the land and the native 'Arabs' who are regarded as backward etc and are on way to become minority in their own land.

That is why Gwadar is vital to give norther Pakistan options of alternative routes for im/export. And importing Bihari's or Banglas is equivalent to Israel importing Ethopian Jews to change the demography in their favour making natives a tiny minority. Interstingly religion is the excuse used.

 

[Max]

I think there is a danger that Sindh could see a civil war in the future between the Israeli style settlers who think they blessed the land and the native 'Arabs' who are regarded as backward etc and are on way to become minority in their own land.

But Sialkot accepted 2000 Bihari

 

[Azadkashmir]

Do you worship I.K? I think so otherwise no Pakistani agree to grant citizenship to filthiest scums of this planet earth.

We used to have Afghan mazaras due to cheap labor and hard work but what they have started in my village, bringing charas, heroin and started to addict local farmers, further one of them harass our female villagers and what we decided to throw them all from our area...my father and other elders announced if anyone trade with them or even gave their house on rent we will throw them out as well and as a result now we have zero Afghani scum in my area and we repeated in out town as well and successfully made it Afghan free.

I like the fact everybody got together to do something especially not trade,, here in azad Kashmir they ripp you off if you not one of them , sorry to say i find them behaving like je ws.

 

[Maarkhoor]

And importing Bihari's or Banglas is equivalent to Israel importing Ethopian Jews to change the demography in their favour making natives a tiny minority.

No one is importing them since they are already living in Pakistan.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

No one is importing them since they are already living in Pakistan.

Yeh of course. Every one of those from India and Bangla arrived before 1950 !

 

[Maarkhoor]

Yeh of course. Every one of those from India and Bangla arrived before 1950 !

Very few of them arrive later as illegal immigrants and we shall deport them but not Biharis or those Bengalise who choose Pakistan over Bangladesh.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Very few of them arrive later as illegal immigrants and we shall deport them but not Biharis or those Bengalise who choose Pakistan over Bangladesh.

First of all majority of Banglas in Karachi are post 1971. In fact mostly 1980s/90s. Under Gen. Zia significant migration took place from India/Bangla in a attempt to offset PPP in Sindh. This was when Gen. Zia nurtured MQM as a riposte to PPP. MQM brough in many thugs from India. Indian connection is well recorded and even RAW was involved. But of course you don't see any of this. Fact is they all hide under the pretext of the original wave of migrants and there is not much you can do to differantiate.

And if you ask any of these people of course they are going to sing pro-Pakistan songs.

 

[Maarkhoor]

First of all majority of Banglas in Karachi are post 1971. In fact mostly 1980s/90s. Under Gen. Zia significant migration took place from India/Bangla in a attempt to offset PPP in Sindh. This was when Gen. Zia nurtured MQM as a riposte to PPP. MQM brough in many thugs from India. Indian connection is well recorded and even RAW was involved. But of course you don't see any of this. Fact is they all hide under the pretext of the original wave of migrants and there is not much you can do to differantiate.

And if you ask any of these people of course they are going to sing pro-Pakistan songs.

So what you suggest? your own P.M wanted to gave them citizenship even those who openly do terrorism and involved in all type of crimes aka filthiest Afghan scums. I just agreed with I.K over Behari and Genuine Bangali immigrants.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

So what you suggest? your own P.M wanted to gave them citizenship even those who openly do terrorism and involved in all type of crimes aka filthiest Afghan scums. I just agreed with I.K over Behari and Genuine Bangali immigrants.

I don't have time but I will make case later to show you that Afghans have directly or indirectly done more for Pakistan then those vile, traitor Banglas that humiliated 90,000 of our people. Nothing and I mean nothing comes close to that infamy.

 

[Maarkhoor]

I don't have time but I will make case later to show you that Afghans have directly or indirectly done more for Pakistan then those vile, traitor Banglas that humiliated 90,000 of our people. Nothing and I mean nothing comes close to that infamy.

Lols bro because of Afghan scums we lost 700000 people including children in recent years but as per you posts on other thread you are quite ok to grant them citizenship.....

 

[TMA]

Afghans should be given citizenship on the basis that they renounce their afghan one and pledge allegiance to Pakistan.

Not enough. Prove it. Military service.

You can call me a libtard, but I still think they are humans and most of them are like this because they are disenfranchised.

If you enfranchise them, they will become model citizens.

Again, on the condition that they renounce their afghan citizenship

What foolish thoughts!

Have you met Afghans who are well established in the UK who came via Pakistan?
The venom they have for Pakistan despite being married to Pakistani Pukhtoon girls?

Money does not buy love. Passports do not buy Patriotism.

At worst we are subhumans who deserved to be ruled from Kabul and best just neutral.

Honestly ask yourself this: Another border skirmish between Afghanistan and Pakistan, where do you think the loyalties will lie?

Of course I agree with you they are human.

If we can bear millions of afghanis for 30 years, then we can also bear their citizenship. It will reduce crime rate too. They are already spread everywhere. Anyway few of them already got ID cards legally through illegal ways.
Even many labours age like 50, 60 years old spent half of life in Pakistan. We should give them citizenship.

Nope it won’t. It will embolden anti state parties/elements. This will cause bigger problems than petty theft and the like...

Those who gotten it illegally, can be investigated and invalidated.