Why I am not against granting citizenship to Banghalese / Biharise while opposing Afghans.

[Maarkhoor]

Why I am not against granting citizenship to Banghalese / Biharise while opposing Afghans.

1. Bangladeshi were Pakistanis and choose to stay Pakistanis even after the creation of Bangladesh and they never involved in anti Pakistan activities.
2. Biharise were and are as much Pakistan as I am they gave their lives in Bangladesh for Pakistan they must be granted Pakistani citizenship.


3. Afghans are refugees and no nation on this planet earth gave citizenship to refugees, they are meant to stay in country for temporary basis. Further Afghan hate Pakistan and the last nation on this world who accept Pakistan as a state, they involved in heinous crimes in Pakistan from drug trafficking to terrorism...they don't accept Afghan-Pakistan border etc.....

@django @DESERT FIGHTER @Burhan Wani @Arsalan

 

[Rusty]

Afghans should be given citizenship on the basis that they renounce their afghan one and pledge allegiance to Pakistan.

 

[Maarkhoor]

Afghans should be given citizenship on the basis that they renounce their afghan one and pledge allegiance to Pakistan.

They are filthiest scums of this planet earth and they will remain and we should send them back to hell hole from where they belong.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Afghans should be given citizenship on the basis that they renounce their afghan one and pledge allegiance to Pakistan.

as long as Afghanistan exists as a political entity their loyalty will always be in question

 

[Umair Nawaz]

kaka g giving citizenship to anyone right now must be opposed for economic reasons and for the lack of jobs we already have. giving nationalities for more people means more hungry mouths to feed....Its not a good idea.

One needs to realize that we not economically stable and hence no secured jobs. Heck our unemployment rate is already high, and thats for the proper pakistani citizens, now after giving nationalities to bangalis and Afghans, where u think we will create jobs for them from? Some people are trying to justify it by looking at it from the prism of security only, but even that too is a great gamble itself. There is simply no guarantee that after giving them ID cards they will suddenly become loyal citizens of pakistan. These r non integrated groups and shall remain so and hence will always hamper our social stability, political stability and hence economic stability. And also this will hamper our overall unity as a nation too. Havnt we learnt anything by those muhajirs of karachi? thats another non integrated group whom also we adopted out of emotions and islam, and what has that experiment led us to? I mean these afghans, bangalis or these muhajirs or beharis share nothing in common with us. And by ''us'' i mean we, the indigenous people of pakistan, who have been settled in this land since centuries and r now 100% indigenous. Would we still have to wait for more centuries to completely integrate them? and these r the kharante pathans, they actually dont like us. They r uncivilized and jahil junglis to their core! That Mohsin Dawar, Manzoor Pashteen, ANP and AMP of balochistan types. What we need to do is do everything we can to ensure they no longer r able to live in pakistan. Block then economically and socially so they r encouraged to leave this country, and if that also dont work, simply kick them out by force like israelis did a year ago with their african refugees. This way we can kill 2 birds with one stone, ie security threat that u said can be neutralized that way and our severe economic burden these people have on our economy can be relieved. If the entire world specially those western countries, which r economically and academically more profound then us r doing this, then there is a reason for that, a bloody good reason. Keep the emotions aside and yr yr head for once.

 

[Rusty]

They are filthiest scums of this planet earth and they will remain and we should send them back to hell hole from where they belong.

You can call me a libtard, but I still think they are humans and most of them are like this because they are disenfranchised.

If you enfranchise them, they will become model citizens.

Again, on the condition that they renounce their afghan citizenship

 

[baapu]

kaka g giving citizenship to anyone right now must be opposed for economic reasons and for the lack of jobs we already have. giving nationalities for more people means more hungry mouths to feed....Its not a good idea.

One needs to realize that we not economically stable and hence no secured jobs. Heck our unemployment rate is already high, and thats for the proper Pakistani citizens, now after giving nationalities to bangalis and Afghans, where u think we will create jobs for them from? Some people are trying to justify it by looking at it from the prism of security only, but even that too is a great gamble itself. There is simply no guarantee that after giving them ID cards they will suddenly become loyal citizens of pakistan. These r non integrated groups and shall remain so and hence will always hamper our social stability, political stability and hence economic stability. And also this will hamper our overall unity as a nation too. Havnt we learnt anything by those muhajirs of karachi? thats another non integrated group whom also we adopted out of emotions and islam, and what has that experiment led us to? I mean these afghans, bangalis or these muhajirs or beharis share nothing in common with us. And by ''us'' i mean we, the indigenous people of pakistan, who have been settled in this land since centuries and r now 100% indigenous. Would we still have to wait for more centuries to completely integrate them? and these r the kharante pathans, they actually dont like us. They r uncivilized and jahil junglis to their core! That Mohsin Dawar, Manzoor Pashteen, ANP and AMP of balochistan types. What we need to do is do everything we can to ensure they no longer r able to live in pakistan. Block then economically and socially so they r encouraged to leave this country, and if that also dont work, simply kick them out by force like israelis did a year ago with their african refugees. This way we can kill 2 birds with one stone, ie security threat that u said can be neutralized that way and our severe economic burden these people have on our economy can be relieved. If the entire world specially those western countries, which r economically and academically more profound then us r doing this, then there is a reason for that, a bloody good reason. Keep the emotions aside and yr yr head for once.

lack of jobs, has nothing to do with the population numbers. If it was true , no country in the West would would ever have immigration.
Most of these residents already have a job or source of income so this argument is completely invalid in that respect.

 

[RealNapster]

Afghans should be given citizenship on the basis that they renounce their afghan one and pledge allegiance to Pakistan.

Just this morning. I went to the market where we have shops. And afghanis were like “haan bhai... kaisa dia kal rawt ? ... ni dia acha ? Hay barwo”””

They were celebrating Indian victory

 

[Kabira]

Why I am not against granting citizenship to Banghalese / Biharise while opposing Afghans.

1. Bangladeshi were Pakistanis and choose to stay Pakistanis even after the creation of Bangladesh and they never involved in anti Pakistan activities.
2. Biharise were and are as much Pakistan as I am they gave their lives in Bangladesh for Pakistan they must be granted Pakistani citizenship.


3. Afghans are refugees and no nation on this planet earth gave citizenship to refugees, they are meant to stay in country for temporary basis. Further Afghan hate Pakistan and the last nation on this world who accept Pakistan as a state, they involved in heinous crimes in Pakistan from drum trafficking to terrorism...they don't accept Afghan-Pakistan border etc.....

@django @DESERT FIGHTER @Burhan Wani @Arsalan

Bengolis are post 71 migrants. Biharis of east Pakistan that migrated still don't have citizenship?

Anyway Sindh is opposed to giving citizenship to afghanis and bengolis. Basically its not happening for either of them.

 

[Maarkhoor]

Bengolis are post 71 migrants. Biharis of east Pakistan that migrated still don't have citizenship?

Anyway Sindh is opposed to giving citizenship to afghanis and bengolis. Basically its not happening for either of them.

Banghalese and Biharis who choose to stay Pakistanis must be granted citizenship, Afghans are in million while other two in thousands and quite loyal to Pakistan.

 

[Kabira]

Banghalese and Biharis who choose to stay Pakistanis must be granted citizenship, Afghans are in million while other two in thousands and quite loyal to Pakistan.

Biharis sure but bengolis are post 71 migrants, not those who decided to stay. Thats what they claim. Like afghanis claim they have been in Pakistan before 1979 to get CNIC. But problem is it will be like opening pandora box hence thousands of bengolis will not get citizenship just to not give millions of afghanis citizenship.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

They are filthiest scums of this planet earth and they will remain and we should send them back to hell hole from where they belong.

what i dont understand is why all of a sudden there is a lot of love for Afghans, why there past transgressions are being forgiven/forgotten.Are we gonna pretend that the pre soviet afghan war Afghanistan's hostility toward Pakistan didn't happen.People who have never interacted with afghans have become experts on them.There is one thing i m sure about now is people here are not loyal to the state but to their political leadership be they are from PTI,PPP,or PMLN etc

 

[Maarkhoor]

what i dont understand is why all of a sudden there is a lot of love for Afghans, why there past transgressions are being forgiven/forgotten.Are we gonna pretend that the pre soviet afghan war Afghanistan's hostility toward Pakistan didn't happen.People who have never interacted with afghans have become experts on them.There is one thing i sure about now is people here are not loyal to the state but to their political leadership be they are from PTI,PPP,or PMLN etc

Pitiyans worship I.K like cult leader and to defend his idiotic actions they can stoop to any level.

Biharis sure but bengolis are post 71 migrants, not those who decided to stay. Thats what they claim. Like afghanis claim they have been in Pakistan before 1979 to get CNIC. But problem is it will be like opening pandora box hence thousands of bengolis will not get citizenship just to not give millions of afghanis citizenship.

Yes post 71 should not allowed to reside without visa in Pakistan.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Just this morning. I went to the market where we have shops. And afghanis were like “haan bhai... kaisa dia kal rawt ? ... ni dia acha ? Hay barwo”””

They were celebrating Indian victory

Those of us who truly know and understand their rotten harm khor mindset will never even think of granting them citizenship.
And those who want to give them political ammunition to cause discord in the motherland just need to meet them and talk them in person they will learn their folly.

 

[Sugarcane]

Bengalis who chose Pakistan over Bangladesh already have/had Pakistani citizenship, ones who are currently illegal are those who came much later as economic migrants.